Blog

John Taylor of Trenton and the 1856 ham

How a Trenton provisions man's 1856 recipe became "Taylor's Prepared Ham," why a 1906 federal law forced a new name, and why pork roll is a Trenton product.

Ask a New Jerseyan where the state's signature breakfast meat comes from and the answer is a city name: Trenton. The capital is where the state government sits, where the Delaware River bends toward Pennsylvania, and where in 1856 a man named John Taylor developed a recipe for a cured, spiced, smoked pork product that he sold as "Taylor's Prepared Ham." The name lasted half a century. The product has lasted a century and a half.

The story of pork roll, or Taylor ham, depending on where you grew up, begins in Trenton and returns there. Two companies that still make it have their headquarters in the city, and a festival in its public park is dedicated to it. What follows is the history of the first of them, and what happened to the word "ham" along the way.

Trenton in 1856

The Trenton that Taylor knew was a river city on its way to being an industrial one. It was the county seat of Mercer County and the state's capital, a place of canal boats, rail lines and workshops. The Delaware and Raritan Canal and the railroads that followed gave it cheap shipping, and over the next several decades its factories made ceramics, wire rope, rubber goods and steel. Local pride eventually put its motto on a bridge over the Delaware, "Trenton Makes, The World Takes," a sentence that fits a city of small manufacturers and also fits a meat product that left town in boxes.

It was a good place for a provisions business. A city with workers needs cheap, filling, long-lasting food, and cured pork was exactly that. A product that could be sliced, fried and put on bread, and that kept without a refrigerator, suited a boarding house, a factory canteen or a railroad lunch counter.

What Taylor made

By most accounts, John Taylor of Trenton created his recipe in 1856. It was sold as "Taylor's Prepared Ham," a name that makes sense for a ready-to-slice pork product marketed as a convenient alternative to a whole ham. In shape, it is a cylinder of seasoned, processed pork, and the traditional package was a cotton sack. A court in 1910 would later describe pork roll as a food article made of pork, packed in a cylindrical cotton sack or bag.

Both recipes remain trade secrets: the two companies that make pork roll today, one descended from Taylor's business and one from a competitor, have not published a formula. What the public knows is the shape, the flavor and the way it cooks. A slice behaves unlike a slice of bacon or of ham. It curls into a cup in a hot pan, so cooks cut one slash across the middle in a "Pac-Man" pattern, or four small cuts toward the center in a "fireman's badge," to keep it flat. Then it is pan-fried until the edges brown and crisp.

That edge is the point of the product. A pork roll slice has a saltiness and a crust that a cooked deli ham does not, and it is why the sandwich of pork roll, egg and cheese on a roll became a breakfast institution. Pork roll or Taylor ham: where the dividing line runs covers the name that people use for it.

The 1906 problem

For fifty years, "Taylor's Prepared Ham" was a fine name. Then, in 1906, Congress passed the Pure Food and Drug Act, one of the first federal laws to regulate the labeling of food. The act set rules about what could be sold under a given name, and Taylor's product did not meet the legal definition of "ham."

The company had to change the name. It became "Taylor's Pork Roll," a plain description of what was in the sack. The change was a small piece of paperwork with a long afterlife. Because the label can no longer say "ham," any product sold under it has to say "pork roll," and that rule applies to every maker, not just Taylor. Labels in the grocery case say pork roll. The word "Taylor ham" survived only in the mouths of customers.

That split is why New Jersey has a naming dispute. People who grew up buying the product under the Taylor brand kept calling it by the old, informal name, and the habit passed through families and towns. Others learned the label name. The Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906 created, by accident, a state argument that still runs a century later. George Washington Case and the Belle Mead roll tells the rival's story, including the 1910 court case that settled whether anyone could own the name.

The law in its moment

The Pure Food and Drug Act was signed on June 30, 1906, the same day as the Meat Inspection Act, in a year when Upton Sinclair's novel about the Chicago stockyards had made the public suspicious of what went into packaged meat. Congress was responding to a decade of complaints about adulterated, mislabeled and unsafe food. Its central idea was simple: a label had to tell the truth about what was in the package. For a Trenton maker with a product called a ham that was not one, a new name was a small price for staying in business.

It is worth noticing how little the change cost the product. Customers did not stop buying it. They kept the habit and let the name drift. That is how a legal definition ends up leaving a mark on a region's speech: the law changed what the box said, and the buyers kept saying what they had always said.

The sandwich, step by step

The pork roll sandwich is simple enough that its details are a matter of local pride. The usual build is three pieces of work, done in this order:

  1. The meat. Slice the roll to about a quarter of an inch, cut the edges so it lies flat, and fry it in a pan or on a griddle until the edges are brown and slightly crisp.
  2. The egg and cheese. An egg is fried or scrambled beside it, and a slice of cheese goes on top to melt.
  3. The roll. The standard vehicle is a hard roll or a Kaiser roll, though bagels and plain white bread have their partisans.

Toppings are a matter of taste and region. Ketchup, salt, pepper and plain butter all have their defenders. The sandwich is the breakfast order that is known by its three ingredients, and a diner's grill cook who hears "pork roll, egg and cheese" knows precisely what is wanted. What makes a Jersey diner looks at the places that make it.

The business after Taylor

Taylor's product grew into a company, and the company is still in Trenton. Taylor Provisions sells its pork roll under the Taylor and Trenton brands, and it is one of two main producers in the state. The other, Case Pork Roll, sells under the name Case's and is also headquartered in Trenton. Both products are made to recipes that their companies keep private, and both are sold in grocery stores across the state and in neighboring ones.

Both products are sold in grocery stores across the state, and a slice of either one ends up in the same place: a hot pan.

How to read a pork roll label

A few points help when you are standing in front of the cooler.

  • The label says pork roll. Since the 1906 act, the legal name is not ham, so the package says pork roll even where shoppers say Taylor ham.
  • The brands differ. Taylor and Trenton are one company's names, and Case's is the other's.
  • It is sold sliced or in a roll. You can buy it in a whole cylinder to slice yourself, or in pre-cut slices.
  • It must be cooked. Slices are pan-fried, grilled or otherwise heated, not eaten cold from the package.
  • Cut the edges. A single radial cut or four small cuts around the edge keeps a slice from curling.

Why it matters that it came from Trenton

New Jersey has a habit of letting its food be defined by its cities and counties rather than by the state at large. Paterson has its Great Falls and its textile past, Atlantic City has its taffy, and Trenton has its pork roll. Pork roll is part of the capital's claim to be a place that makes things. Trenton covers the capital, and trenton: a walk around the capital walks it.

The product is also a small lesson in how a regulated label shapes a culture. The Pure Food and Drug Act was meant to protect consumers from misleading names. It did that, and it also, as a side effect, gave New Jersey a quarrel about what to call a sandwich. The Trenton Pork Roll Festival and its 2015 split shows how far the quarrel has gone, and the state sandwich bills of 2016 and 2023 shows how the Legislature and a governor tried, in their different ways, to settle it.

The timeline

Year What happened
1856 John Taylor of Trenton develops his recipe, sold as "Taylor's Prepared Ham"
1870 George Washington Case of Belle Mead is reported to begin selling a rival product
1906 The Pure Food and Drug Act forces the end of the "ham" name
1910 A federal court rules that "pork roll" cannot be trademarked
2014 The first Pork Roll Festival is held in Trenton
2016 Two state sandwich bills are introduced and die in committee
2023 The governor proclaims the "Taylor Swift Ham, Egg, and Cheese"

The list runs from a meat shop to a proclamation, and the thread through it is a single product and the question of what to call it. For where to find the foods of the state in context, see North, Central and South Jersey, and the shore: the regions explained.

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic