Blog
Pork roll or Taylor ham: where the dividing line runs
What three surveys say about the state's favorite argument: a 2016 reader poll along I-78, a 2014 menu survey near the Raritan and a Rutgers-Eagleton poll.
At a diner counter in Hackensack a cook slaps three slices of the same cylindrical meat on the grill and calls it Taylor ham. At a luncheonette in Cherry Hill, a cook does exactly the same thing and calls it pork roll. Neither is wrong, and neither will ever convince the other. The two words name one product, and the choice between them is the closest thing New Jersey has to a state religion.
The argument has become a staple of the state's identity, and unlike most identity quarrels it has been measured. There is a 2014 survey of menus, a 2016 reader poll with more than 70,000 respondents and a scientific poll from Rutgers University. They do not match exactly, but together they draw a map. This is a tour of that map: where the line runs, what the numbers say and why the label on the package settles nothing.
The label
Start with the one thing nobody disputes. The legal name of the product is pork roll. A 1906 federal law about food labeling ended the use of "ham" for it, and the manufacturers have sold it as pork roll ever since. One of the two main makers sells under the names Taylor and Trenton, and the other sells under the name Case's. The package at the supermarket says pork roll.
"Taylor ham" is therefore a customer's word, not a manufacturer's. It comes from the Taylor name, which for a very long time was attached to the product, and it has survived in the speech of people who grew up asking for Taylor's. That is the origin of the divide: one group of New Jerseyans names the item after a brand, and another names it after the thing itself. John Taylor of Trenton and the 1856 ham tells how the brand and the product were separated.
The 2014 menu survey
The first attempt to draw the line used restaurants rather than people. In 2014, a survey looked at what diners and eateries called the item on their menus. It found the north-south line farther south than many expected, in Somerset and Middlesex counties around the Raritan River. Restaurants in Monmouth County, notably, used "Taylor ham."
A menu is a different kind of evidence from a person's speech. A restaurant owner may print a name because it is what customers say, because a supplier uses it or because it looks better on a sign. The menu survey is useful because it counts something concrete, and it is a reminder that the line is not a clean curve. Monmouth, a shore county, has a Taylor ham habit that a simple north-south split would not predict.
The 2016 reader poll
The best-known measurement came in 2016, when a reader poll that drew more than 70,000 respondents from municipalities across the state put the line on the Union-Middlesex border in the east. Moving west, it ran along Interstate 78 through Somerset and Hunterdon counties.
That is a clear, memorable geography. North and east of the line, people say Taylor ham. South and west, they say pork roll. For a driver the rule is nearly a highway map: Interstate 78 as a boundary through the middle of the state, with the Union and Middlesex county line marking the eastern end. The cities of the northern core, Newark, Jersey City, Paterson, Elizabeth and the rest of Hudson, Essex, Passaic and Bergen, fall on the Taylor ham side. Trenton, Camden, Atlantic City and the Pine Barrens fall on the pork roll side.
A reader poll is not a random sample. People who answer one are those who care about the question, and respondents choose to take part. That limits what it can prove. But 70,000 is a large number for a lighthearted subject, and the clarity of the result has made it the standard reference for the debate.
The Rutgers-Eagleton poll
The most rigorous measure came from the Rutgers-Eagleton Poll, which asked 843 adult New Jerseyans by telephone, on both landlines and cell phones, between November 30 and December 6, 2015, with a margin of error of plus or minus 3.8 percentage points. The results were released in May 2016.
Statewide, 38 percent said pork roll and 35 percent said Taylor ham. Thirteen percent used neither name, 2 percent used both interchangeably and 12 percent were not sure. In other words, the state is nearly split, with a slight edge for the name on the label.
The regional breakdown is the interesting part. In North Jersey, 59 percent said Taylor ham. In Central Jersey, 25 percent said Taylor ham and 45 percent pork roll, with the rest in the other categories. In South Jersey, 65 percent said pork roll. Central Jersey is, as ever, the place where the two worlds overlap, and it is the region where the answer is least predictable.
