Blog

The Trenton Pork Roll Festival and its 2015 split

From the first festival on May 24, 2014 to the rival events of 2015 and the cancelled 2020 edition, how Trenton came to host two competing pork roll parties.

The organizers of the first Pork Roll Festival in Trenton spent $50 on advertising. They expected a crowd of locals who liked the product. On Saturday, May 24, 2014, more than 4,000 people showed up at a restaurant in the city, ate hundreds of pounds of the stuff, crowned a Miss Pork Roll Queen and ran short of food. A supplier had to bring in 20 more cases. By the end of the day the event was a hit, and a year later it was two events.

That is the short version of one of the stranger local-festival stories in New Jersey. It starts with a delicious idea, moves through a dispute over venue and name, and ends with rival celebrations a short walk apart, each insisting on being the real one. It is also a useful case study in what happens when something succeeds faster than its organizers planned.

The first festival, May 24, 2014

Pork roll has been made in Trenton since 1856, and by the twenty-first century it was the city's best-loved export. The first Pork Roll Festival was held at a Trenton restaurant on May 24, 2014. The turnout of more than 4,000 was far above what the organizers had prepared for, and the food ran out. Case Pork Roll, one of the two companies that make the product in the city, delivered 20 more cases to keep the grills going.

The program had the elements that have become the festival's trademarks: sandwiches in volume, a contest for royalty and a crowd that treated the whole thing as a civic celebration. The Miss Pork Roll Queen crown is the sort of detail that tells you how the organizers saw it, as a warm, slightly absurd tribute to a food that most New Jerseyans take seriously and a few take too seriously. John Taylor of Trenton and the 1856 ham tells the product's origin, and George Washington Case and the Belle Mead roll the other company's.

2015: two festivals

The second year was where the trouble began. The organizers disagreed over where to hold the event and how large it should be. One side argued that the restaurant that had hosted the first festival was too small for the crowd the festival now drew. The other side wanted to stay where it had started.

The result was that the festival split. One group held a "Trenton Pork Roll Festival 2015" at the original restaurant. The other held an "Official 2nd Annual Pork Roll Festival" at Mill Hill Park, a public park in downtown Trenton. Both were scheduled for the same date. Press reports at the time described lawyers getting involved, and one of the sides was reported to have received a cease-and-desist letter. Both events went ahead anyway.

It made national news. National outlets, including public radio, covered the story of two rival pork roll festivals in a single city. In the same year there was also a Vegan Pork Roll Festival at a community garden on East Hanover Street in the city. And the Trenton Thunder baseball team hosted a pork roll eating championship, which Joey Chestnut won by eating 32 four-ounce sandwiches in ten minutes.

What each side said

The record supports a few plain statements about the positions, without needing to take a side.

  • The Mill Hill Park organizers said the original venue was too small for what they wanted to do. Their festival was held in a public park with room for a large crowd, and it used the word "Official" in its name.
  • The restaurant organizers stayed at the original site and used the name "Trenton Pork Roll Festival."
  • The lawyers exchanged letters. A cease-and-desist letter was reported, and both events went ahead.

Neither festival disappeared. By 2016, two pork roll festivals were taking place in Trenton at the same time, and the rivalry continued in the years after. In 2019, the sixth annual Official Pork Roll Festival was held at Mill Hill Park, and the city also celebrated its Trenton Pork Roll Festival not far away.

The park and its history

Mill Hill Park sits in downtown Trenton near Assunpink Creek, the stream where Washington's army held off the British on the evening of January 2, 1777, in the days between the Battle of Trenton and the Battle of Princeton. A festival devoted to a breakfast meat is an odd tenant for ground with that history, and it is also a reminder of how many layers Trenton has. The same few blocks hold the story of a Revolutionary War crossing, the state government, a ceramics-and-steel industrial past and a processed-pork product. The crossing, Trenton and Princeton: December 25, 1776 to January 3, 1777 tells the campaign, and a walk through the neighborhood shows how close together these things are. trenton: a walk around the capital follows that route.

The arithmetic of a crowd

The numbers in the first festival's story are small and large at once. The organizers spent $50 on advertising and drew more than 4,000 people, which works out to about a penny and a quarter per visitor. That is a sign of how much of the draw was word of mouth and how little was marketing.

The food math is just as striking. Say each of those 4,000 visitors ate one sandwich made from four ounces of pork roll, the size used in the later eating contest. That is 16,000 ounces, or 1,000 pounds. The reported figure was hundreds of pounds, so the real consumption was lower per person than in this example, but the order of magnitude is clear: a festival at this scale consumes a large amount of a single food in a single afternoon. It is why a supplier had to deliver 20 more cases, and why anyone planning a food event at that size has to arrange supply well ahead.

There is an irony in a dispute over who owns a festival name when the product's own name was settled in court more than a century earlier. In 1910, a federal judge ruled that "pork roll" could not be trademarked, since it was a description of a kind of food. The same logic, in general terms, applies to the festival: the words "pork roll festival" describe an event and are not easy for any single organizer to own. What a festival can build is a reputation, and the qualifiers in the two names, "Official" at the park and "Trenton" at the restaurant, are the way each side tried to claim one. This is general information about names, not a view on who was right.

The count of festivals

Year What happened
2014 The first Pork Roll Festival, with more than 4,000 visitors
2015 Two rival festivals on the same date; a vegan festival; the eating championship
2016 Both pork roll festivals continue
2019 The sixth annual Official Pork Roll Festival at Mill Hill Park, alongside the Trenton Pork Roll Festival
2020 A seventh festival is planned, delayed and cancelled because of COVID-19

The cancellation of 2020 is a footnote on a pattern shared with every other festival that year. The pandemic cleared the calendar, and Trenton's two festivals were no exception.

Why it worked, and why it split

A festival built around one food succeeds because it gives a crowd something to do and something to eat. Pork roll is cheap to cook, quick to serve and recognized by every New Jerseyan, so a plate of it is a ready-made reason to go downtown on a Saturday. The first festival worked because the idea matched what people already wanted.

A festival that draws 4,000 people needs a venue, food, vendors, permits and money, and decisions about which to pay for and who takes the risk. The stated reasons for the split were the venue and the capacity, and when two groups wanted different answers, they each held their own.

For Trenton, the festivals bring people into the city on a spring weekend. Trenton covers the city, and trenton: a walk around the capital walks the neighborhood around the state house.

Questions visitors ask

Which one was first? The first festival, in 2014, was held at the restaurant. The park festival began in 2015 as the "Official 2nd Annual" event, so both trace their lineage to the same 2014 day.

Does one festival have the real claim? That is exactly what the dispute was about. Both ran in the years that followed, and visitors have chosen by location and habit.

Is it only about pork roll? The festival's food is built around it, but the events have included contests, a royalty crowning and, in 2015, the separate vegan event and the baseball team's eating championship.

Does the state run it? No. These are community and private events, not state programs, though the state's tourism site lists festivals around New Jersey.

How to find the current festival

The festival's schedule is the kind of detail that changes year to year, and the right habit is to check before going.

  1. Look for a May date. The first festival was held on May 24, 2014, and the festivals have been a late-spring event.
  2. Check which festival it is. The names are similar, so confirm the organizer and the site.
  3. Plan for crowds. Both festivals have drawn large crowds, and food can run out.
  4. Use local sources. The city's tourism and events listings, and the state's visitor site at visitnj.org, list current events.

For the wider picture of the state's food culture, see North, Central and South Jersey, and the shore: the regions explained and Pork roll or Taylor ham: where the dividing line runs. And for how the state's lawmakers and governor have weighed in on the sandwich itself, the state sandwich bills of 2016 and 2023 picks up the story.

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic