Blog

1664: how New Netherland became New Jersey

From Hudson's 1609 voyage through the Dutch posts at Pavonia and Bergen and New Sweden to the English fleet that seized New Netherland and created New Jersey.

The state of New Jersey has a name that could only have come from an accident of English politics. It is not a Native word, not a Dutch one, and not an old name for the land. It comes from a small island in the English Channel, and it was attached to this ground in 1664 by a royal proprietor who had never seen it and the two courtiers he gave it to. Before that, for roughly half a century, the land between the Hudson and the Delaware belonged to a Dutch colony with a different name, and its first settlements were built by people who expected to stay.

The change of name is the end of one story and the beginning of another, and it happened without much of a battle. This is how it went.

1609: a river, a bay and a claim

In 1609 Henry Hudson, an Englishman hired by the Dutch East India Company, explored Delaware Bay and then the river that would take his name. His reports gave the Dutch a basis for a claim. Earlier, in 1524, the Italian navigator Giovanni da Verrazzano had sailed the coast for France and recorded the shore, but the French did not follow with settlers. The Dutch did. The Dutch West India Company, formed to profit from the fur trade, conceived the colony of New Netherland in 1621, and its claim stretched from the Delmarva Peninsula to Cape Cod.

The land was not empty. The Lenape before 1609 describes the people who already lived here and traded furs for iron tools and wampum with the newcomers. The Dutch built Fort Nassau in the 1620s on the Delaware, near present-day Gloucester City, and settlement on the Hudson side was limited at first by Lenape resistance and by the company's own mismanagement.

The Dutch settlements on the Hudson side

The Dutch center of gravity was Manhattan, but their farms and trading posts spread across the water. In 1630 a settlement was established at Paulus Hook, at the site of today's Jersey City, within an area the Dutch called Pavonia. The early years were violent: conflicts with the Lenape, including Kieft's War of 1643 to 1645, and European diseases reduced the native population and set back the settlers.

By the 1650s the colony had stabilized enough to try again. In January 1658, Director-General Peter Stuyvesant re-purchased most of the land that became Bergen, and in 1660 a village was officially settled on a hilltop west of Communipaw. The village was laid out as a square, 800 feet on a side, with a wooden palisade, by Jacques Cortelyou, New Amsterdam's surveyor. In September 1661 Bergen received a charter that gave it a court of justice, which is why it is often described as the oldest autonomous municipality in the state. The full story of that charter and the grid that survives at Bergen Square is in bergen, 1661: the state's oldest municipality, and Jersey City covers the city that grew around it.

New Sweden

The Dutch were not the only European presence on the Delaware. In 1638 Sweden founded a colony, New Sweden, on the river, and for seventeen years it held a stretch of ground that the Dutch also claimed. The competition ended in 1655, when Stuyvesant's forces overpowered the Swedes. By the 1650s the Dutch controlled the Delaware, the Hudson and everything between.

The Dutch colony had grown. Its population rose from about 350 in 1630 to 4,301 in 1650, and reached roughly 8,000 to 9,000 by 1674, not counting Native Americans. The colonists were Dutch, Walloon, French Huguenot, German, Scandinavian and African, so the society was never uniform. That was a place of many languages before it was a place of English law.

1664: the fleet

England had long viewed New Netherland as a wedge between its northern and southern colonies. In 1664, during the Second Anglo-Dutch War, it moved. Charles II gave his brother James, the Duke of York, a grant of the territory in March, and an English fleet commanded by Richard Nicolls sailed for New Amsterdam that summer.

Stuyvesant, the colony's director-general, did not have the troops to resist. The English took the town, which became New York, in September 1664, and the articles of surrender were generous. They protected religious liberty, promising that settlers could keep and enjoy the liberty of their consciences in religion, and they left property and customs in place. The Dutch settlers on the Jersey side became English subjects without having been moved.

The Duke gives it away

The Duke of York did not keep the land west of the Hudson. In June 1664, even before the conquest was complete, he granted it to two of his friends and supporters, Sir George Carteret and John, Lord Berkeley, who became its proprietors. Carteret had been governor of the Isle of Jersey in the Channel, a place that had sheltered the royalist cause during the English Civil War, and the new province was named for it: New Jersey, a Latin form of which was Nova Caesarea.

The proprietors moved quickly to attract settlers. Philip Carteret, a relative of Sir George, became the first governor and made Elizabeth the capital. In 1665 a document called the Concession and Agreement offered religious freedom and a measure of self-government to colonists, a generous deal designed to fill the land with tenants who paid rent to the proprietors. The first English towns, Elizabethtown and its neighbors, were settled by people from New England and Long Island, and the Dutch farms at Bergen continued as before. Elizabeth and Perth Amboy hold the earliest English-era settlements, and Perth Amboy later became a proprietary capital.

The Dutch return, briefly

The story had one more twist. In 1673, during the Third Anglo-Dutch War, the Dutch retook the colony and renamed New York as New Orange. The reconquest lasted barely a year. Under the Treaty of Westminster in 1674 the territory went back to England for good. In the meantime the Duke of York had to confirm his grant of the land, and the proprietors' title was reissued.

What followed that settlement was a quarter century of division. In 1674 Lord Berkeley sold his share to Quakers, and the province split into East and West Jersey, two proprietary halves that would not rejoin until 1702. That story is told in East and West Jersey, 1674 to 1702.

The sequence at a glance

Year What happened
1524 Verrazzano explores the coast for France
1609 Hudson explores for the Dutch East India Company
1621 The Dutch West India Company conceives New Netherland
1620s Fort Nassau on the Delaware near Gloucester City
1630 Settlement at Paulus Hook, in Pavonia
1638 Sweden founds New Sweden on the Delaware
1655 Stuyvesant's forces overpower New Sweden
1660 to 1661 Bergen settled, then chartered with a court of justice
1664 English fleet takes New Amsterdam; the Duke of York grants the land to Berkeley and Carteret
1665 Concession and Agreement offers religious freedom and self-government
1673 to 1674 Dutch retake the colony, then return it under the Treaty of Westminster

Traces on the ground

Very little of Dutch New Jersey is standing, but some of it is. The grid of old Bergen, 800 feet on a side, can still be read at Bergen Square in Jersey City, and the Old Bergen Church stands nearby, near the site where the original village's congregation and school began. The area also holds the Newkirk House, built in 1690 and counted as the oldest structure in Jersey City. The English side has its own survivals in Elizabeth, where the province's first capital stood, and in the old proprietary town of Perth Amboy.

These are modest remains, and they are worth seeing because they are so ordinary: a square, a church, a farmhouse. The empires that fought over the land left a handful of buildings and a good deal of paper, and the paper is in the state's archives; see The New Jersey State Archives for what the collection holds.

Why it matters

The 1664 conquest set up features of New Jersey that still show in the map.

  • A state defined by neighbors. New Jersey was never a unified colony in the way Massachusetts or Virginia was. It began as a gift carved out of another colony's territory, and it spent the colonial period as a province caught between New York and Pennsylvania. Even in 1702, when the Crown reunited it, New York's governors oversaw New Jersey until Lewis Morris became governor of New Jersey alone in 1738.
  • A border in dispute. The line between New York and New Jersey was not settled by the grant. A long series of border skirmishes, known as the New York-New Jersey Line War, ran from 1701 to 1765, and a royal commission ended it in 1769. The legacy is still alive: the two states went to the U.S. Supreme Court in 1998 over Ellis Island, a case told in The Ellis Island boundary fight.
  • A place of mixed settlements. Dutch farms, English towns, Quaker meetings and Scottish proprietors all arrived within a few decades. That patchwork is part of the background to the state's later habit of home rule and its 564 municipalities.
  • A name with a history. The word Jersey tied this land to an English island and to a proprietor who never lived here, an odd origin for a state known for its own strong identity.

The calendar sets the dates: 1609 for Hudson, 1630 for Paulus Hook, 1660 and 1661 for Bergen, 1664 for the English fleet and the grant, 1674 for the split. Each marks a turn, and together they explain why the state's earliest chapters read like a negotiation among empires. For how the region's names and geography are used today, see North, Central and South Jersey, and the shore: the regions explained.

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic