Blog
The Ellis Island boundary fight
How an 1834 compact, a century of landfill and the Supreme Court's 1998 ruling in New Jersey v. New York put most of Ellis Island in Jersey City.
Most Americans with immigrant ancestors can find Ellis Island on the map. Fewer know which state it is in. The answer, since a ruling of the United States Supreme Court in May 1998, is both. Of the island's 27.5 acres, about 22.80 acres belong to New Jersey and about 4.68 acres to New York, and the line between them cuts through the historic buildings. The case that drew that line is among the odder border disputes in American law: a fight over water, mud and a nineteenth-century treaty between two states, resolved in a courtroom a few miles from the buildings in question.
The story is a good illustration of how a contract written in 1834 can decide who owns land that did not exist until nearly a century later.
The island before the fill
The natural island in Upper New York Bay was tiny, a few acres of sand and oyster beds near the Jersey shore. In 1892 the federal government opened an immigration station on it, and over the following decades the station grew. The first station opened on January 1, 1892, the second on December 17, 1900, and the station closed on November 12, 1954. In that time about 12 million immigrants passed through. In 1965, on May 11, Ellis Island was added to the Statue of Liberty National Monument.
Making an immigration station fit on a small island meant making the island bigger. The government enlarged it with landfill, including ballast from ships and excavated material from construction work, until it reached about 27.5 acres. By the end of that work, most of the island was man-made. That fact is the heart of the dispute.
The 1834 compact
The legal question went back to the 1830s. New York and New Jersey, which had argued over the Hudson River and the harbor since colonial times, negotiated a compact in 1833, and Congress approved it in 1834. The compact set the boundary between the states at the middle of the Hudson River and the harbor. It also gave New York exclusive jurisdiction over the waters of the Hudson west of Manhattan, up to the low-water mark on the New Jersey shore, and it treated Ellis Island, which sat in New Jersey waters, as part of New York.
For a long time that arrangement was workable, because nobody was fighting over a few sandy acres. Then the island grew. The landfill was placed on the submerged lands around the original island, and those submerged lands lay on the New Jersey side of the line. By the late twentieth century the question was no longer academic: who had jurisdiction over the filled land, which made up most of the island's area? It mattered for taxes, for policing and for who could control development.
New Jersey sues
New Jersey took the dispute to the U.S. Supreme Court, which has original jurisdiction over disputes between states, and the case was filed in the 1990s. New Jersey's argument turned on a simple reading of the compact. The compact gave New York the island as it then existed, but the water and the land beneath it around the island belonged to New Jersey. The landfill had been added on top of that submerged land. When something is built on land that belongs to one state, the argument ran, it stays inside that state's border, whatever it was attached to.
New York defended its position on the ground that Ellis Island had always been treated as New York's, and that the filled land should follow the island it enlarged. The state could point to the long period in which the island had been run as a federal enclave with New York as the default jurisdiction.
The decision
The Supreme Court heard argument on January 12, 1998, and decided the case on May 26, 1998. The vote was 6 to 3, and Justice David Souter wrote the opinion of the Court. The majority concluded that, because the 1834 compact gave New Jersey jurisdiction over the submerged lands, the newly created land was in New Jersey. The original island, which the compact had given New York, remained New York's, and the rest, the filled land, was New Jersey's.
The result was the odd map of today. The natural island, about 4.68 acres, is a New York exclave inside New Jersey waters. The 22.80 acres of landfill are part of Jersey City, Hudson County. The line between them runs through the grounds and in some places through buildings.
What changed, and what did not
The ruling changed less than the headlines suggested, because Ellis Island belongs to the federal government. The National Park Service operates it as part of the monument. The U.S. government owns the land regardless of which state's boundary it falls in.
But the decision did have effects:
- Two sets of tax lots. Jersey City and New York City assigned separate tax lot numbers to their respective parts of the island.
- Buildings across the line. Several historic buildings straddle the interstate border, which created confusion at first about which state's codes applied.
- No shared fiscal burden. The two states share jurisdiction over the island, with each state covering its own part, and neither takes fiscal or physical responsibility for maintaining or improving the historic properties. The federal government is the one that pays for that work.
- Liberty Island unaffected. The ruling did not touch the Statue of Liberty's island, which remains in New York.
In practice, visitors cross no visible line. The ferry that brings people to the island runs from Liberty State Park in Jersey City and from Manhattan, and what a visitor sees is a federal museum. The question of which state's police have jurisdiction, or whose sales tax applies to a gift-shop purchase, matters mostly to lawyers and budget offices.
The arithmetic of the line
The numbers are worth checking, because they show how lopsided the split is. The island totals about 27.5 acres. New Jersey's share is 22.80 acres and New York's is 4.68, which adds to 27.48, close enough to the round figure. Divide 22.80 by 27.48 and New Jersey holds roughly 83 percent of the island, New York roughly 17 percent. The fill, in other words, is nearly five times the size of the natural island it surrounds.
That ratio explains why the case mattered. A fight over a few acres of mud would not have reached the Supreme Court. A fight over most of a national landmark that draws visitors from around the world did, and the state that lost the argument lost most of the island's area.
What a visitor meets
The National Park Service runs the site, and the border is not a feature of the tour. A visitor arriving by ferry from Liberty State Park or from Manhattan walks into one federal museum, and several of the historic buildings straddle the line between the two states. It matters when a pipe breaks, a lot needs a tax number or a building needs a code inspection, and at those moments the agencies of two states and the federal government have to agree on who does what. The same island, with the same history, simply has two sets of local paperwork.
Why the case drew attention
Three reasons made the case a favorite of historians and lawyers.
- It turned on a treaty that was old and short. The 1834 compact, a short document, controlled how a twentieth-century fact was classified. The justices had to decide what two states in 1833 would have intended about land that did not exist yet.
- It was symbolic. Ellis Island is one of the most visited places in American history. The idea that it sits partly in New Jersey surprised many people, including residents of the state, and the ruling gave Jersey City a new claim on a national landmark.
- It showed how states settle fights. Two sovereign states cannot sue in an ordinary court. They go to the Supreme Court, and the case is in a sense a diplomatic agreement settled by a judge. The two states had a long record of cooperation, including the Port Authority, and the boundary fight was settled without much rancor.
The wider river story
The dispute is one chapter in a long argument between the two states over the water between them. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, created in 1921, was designed to manage shared transportation and port facilities; see The Port Authority of 1921: how two states agreed to share a harbor and Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. The bridges and tunnels that cross the Hudson, from the Holland Tunnel to the George Washington Bridge, are described in bridges and tunnels, 1926 to 1937 and Crossing to New York: bridges, tunnels and tolls. The boundary itself dates back to the colonial grants, a story told in 1664: how New Netherland became New Jersey, which also covers the long colonial border dispute between the provinces.
For the history of the island as an immigration station, see Ellis Island, 1892 to 1954. For the visit, A day at Ellis Island and Liberty State Park and Liberty State Park, the best seat in the house for the Statue of Liberty cover the New Jersey side of the water, and Jersey City has the city's own context. The Supreme Court is the top of the court system described in New Jersey Judiciary, though the court that decided this case was the federal one in Washington, not the state's.
A short summary
- 1834: Congress approves the compact between the states setting the boundary in the middle of the Hudson and harbor.
- 1892 to 1954: The immigration station operates and the island is enlarged by landfill.
- 1998: On May 26 the Supreme Court rules 6 to 3 for New Jersey on the filled land.
- Result: About 22.80 acres in Jersey City, New Jersey, and about 4.68 acres in New York.
- Today: The federal government owns and runs the island, and visitors see one national museum on a split piece of ground.