Blog
George Washington Case and the Belle Mead roll
The Somerset County butcher whose 1870 pork roll rivaled Taylor's, the 1910 ruling that no one could own the name, and the Trenton firm that carries it on.
Every state with a signature food has a founder's story, and the story is usually told with one hero. New Jersey's pork roll has two. John Taylor of Trenton is the better known, and the argument over what to call the sandwich is often named after him. But the other claimant is a man with one of the most American names imaginable, George Washington Case, who ran a farm and a butcher's trade in Belle Mead, in Somerset County, and who sold his own pork roll in 1870.
His product, and the company that grew from it, are the reason there are two brands of pork roll on the market rather than one. They are also the reason a federal judge once had to say, in plain language, that nobody can own the words "pork roll."
The man and the roll
George Washington Case was a farmer and a butcher in Belle Mead, a small community in Montgomery Township, in the central part of Somerset County. By the accounts that have come down, he began making and selling his own pork roll in 1870, a hickory-smoked version, reportedly packaged in corn husks. That is fourteen years after Taylor's first recipe, and it makes Case a competitor rather than an imitator: both men were working in the same place and period, and both were turning cured pork into a product that could be sliced and fried.
The recipes of both companies remain trade secrets, which is why the history of the product's formula is vague. The public record includes the dates, the names and the court case. It does not include the ingredients. What is documented is that the Case business grew into a company, that it later moved to Trenton, and that it continues to sell pork roll under the name Case's. It is the second of the two major producers in the state, the other being Taylor Provisions. Both are headquartered in Trenton today.
That fact deserves a moment. Case began in the countryside of Somerset County, in a village of farms and a crossroads, and the business that grew from it is now a Trenton enterprise like its rival. The two companies sit in the same city and sell similar products under different names, and their competition has been one of the quiet constants of the state's food history.
What Case's represents
Case's pork roll is sold under its own brand, with its own packaging, next to the Taylor and Trenton products on the same shelf. It is a reminder that "pork roll" is a category rather than a single product.
The category question is exactly what the courts had to decide.
The 1910 case
In 1910, the Taylor company went to court. The suit, Taylor Provision Co. v. Gobel, was decided in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York on August 15, 1910, and is reported at 180 F. 938. The defendant was Adolph Gobel, a Brooklyn meat man known as the "Sausage King," who sold a product he called "Roll of Pork."
Taylor's claim was twofold. The company said that Gobel was engaging in unfair competition and that he was violating its trademark. Taylor had been selling "Taylor's Pork Roll," and it argued that Gobel's name was too close to its own.
Judge Thomas Chatfield ruled against the trademark claim. The court held that the terms "Pork Roll" and "Roll of Pork" could not be trademarked. In the judge's description, pork roll was "a food article made of pork, packed in a cylindrical cotton sack or bag." That is a description of a kind of food, and a description of a kind of food belongs to everyone who makes it.
Why a description cannot be a trademark
The reasoning is a general principle of trademark law, and it is worth stating plainly. A trademark protects a name that identifies the maker of a product: it tells the buyer who made it. A word that merely describes what the product is, or names the product's kind, does not do that. If one company could own the words "pork roll," every other company would be unable to describe its pork roll to customers. The law therefore does not allow a business to own the ordinary name of the thing it sells. What a company can protect is its brand: Taylor, Trenton, Case's.
This is general information about how trademark law works, not advice about any particular case. It is also the reason that the 1910 ruling still matters. It meant that Case, Gobel and any later maker could sell pork roll under that name, and the two companies that dominate the market today do so.
Names that lost their protection
The pork roll ruling is one case in a long line. American courts have repeatedly held that a word can lose, or never gain, trademark protection when it becomes the ordinary name for a kind of product. "Aspirin" and "escalator" were once brand names and are now common nouns, and the law treats them as such. The pork roll decision came at the other end of the process: the words were descriptive from the start, and the court refused to let one maker take them out of the common vocabulary. The practical result is that two companies, and anyone else who wants to, can put "pork roll" on a package, and competition is on brand, price and taste.
Questions people ask
Is Case's the original pork roll? Taylor's is the older of the two recipes, dated to 1856, and Case's is dated to 1870. Both claims are about the start of a business, and neither maker holds the words "pork roll."
Can anyone sell something called pork roll? Under the 1910 ruling the name is open to all makers. A seller still has to follow food labeling rules and cannot use another company's brand name.
Where is Belle Mead? It is a community in Montgomery Township, Somerset County, in the central part of the state.
Does the 1910 case still matter? It is the reason the category has stayed open. Taylor lost the claim to the generic words, and the product has been sold under more than one brand ever since.
Is Case's made in Belle Mead today? The company is headquartered in Trenton.
The festival and the contest
Case's name appears in a few of the product's cultural moments. At the first Pork Roll Festival in Trenton on May 24, 2014, the pre-ordered supply of pork roll ran out as thousands of visitors arrived, and the president of Case Pork Roll delivered 20 more cases. The episode is part of the festival's legend. The Trenton Pork Roll Festival and its 2015 split tells the whole story, including the split that followed.
The following year, in 2015, the Trenton Thunder baseball team hosted the Trenton Thunder World Famous Case's Pork Roll Eating Championship. Joey Chestnut, the competitive eater, won the inaugural contest by eating 32 four-ounce sandwiches in ten minutes. The number is a reminder of how much pork roll there is in New Jersey, and of how the product has become a spectacle as well as a breakfast.
Two companies, one capital
It is a quirk of the state's food history that the two main pork roll companies are in the same city and that their products are sold under distinct brands: Taylor and Trenton from one, Case's from the other. A cook may prefer one over the other and say so.
The two firms have a shared history in the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906, which ended the name "ham" for Taylor's product and set the whole category on the path to the label "pork roll." They shared the 1910 ruling that kept the category open. And they share the city. For the other half of the story, see John Taylor of Trenton and the 1856 ham, and for the name argument, Pork roll or Taylor ham: where the dividing line runs.
Why the Case story gets less attention
The Taylor story has a founder with a date and a Trenton address, and the Taylor name is baked into the dispute over what to call the sandwich. Case's name does not appear in that argument. People do not say "Case ham." The company's name is attached to a brand, not to a word, and so the man behind it is less well known.
Both outcomes are ordinary ways a business name ends up in the language, or does not.
How to find it
If you want to try the product the Case family made famous, the practical steps are simple.
- Look for Case's on the label. The brand name is on the package, next to the words pork roll.
- Buy it by the roll or sliced. Pork roll is sold both ways.
- Cook it right. Slice it to about a quarter of an inch, cut the edge or score the center so it lies flat, and fry until the edges brown.
- Compare. The only way to find a preference between the two brands is to taste both.
For a map of where the product is most at home, North, Central and South Jersey, and the shore: the regions explained outlines the state's regions, and New Brunswick and Trenton cover two of the Central Jersey cities where it turns up on every breakfast menu.