Blog

East and West Jersey, 1674 to 1702

For 28 years New Jersey was two provinces, one run from Elizabethtown and Perth Amboy and one from Burlington, and the line between them still shapes the map.

People in New Jersey argue about where North Jersey ends and South Jersey begins, whether Central Jersey exists, and which highway counts as the border. It would surprise nobody to learn that the argument is older than the highways. From 1674 to 1702 the colony was split, formally, into two provinces with their own governors, laws, capitals and proprietors, and the quarrels over where one stopped and the other started went on for most of that time. The state's habit of drawing a line through its own middle is not a joke. It is a memory.

A split that began with a sale

The province had been a gift. In 1664 the Duke of York granted the land between the Hudson and the Delaware to two friends of the Stuart cause, Sir George Carteret and John, Lord Berkeley, and the new proprietors set about attracting settlers. 1664: how New Netherland became New Jersey tells how that happened. Then the Dutch briefly retook the colony in 1673 and gave it back to the English in 1674, and the proprietors' partnership did not survive the interruption.

On March 18, 1674, Berkeley sold his half of the province to a pair of Quakers, John Fenwick and Edward Byllynge. The sale divided the colony. Carteret kept the eastern portion, looking toward the Hudson and New York harbor, which became East Jersey. The Quaker purchasers held the western portion, facing the Delaware River, which became West Jersey. Each half had its own proprietors, its own governor, and its own constitution.

The first line between them was drawn in 1676 in a document called the Quintipartite Deed, so named because it had five parties. It was meant to run from the Atlantic coast near Little Egg Harbor to a point on the Delaware far to the north. It left a good deal of room for argument.

East Jersey: Elizabethtown, Perth Amboy and a Scottish turn

East Jersey was the older, more settled half. Philip Carteret, the first governor of the province, had made Elizabethtown his capital, and from 1674 to 1682 he governed East Jersey. In 1675 the province was divided into four counties, Bergen, Essex, Middlesex and Monmouth, and the settlements there drew people from New England and Long Island, as well as the Dutch families already at Bergen.

The turn came in 1682. East Jersey was sold again, this time to a group of investors, including many Scottish proprietors, and Robert Barclay, a prominent Scottish Quaker, became governor, serving until 1688. Barclay and his colleagues set out to build a new capital on the Raritan Bay at what became Perth Amboy, named for the Earl of Perth, one of the investors, and the Amboy of the old Lenape place name. They wanted a deepwater port to rival New York. In 1687 King James II gave Perth Amboy the right to clear ships directly, which was a real prize in a world where New York wanted to control the harbor.

A survey of 1684 estimated East Jersey's population at about 3,500 people in roughly 700 families, a count that excluded enslaved Africans. That number is small by any later standard, and it is a reminder that the province was a collection of farm settlements and a few small towns. See Perth Amboy and Elizabeth for the places that carry the East Jersey story.

West Jersey: the Quaker half

West Jersey was thin on settlers until the English took over from the Dutch in 1664, and then it filled in from the river. Quaker families settled in large numbers beginning in the late 1670s, first in what is now Salem County and then in Burlington. Burlington became the capital of West Jersey, and Burlington County was formed in 1694.

The founders of West Jersey wanted a model of Quaker principles. The Concessions and Agreements of 1677, a founding document that William Penn and other Quaker proprietors helped write, set out an elected assembly, trial by jury and a broad religious freedom. It was a more democratic framework than most colonies had, and it fit a settlement meant for people who were fleeing persecution in England. The Delaware River towns of South Jersey, including the ones around present-day Camden, took their early shape in this period.

The line that never quite held

The boundary between the two provinces was the persistent problem. The Quintipartite Deed set a line in 1676. A later survey in 1687, known as the Keith Line after the surveyor George Keith, was run north only as far as the south branch of the Raritan River. A different line, the Coxe-Barclay Line, followed in 1688. West Jersey and East Jersey each claimed ground the other thought was theirs, and the disputes were never fully resolved before the provinces came together.

The same logic produced a loose cultural boundary that outlasted the provincial one. East Jersey faced New York, and in later centuries the northeast became the orbit of New York City. West Jersey faced Philadelphia, and the southwest became the orbit of the Philadelphia region. The dividing line the state's residents argue about today, between North and Central and South Jersey, runs about where the old frontier did, which is why people still ask whether Trenton belongs to one side or the other. North, Central and South Jersey, and the shore: the regions explained lays out the state's regions as people use the words today.

The two provinces side by side

East Jersey West Jersey
Faced New York harbor and the Hudson The Delaware River and Philadelphia
Capital Elizabethtown at first, then Perth Amboy Burlington
First settlers Dutch farmers at Bergen, then New Englanders and Long Islanders Quakers, beginning in the late 1670s
Proprietors Carteret, then from 1682 a group with many Scots Quaker purchasers, Fenwick and Byllynge
Counties named Bergen, Essex, Middlesex and Monmouth (1675) Burlington County formed in 1694
Character Older, more settled, mixed English and Dutch Newer, Quaker, with a written frame of liberties

The timeline in short

  • 1664. The Duke of York grants the land to Berkeley and Carteret.
  • 1673 to 1674. The Dutch retake and then return the colony.
  • March 18, 1674. Berkeley sells his half to Fenwick and Byllynge.
  • 1675. East Jersey creates its four counties.
  • 1676. The Quintipartite Deed sets the first boundary.
  • 1677. West Jersey's Concessions and Agreements are issued.
  • 1682. East Jersey passes to a new group of proprietors; Barclay becomes governor.
  • 1687 to 1688. The Keith and Coxe-Barclay lines are surveyed.
  • 1688 to 1689. East Jersey is folded into the Dominion of New England.
  • April 15, 1702. The proprietors surrender government and the two provinces unite.

Troubles and the end of proprietary rule

The proprietary system struggled. Quarrels among proprietors, disputes with settlers over land titles and quit-rents, and problems with the colony's governors accumulated. In 1688 and 1689 East Jersey was governed as part of the Dominion of New England under Edmund Andros, an experiment that created unrest. In the 1690s a series of governors tried to keep order. Andrew Hamilton governed from 1692 to 1697, then Jeremiah Basse from 1698 to 1699, then Hamilton again from 1699 to 1702.

In West Jersey the story was similar. A period of prolonged violence, at the end of the seventeenth century, weakened the proprietors' hold. By 1700 it was clear that neither proprietary government was able to keep the peace. The proprietors still held the land, but they were ready to give up government.

April 15, 1702: the surrender

On April 15, 1702, the proprietors of both East and West Jersey surrendered their rights of government to Queen Anne's government. The two provinces were joined as one royal colony. The land titles remained with the proprietors, who kept the right to divide unsettled land. That is why proprietary boards continue, in a modest form, to exist in the state to this day. What the Crown took was the power to govern, not the soil.

The first royal governor, Lord Cornbury, proved corrupt and was recalled in 1708. For years the governors of New York also governed New Jersey, and the arrangement did not end until Lewis Morris became governor of New Jersey alone in 1738. The government of the united colony met alternately in the old capitals, Perth Amboy and Burlington, a reminder of the two halves. Trenton did not become the capital until later, and Princeton and Trenton as national capitals, 1783 and 1784 covers the first brush with that role.

What remains

The two-province period was short, 28 years, but it left lasting marks.

  • A habit of regions. North, Central and South Jersey, and the borderline arguments, echo an old divide.
  • Two river orientations. New Jersey still looks two ways, to New York and to Philadelphia, as East and West Jersey did.
  • Proprietary land law. The legal system of land titles that goes back to the proprietors still appears in New Jersey's property records.
  • Double capitals. The two capitals under royal rule explain why the colonial government was always on the move.
  • A tradition of toleration. The Quaker and Scottish proprietors' promises of religious freedom, written into the founding documents, set a tone of toleration that the later colony kept.

That is a lot of inheritance from a short chapter. When someone insists that the state is really two states, or three, they are repeating a debate that began in a Quaker land sale in March 1674.

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic