Blog
Princeton and Trenton as national capitals, 1783 and 1784
How an unpaid mob in Philadelphia sent Congress to Princeton in 1783 and why Trenton hosted it for eight weeks in 1784 while two capitals were debated.
For a short time after the Revolution, the government of the United States rented rooms in New Jersey. Twice, in 1783 and again in 1784, the Continental Congress, which was then the whole of the national government, met in a New Jersey town because there was nowhere better to go. Princeton had it for about four months. Trenton had it for about eight weeks. Neither was ever a capital in the sense that Washington, D.C., would later be, but each held the title of seat of the government for a stretch, and that is why New Jersey still teases the neighbors about it.
The two stays at a glance
| Date | Where | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| June 21, 1783 | Philadelphia | Unpaid soldiers surround the State House; Congress votes to leave |
| June 30, 1783 | Princeton | Congress opens its sessions at Nassau Hall |
| Late July 1783 | Princeton | Relations opened with Sweden, after news of the peace treaty arrives |
| August 26, 1783 | Princeton | Washington addresses Congress, staying at Rockingham in Rocky Hill |
| September 15, 1783 | Princeton | Virginia's western land cession accepted |
| October 1783 | Princeton | Plan for two capitals, on the Delaware and the Potomac |
| November 4, 1783 | Princeton | Last day in town; Congress goes on to Annapolis |
| November 1, 1784 | Trenton | Congress opens at the French Arms Tavern |
| December 24, 1784 | Trenton | Congress adjourns to New York for January 11, 1785 |
The college Congress borrowed was itself a New Jersey story. The College of New Jersey was founded in Elizabethtown in 1746 and moved to Princeton in 1756, and by 1783 Nassau Hall was its main building. Congress was not so much choosing a capital as choosing the biggest roof in reach.
Saturday, June 21, 1783
The reason Congress was in Princeton at all is that it was run out of Philadelphia. Soldiers of the Continental Army, posted in Pennsylvania, had not been paid, and in the summer of 1783 hundreds of them gathered around the Pennsylvania State House, where Congress was meeting in a special Saturday session, to demand their back pay. The Pennsylvania authorities would not call out the state militia to disperse them. Delegates leaving the building that afternoon walked through jeering soldiers.
Congress reacted by getting out of town. That same evening the delegates voted unanimously to adjourn across the Delaware into New Jersey. The president of Congress, Elias Boudinot, himself a New Jerseyan and a trustee of the College of New Jersey, picked Princeton from the two options on the table, Princeton and Trenton. The delegates met in Princeton for the first time on June 30, and they stayed until November 4. A lot happened in those four months.
Nassau Hall as a capitol
The college, today's Princeton University, then centered on Nassau Hall. The college's own history says Congress met mainly in the library on the second floor. Delegates also met at Prospect, a farmhouse belonging to Colonel George Morgan on the edge of town. This arrangement was a long way from the splendor of Philadelphia's State House, and the delegates noticed.
The politics of the moment were large. News of the peace treaty with Britain, which was highly favorable to the new country, arrived that summer and formally ended the Revolution. In late July, Congress opened diplomatic relations with Sweden, the first neutral European country to recognize the United States. In September, Congress accepted Virginia's cession of its western land claims, on the principle that the future western states would enter the Union on equal terms. In October it forbade private land purchases from Native Americans without federal approval.
The best-known visit was Washington's. Congress invited him in July to receive its thanks, and he arrived in August, staying at Rockingham, a rented house in Rocky Hill about five miles north of Princeton. On August 26 he appeared before Congress at Nassau Hall, and Boudinot read a speech of welcome and gratitude. Townspeople cheered him as he rode up Nassau Street. It was one of the few occasions on which the commander of the army and the civilian government met in the same room in a town that was neither's own.
The first plan for two capitals
In October 1783 Congress also took a decision that matters for the later story. It resolved to divide the permanent seat of the government between two sites, one on the Delaware near Trenton and one on the Potomac. The idea was a compromise between North and South, and it kept people arguing for years. Congress did not stay long enough to build either. For Trenton, the Delaware site was a real hope, and that is the background to what happened in 1784.
Why Princeton did not last
The honest version is that Princeton did not work as a capital. The town was small, lodging was cramped and scattered, and taverns could not supply enough meals. Boudinot reportedly remarked on June 30, the day the first session opened, that the place "would not do." Citizens of the town petitioned Congress to stay through the winter. Congress ignored them and moved on, first to Annapolis, Maryland, where it sat from late November 1783 until June 1784, and then to Trenton in the fall.
Small as it was, Princeton gained something from the stay. The college's seat of learning had been a battle site in 1777 and was now the place where the national government met. That chain of events is part of why Nassau Hall is a landmark, and the Battle of Princeton on January 3, 1777, is covered in The crossing, Trenton and Princeton: December 25, 1776 to January 3, 1777.
November 1, 1784: Trenton
Trenton's turn came after Annapolis. Congress sat in Trenton from November 1 to December 24, 1784, in a building known then as the French Arms Tavern. It stood at the southwest corner of King Street, now Warren Street, and Second Street, now State Street, in the middle of the town. John Dagworthy had built it as a residence in the early 1730s, and it later became a tavern. In 1784 a legislative commission of the State of New Jersey leased it to Congress, and the Long Room, the largest space in the house, was refitted as the assembly hall.
What did Congress do in Trenton? Mostly it tried to assemble a quorum. Much of its time went to appeals to the states to send delegates at all, and there was some talk about building a federal city. It continued to run foreign affairs and discussed sending ministers to London and Madrid. On December 24 it adjourned to meet in New York City on January 11, 1785.
The tavern changed hands soon afterward. Francis Witt leased it on January 4, 1785, and renamed it the Blazing Star. It is the same building where, three years later, the New Jersey convention met to ratify the Constitution, and that story is told in Ratification: the third state, December 18, 1787.
A town that hoped
Trenton had the better argument for the Delaware site. It was a river town with a ferry crossing, on the road between Philadelphia and New York, at the head of navigation on the Delaware. A historical marker in the city calls the winter of 1784-85 the time when Trenton was briefly a leading candidate to become the national capital. It was not to be. Congress went north to New York, and the idea of a Delaware capital faded and was gone with the Constitution of 1787 and the District of Columbia on the Potomac.
Why a state still cares
Why dwell on two small episodes? Because they show how strange the early republic was. The national government was a committee that could not collect its own taxes, could not pay its own soldiers, and had to rent its rooms from state legislatures and innkeepers. Governors and legislatures held the real power, and the state of New Jersey was the one that provided the roof when Congress was homeless.
That relationship between the state and the national government is still the subject of New Jersey's civics, which is why the state's own structure is worth understanding. The Legislature that leased the French Arms Tavern is the ancestor of the one that meets in Trenton today, covered in The New Jersey Legislature, and Trenton's role as the capital is explored in Trenton. The Princeton side of the story, including the town and the university, is in Princeton.
Seeing it today
Nassau Hall still stands on the Princeton campus, and it is open to visitors; check Princeton University's visitor information for the current hours of the building. The French Arms Tavern stood at what is now the corner of Warren and State Streets in downtown Trenton, and a historical marker there notes the Congress that met in it. The State House, a few blocks west, is the capitol of the state, and the New Jersey State Archives and State Museum are near it; see The New Jersey State Archives and The New Jersey State Museum for the institutions that keep the older records.
A good short route for a history-minded day is to start in Princeton, where Nassau Hall and Rockingham in Rocky Hill tell the 1783 story, and then drive down Route 206 and then Route 1 or I-295 to Trenton for the 1784 corner. The trip is about the same distance Congress traveled, in one afternoon instead of six months.