Blog

The state sandwich bills of 2016 and 2023

Two Assembly bills in April 2016 tried to name a state sandwich and died in committee; in May 2023 a governor's proclamation named one anyway.

New Jersey has an official state bird, fish, fruit and dinosaur. It also has an official state dog, which is the Seeing Eye dog, an official state dance, which is the square dance, and an official state microbe. The state's list of symbols has no sandwich on it. It almost did, twice, and the attempts say a lot about how the Legislature works, how a governor can sidestep it and why this particular argument is hard to settle.

The first try came in April 2016, when a legislator introduced two bills on the same day. The second came in May 2023, when a governor stepped in front of a camera and declared the matter closed, with a flourish borrowed from a pop star. Neither route produced a law. Both produced a lot of newspaper space.

How a state symbol gets made

First, the machinery. New Jersey's official symbols are mostly set by statute, which means a bill passes both houses of the Legislature and the governor signs it. The examples are a useful comparison. The eastern goldfinch was named the state bird in 1935. The horse became the state animal in 1977, thanks to the efforts of a fifth-grader and an eighth-grader. Hadrosaurus foulkii, a dinosaur whose remains were found in the state, was made the state dinosaur on June 13, 1991. The brook trout became the state fish when the governor signed a bill on January 8, 1992. The blueberry became the state fruit in 2004. The red oak is the state tree.

Many of those started with schoolchildren and a local legislator, and they went through the ordinary process: introduced, referred to a committee, heard, voted and signed. How a bill becomes law in New Jersey describes the route in general terms, and The New Jersey Legislature covers the institution. The important feature for this story is that a bill needs a committee to move it, and a committee decides whether to put it on its agenda. A bill that the committee chair does not list does not get a hearing.

The state's symbols, as listed

The state's own page of symbols is longer than most people expect, and the way it reads shows the kind of thing the Legislature usually names.

Symbol Official choice
Seal Created in 1777
Flag Adopted in 1896
Animal Horse (1977)
Bird Eastern goldfinch
Bug Honeybee (1974)
Dance Square dance (1983, by joint resolution)
Dinosaur Hadrosaurus foulkii
Dog The Seeing Eye dog
Fish Brook trout
Flower Violet
Fruit Blueberry (2004)
Microbe Streptomyces griseus
Mineral Franklinite
Reptile Bog turtle
Shell Knobbed whelk
Ship USS New Jersey
Tall ship A.J. Meerwald
Tree Red oak

The list reads as a map of the state's natural history and its pride: a mineral named for Franklin, a battleship, a dog associated with the state, a bird and a bog turtle. The one food on it is the blueberry, a crop the state grows in quantity. A sandwich would be a different kind of symbol. It is a prepared dish with a disputed name, and it would be the first thing on the list that people argue about at breakfast.

The 1983 entry is worth noticing too. The state dance was named by a joint resolution rather than by a bill, a different kind of legislative act.

April 14, 2016: two bills

On April 14, 2016, an assemblyman introduced two bills on the same day. One, A3666, would have designated the pork roll, egg and cheese sandwich as the New Jersey state sandwich. The other, A3667, would have designated the Taylor Ham, egg and cheese sandwich. They were identical in every respect except the name.

The approach was a deliberate piece of political wit. By filing two bills, the sponsor let the Legislature pick a name, or at least let the public argue about which bill deserved a vote. He told an interviewer in 2016 that he was leaning toward pork roll and would abstain on the Taylor Ham bill. It was a joke with a legal form, and the form was real: both bills were officially introduced and referred to the Assembly State and Local Government Committee.

That is where they stayed. Neither bill left committee. Under the Legislature's two-year session, a bill that does not pass by the end of the session expires, and these two expired with the 2016-2017 session. The lack of a vote is the usual fate of a bill that has no committee hearing, and it was an unremarkable one. But the episode is worth remembering because it put the state's best-known food dispute on the Statehouse's own paper. Pork roll or Taylor ham: where the dividing line runs covers the argument itself, and The Trenton Pork Roll Festival and its 2015 split shows how the rivalry works on the ground.

How a bill like this stalls

Because the 2016 bills never moved, it helps to see where a bill like this can stop. The path, in outline, runs like this.

  1. Introduction. A member files the bill, it gets a number and a short title, and it is printed.
  2. Referral. The presiding officer sends it to a committee. In this case, the Assembly State and Local Government Committee.
  3. Committee action. The chair decides whether to list the bill for a hearing. A bill that is never listed stays where it is.
  4. Floor votes. A bill that clears committee goes to the full house, then to the other house, and then to the governor.
  5. Expiration. At the end of the two-year session, any bill that has not passed expires, and a sponsor must start over in the next session.

Both sandwich bills stopped at step three. The Legislature's site shows the status of every bill, and the history of these two reads, in the plainest terms, "died in committee."

What each name would have meant

The two-bill method sidestepped a question that the Legislature has no easy way to answer: what is the proper name of the sandwich? The legal name of the product is pork roll, which is what the label says. Taylor ham is a colloquial name, tied to a brand. A bill naming one as the state's choice would have put the Legislature on one side of a regional split that, according to polling, runs close to even statewide. Declining to choose, by filing both, was a way of avoiding it.

May 25, 2023: the proclamation

Seven years later, the matter came up again, through a different door. On May 25, 2023, Governor Phil Murphy declared the state's official sandwich to be the "Taylor Swift Ham, Egg, and Cheese." He announced it in a video posted on social media, with a proclamation attached.

The timing was no accident. The singer was about to play three shows at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, on May 26, 27 and 28. The governor framed the move as a response to the long dispute over whether the meat is called Taylor ham or pork roll: the singer's name contained "Taylor," the state was about to host her, and so the sandwich would carry her name. The proclamation itself was packed with references to her songs and albums, and it declared an end to what it called the "Great War" over the name.

It was a clever way out. By naming the sandwich after a person rather than a meat, the governor made the name dispute moot without choosing a side. Fans of pork roll got a sandwich that was not called Taylor ham, and fans of Taylor ham got one that had the word in it.

A proclamation is not a law

The distinction matters. A proclamation is a governor's ceremonial declaration. It did not pass through the Legislature, and it does not appear among the statutory state symbols. It carries the weight of the governor's name and not much more, and it can be a delightful piece of civic theater without changing a single legal fact. Whether the sandwich is the official state sandwich depends on what one means by "official." The state's own page of symbols is the place to check what the statutes say, and the Legislature's bill-search page lists any new bills.

Why the argument is hard to settle

Three features make the sandwich hard to settle.

  1. The name is regional. A statewide symbol has to be acceptable statewide, and the name for this food is a line through the middle of the state.
  2. The product has two makers. Taylor Provisions and Case Pork Roll are both in Trenton, and each sells under its own brand.
  3. It is an identity. A state bird is a bird. A state sandwich is a matter of where you grew up.

The 2023 solution worked because it was a joke aimed at an event, not a statement of policy. It did not pretend to resolve the question. It acknowledged that the question was not going to be resolved and moved on.

What to take from it

The two episodes are a small lesson in how government handles the things people care about but cannot agree on. The Legislature, when asked to choose, let the bills lapse in committee. The governor, when offered a chance to make news, chose a symbol that avoided the dispute entirely. Neither was dramatic. Both were intelligent responses to a problem with no clean answer.

For anyone who wants to follow a bill of their own, the legislative site at njleg.state.nj.us lets you search by bill number or keyword, and how to find your legislators and track a bill explains how. For the governor's office, see Office of the Governor. For the sandwich's history, John Taylor of Trenton and the 1856 ham and George Washington Case and the Belle Mead roll tell where the two names came from.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic