Blog
Myths about pork roll and Taylor ham
Six myths about New Jersey's breakfast meat, from the 1856 invention to the 1910 ruling, the 2016 sandwich bills and where the north-south line really falls.
There are two kinds of New Jerseyans, and the way to tell them apart is to order breakfast. One asks for a Taylor ham, egg and cheese on a roll. The other asks for a pork roll, egg and cheese. Each is certain that the other is wrong, the argument has lasted for generations, and it comes up at every wedding, tailgate and deli counter in the state. What nobody can agree on is what they are arguing about. This post goes through the claims people make most often and says what the record supports, so that the next argument can at least be a better one.
A word on method. The history of pork roll is told mostly in company histories, newspaper pieces and one federal court case, and a lot of what circulates is legend. Where the dates are solid, they are given. Where the stories vary, the post says so.
Myth 1: Taylor ham and pork roll are two different foods
They are the same kind of product with two names. Pork roll is a processed, seasoned, smoked pork product that is sliced, scored at the edges so that it does not curl, and griddled. It was developed in 1856 by John Taylor of Trenton, who sold it under the name Taylor's Prepared Ham. "Taylor ham" is simply a nickname that grew out of that original label, and for much of North Jersey it became the generic word. "Pork roll" is the name that stayed on the packages and is the usual word in Central and South Jersey. The northern name is a brand name that escaped into ordinary speech, the way people say Kleenex for a tissue. The meat on the grill is not a different animal.
That does not mean the people who say Taylor ham are wrong about their own habit. Language works that way. It means that if you hold up a package at a store, it will almost certainly say pork roll.
Myth 2: It was always called ham
It was, for a few decades, and then it was not. Taylor sold his product as Taylor's Prepared Ham until 1906. That year the federal Pure Food and Drug Act passed, and with it came a stricter definition of what could be called ham. Taylor's product did not meet it, and the name had to go. The company changed course and sold it as Taylor's Pork Roll and as Trenton Pork Roll. In other words, the name that most New Jerseyans think of as the correct one is the one a federal food law forced on the company. Those who say Taylor ham are, in a way, using the older name.
Myth 3: The name pork roll is a trademark, and only one company can use it
A 1910 court ruling went the other way. Taylor's company sued a Brooklyn sausage maker named Adolph Gobel, who sold a product as Roll of Pork, in a case known as Taylor Provision Co. v. Gobel in the federal circuit court for the Eastern District of New York, decided in August 1910. The court held that the unregistered words Pork Roll and Roll of Pork could not be the subject of a valid trademark. Accounts of the opinion differ slightly in their wording, but the outcome is consistent: the names were descriptive, not protectable. After that, any maker could sell a pork roll.
Taylor's main rival in New Jersey was Case. George Washington Case, of Belle Mead in Somerset County, is said to have made a hickory-smoked version of the product in 1870, and the Case company, now based in Trenton, still makes one. So the market has had at least two long-running producers for well over a century. George Washington Case and the Belle Mead roll tells that story, and John Taylor of Trenton and the 1856 ham tells the first.
Myth 4: The dividing line between the two names is a fixed boundary
It is a fuzzy band, and surveys put it in different places. A 2016 reader poll that drew more than 70,000 votes placed the line roughly along Interstate 78 from the Union and Middlesex county border through Somerset and Hunterdon counties, with Taylor ham dominating to the north and pork roll to the south. A 2014 survey of menus placed it nearer to the Raritan River. Both agree on the basic picture: Taylor ham in the north, pork roll in the south, and a mixed zone across the middle where each person's usage depends on where they grew up. Say a family moves from Newark to Princeton: it may end up with two vocabularies at one breakfast table.
The line is also a matter of upbringing, and people who have moved around the state often pick up both words. The practical advice is to say whichever word you grew up with and to be ready to be understood.
Myth 5: The Legislature settled it
In 2016 two bills were introduced in Trenton to make the sandwich an official state sandwich. Both died in committee. The idea has the whiff of a joke, but the process is a real one: a bill is introduced, referred to a committee, may be heard and, if the committee does not move it, expires at the end of the two-year session. the state sandwich bills of 2016 and 2023 covers what happened, and The New Jersey Legislature describes how the Legislature works. Nothing in New Jersey law says which name is correct, and no agency enforces one.
The story took a lighter turn in 2023, when Governor Phil Murphy issued a lighthearted proclamation on May 25 naming the state's sandwich the Taylor Swift Ham, Egg and Cheese. It was a joke about the singer, not a food regulation, and nobody should confuse it with a ruling on the name. The question remains open, and the state seems happy to keep it that way.
Myth 6: Nobody celebrates it, so it is only a diner joke
The sandwich has its own festival. The first Pork Roll Festival was held on May 24, 2014, at a Trenton venue called Trenton Social. The Trenton Pork Roll Festival and its 2015 split tells how it grew. It is a pleasing fact that the state capital is also the birthplace of a food that so many residents eat. Trenton has other claims, including the Battle of Trenton in 1776, and Trenton covers the city.
The sandwich is also a symbol of how the state eats. It is a breakfast food that sits at the center of the diner and the deli, the two institutions that most define New Jersey's food scene, and a diner counter at seven in the morning is the place where the argument is most likely to be continued. What makes a Jersey diner is the longer essay on that.
Questions that are not myths
How do you cook it? Pork roll is usually sliced into rounds and cut at the edges so that it lies flat, then fried or griddled until the edges brown. Many cooks cut a few notches around the circumference. A sandwich typically adds a fried or scrambled egg and cheese on a roll, though a sandwich shop will build it as you like.
Is it the same as Canadian bacon, Spam or ham? It is not. It is a processed pork product with its own seasoning and smoke, and it does not meet the definition of ham, which is the reason for the 1906 renaming.
Is it only a New Jersey food? It is rooted in Trenton and the surrounding region, and it is most popular in New Jersey and nearby areas. The question of where else it is eaten is not one this post needs to settle.
Who is right? Neither, in any sense a court would recognize. A Trenton company created the product, the courts said the names could not be owned, and every New Jerseyan is free to use the one they prefer. The most defensible position is the one that most people take, which is to use the word you grew up with and not to correct anyone else's breakfast.
A short timeline
- 1856. John Taylor of Trenton develops the product and sells it as Taylor's Prepared Ham.
- 1870. George Washington Case of Belle Mead makes a hickory-smoked version, according to the standard histories.
- 1906. The Pure Food and Drug Act's definition of ham forces the Taylor product to change its name to pork roll.
- August 1910. A federal court in Taylor Provision Co. v. Gobel holds that the unregistered words Pork Roll and Roll of Pork cannot be trademarked.
- May 24, 2014. The first Pork Roll Festival is held in Trenton.
- 2016. Two bills to name a state sandwich die in committee.
- May 25, 2023. A lighthearted gubernatorial proclamation names a state sandwich in honor of a pop star.
The list is short, and that is part of the charm. The whole saga fits on an index card, which is not how most of the state's arguments go.
How to make the sandwich at home
For anyone who has never had one, the method is simple and the result depends on the details.
- Slice it. Pork roll is sold in logs or in pre-sliced packages. Slices about a quarter inch thick are typical.
- Score the edges. Cut three or four small notches around the rim of each slice, so that the meat lies flat when it cooks instead of cupping.
- Heat a pan or griddle. Medium heat is enough. No oil is needed, as the meat releases its own fat.
- Cook until the edges brown. Turn once. The slices should be browned and a little crisp at the rim.
- Add the egg and cheese. Fry or scramble an egg in the same pan, add a slice of cheese while it is hot and stack it all on a roll. Many people prefer a hard roll or a kaiser roll, and a salt-pepper-ketchup finish is a matter of taste.
The sandwich is a thing of a few minutes and one pan, which is why it endures as a diner standard and a weekend breakfast.
How to settle a breakfast argument
- Start with the history: 1856, Trenton, John Taylor.
- Point out that the name Taylor ham went off the package in 1906, so nobody at the table is using the current official name by accident.
- Mention the 1910 ruling, which means the name is free to anyone.
- Admit that the line between north and south is a blur, and ask where the other person grew up.
- Order.
The argument will outlive the sandwich. It is one of the small, friendly quarrels that hold a state of 564 municipalities together, and nobody who has it is really trying to win.