There was also a finding about time. Almost half of relative newcomers to the state did not take a side. About nine in ten lifelong residents did. Pork roll led among those who had lived in the state up to a decade or two, and the race was closer among those who had lived there 25 years or more. People, in other words, acquire the word from the people around them, and the longer they stay, the more firmly they hold it.
Reading the numbers
A margin of error is easy to skim past, and here it matters. The Rutgers-Eagleton margin was plus or minus 3.8 percentage points. Statewide pork roll led Taylor ham by three points, 38 to 35, which is smaller than the margin, so the honest reading is that the state is split roughly down the middle and the poll cannot say which name is ahead. The regional numbers are much larger than the margin. A 59 percent figure in North Jersey and a 65 percent figure in South Jersey are not noise.
The same caution applies to the other two measurements, in different ways. The menu survey counts restaurants, not people, and the reader poll counts volunteers. None of the three alone settles the matter, and the pattern that appears in all of them is the one worth trusting.
A drive along the line
The 2016 poll's western boundary is easy to test in your head. Interstate 78 crosses the state from the Delaware River in Warren County to the Holland Tunnel approach, and it passes through Hunterdon, Somerset, Union and Essex counties on the way. A driver heading east on I-78 from Hunterdon County passes through country where the poll found the line, and by the time the road reaches Union and Essex counties, it is in territory where Taylor ham is the default. Somewhere along that stretch, the breakfast menus change their words. It is a short stretch of highway for such a large cultural shift.
What the three surveys agree on
Put side by side, the three measurements say the same three things.
- The north says Taylor ham and the south says pork roll. All three agree on the basic split.
- The middle is contested. Somerset, Middlesex, Hunterdon and Monmouth are where the line wobbles, depending on how you ask.
- It is a habit of upbringing. The strongest finding is that lifelong residents are nearly all committed, and newcomers are not.
That last point is worth thinking about. A person who grew up in Bergen County and moved to Camden County will probably keep saying Taylor ham for life, and will be corrected by coworkers for a decade. A person who moves to the state at 30 may never pick a side. The word is a marker of where you were a child, and that is why it lasts.
The political footnote
The argument has reached the highest levels of attention. On May 15, 2016, President Barack Obama joked about settling the debate in a commencement speech at Rutgers. The joke worked because everyone in the audience knew exactly what he meant, and nobody in the stadium was neutral. The Legislature has taken up the matter too. the state sandwich bills of 2016 and 2023 covers the 2016 bills and the 2023 proclamation.
How to order, wherever you are
A few rules of thumb save an awkward moment.
- In North Jersey, ask for Taylor ham. Counties such as Bergen, Essex, Hudson and Passaic lean that way, and a counter worker will understand either name.
- In South Jersey, ask for pork roll. The Rutgers-Eagleton poll found nearly two thirds of South Jerseyans use that word.
- In Central Jersey, either works. Middlesex, Somerset and the surrounding counties are where the two names live side by side.
- If you are not from here, listen first. The cook's own word is the safe one, and nobody will hold the question against you.
- At the grocery store, look for pork roll. The label uses the legal name.
For the larger regional picture, see North, Central and South Jersey, and the shore: the regions explained, and for the two places that anchor the product, Trenton and New Brunswick. Myths about pork roll and Taylor ham takes on the common misconceptions.
Why the argument lasts
The pork roll debate survives because it costs nothing and means a great deal. It is a harmless way for a state of 9.5 million people, with 564 municipalities and three informal regions, to argue about where it belongs. Nobody loses a job over the name. Nobody changes their mind. And every New Jerseyan who has lived anywhere else knows that the question is one of the few that strangers will take seriously, because it tells them where you grew up.
That, in the end, is what the surveys measure. They are not really about ham. They are about the places people learned the word, and the line along Interstate 78 is a line between two childhoods.