Blog

Ratification: the third state, December 18, 1787

New Jersey's convention met at a Trenton tavern, voted unanimously on December 18, 1787, and two years later became first to ratify the Bill of Rights.

New Jersey likes to remind people that it was third. Delaware ratified the new Constitution on December 7, 1787, and Pennsylvania followed on December 12. Six days later, on Tuesday, December 18, New Jersey made it three, and it did so without a single dissenting vote. The story is worth telling in some detail, because it played out in a Trenton tavern that had already hosted the national government once.

What New Jersey brought to Philadelphia

The Constitution did not arrive in the state as a surprise. New Jersey had sent a delegation to the Philadelphia convention, and four of its members signed the finished document on September 17, 1787: William Livingston, David Brearley, William Paterson and Jonathan Dayton. A fifth, William Churchill Houston, had attended part of the summer.

Paterson matters most. On June 15, 1787, he laid before the convention what became known as the New Jersey Plan, an alternative to the larger-state design from Virginia. Where the Virginia plan would have based representation in the national legislature on population, the New Jersey Plan kept the Confederation's model of one state, one vote. The delegates did not adopt it, but the debate led to the compromise that gave the House seats by population and the Senate two seats per state. For a small state, with 13 counties at the time and a long record of being squeezed between New York and Philadelphia, that equal Senate vote was a real concession. It is a major reason the ratification went the way it did.

The convention in Trenton

The state legislature called a convention to consider the Constitution and set elections of delegates in each of the thirteen counties then existing. Thirty-nine delegates were chosen, three from each county. On Tuesday, December 11, 1787, they began to gather at Francis Witt's tavern in Trenton, the Blazing Star, a large building at the corner of King and Second Streets. It was the same building that Congress had met in three years earlier as the French Arms Tavern, a story told in Princeton and Trenton as national capitals, 1783 and 1784. Witt had renamed it the Blazing Star in January 1785, and in December 1787 it again served as the town's biggest meeting place.

Thirty-eight of the thirty-nine were present. Only Samuel Dick of Salem County did not attend. The convention chose John Stevens of Hunterdon County as its president and Samuel W. Stockton as its secretary. It sat for a week, and on December 18 voted to ratify.

The signers

The document of ratification, signed that day, lists the delegates by county. It is a map of the state as it stood in the 1780s:

County Delegates
Hunterdon John Stevens (president), David Brearley, Joshua Corshon
Bergen John Fell, Peter Zabriskie, Cornelius Hennion
Essex John Chetwood, Samuel Hay, David Crane
Middlesex John Neilson, John Beatty, Benjamin Manning
Monmouth Elisha Lawrence, Samuel Breese, William Crawford
Somerset John Witherspoon, Jacob R. Hardenbergh, Frederick Frelinghuysen
Burlington Thomas Reynolds, George Anderson, Joshua M. Wallace
Gloucester R. D. Howell, Andrew Hunter, Benjamin Whitall
Salem Whitten Cripps, Edmund Wetherby
Cape May Jesse Hand, Jeremiah Eldredge, Matthew Whilldin
Morris William Windes, William Woodhull, John Jacob Faesch
Cumberland David Potter, Jonathan Bowen, Eli Elmer
Sussex Robert Ogden, Thomas Anderson, Robert Hoops

Two names will be familiar. David Brearley sat in the Philadelphia convention and signed the Constitution there, and John Witherspoon, the Presbyterian minister who led the College of New Jersey at Princeton, signed the Declaration of Independence in 1776. Look at the counties, too. Hudson, Atlantic, Ocean, Union, Passaic, Camden, Mercer and Warren are not on this list because they did not exist yet.

The wording of the document is short. The delegates, "by the unanimous consent of the members present," agreed to and ratified the Constitution on behalf of the people of New Jersey. A small correction on the page shows the care taken; the words "Cession of" were written in between the lines on the second sheet before the signing.

How ratification worked

Ratification was a state-by-state affair, and the rules were set in the Constitution itself. Article VII required the approval of conventions in nine of the thirteen states before the new government could take effect among them. That meant the order in which states voted mattered less than the count, but the early votes set the mood. Delaware, Pennsylvania and New Jersey, all small or middling states with a stake in a stronger union, voted within twelve days of each other in December 1787. Georgia and Connecticut followed in January 1788.

The Confederation Congress certified the result in September 1788, when eleven states had ratified, and it set March 4, 1789, as the day the new government would begin. North Carolina waited until after the first Congress had passed the Bill of Rights, and Rhode Island ratified only after a trade embargo was threatened. Against that background, New Jersey's quick and unanimous vote looks like what it was: the state's leaders thought the new frame of government was an improvement and saw no reason to wait.

The state before the vote

The state that voted was a different one from the New Jersey of today. It was divided, as it still is, between a northern half oriented toward New York and a southern half oriented toward Philadelphia, and its center was the road between the two, the route now followed by the Northeast Corridor and the Turnpike. It had been governed since 1776 under its first constitution, which was drafted in the days before July 4 of that year. A second constitution followed in 1844 and the third, the one in use now, in 1947.

That history is why New Jerseyans have always had a pointed view of national power. The state had been the cockpit of the war, from Trenton and Princeton to Monmouth and Morristown. Its farms had fed the armies and its towns had quartered them; for the people who lived there, the argument for a government that could pay its debts was not abstract. To understand the winter that the army spent in the state, see Washington's winters at Morristown.

Why unanimous?

The vote was not an accident. New Jersey had spent the 1780s as a state that paid the price of the Confederation's weakness. Contemporaries often argued that New York and Philadelphia collected duties on goods New Jerseyans consumed, because so much of the state's trade passed through their ports. A national government with the power to regulate commerce and collect a common tariff was an obvious benefit.

The second reason was the small-state compromise. New Jersey had insisted that a state's voice in the Senate be equal, and it got it. Once the delegates saw the Senate they could vote for the document in good conscience.

Across the country, critics of the Constitution complained that it had no bill of rights. In New Jersey the objections did not block the vote, and the state's own accounts describe the outcome as unanimous among the delegates present.

The first to ratify the Bill of Rights

The state's first-in-the-nation distinction came two years later. In 1789 Congress sent the states twelve proposed amendments. The New Jersey Legislature acted quickly, and on November 20, 1789, New Jersey became the first state to ratify the amendments that came to be known as the Bill of Rights. The decision was made in the state's legislature, not in a special convention, as the Constitution allows. Ratification by the necessary three-quarters of the states was completed in 1791.

So New Jersey can claim two firsts of a kind: the third state to ratify the Constitution, and the first to ratify the amendments that give it its guarantees of individual liberty. A good deal of the state's later history has turned on its own constitution as well; see the 1947 constitution and the state it built, which tells how the third and current constitution replaced the 1844 charter.

The anniversary

December 18 is not a major holiday in the state, and it competes with the run-up to Christmas. But it is a good day to go back to the document and the story of the convention. New Jerseyans who want to look at the founding moment at first hand have several options. Trenton has the archives, the State House and the downtown tavern corner. Princeton has Nassau Hall, where Congress had met four years earlier. Morristown and Monmouth County have the battle and camp sites that made the argument for a stronger union concrete.

The date is also a useful corrective. When people say that New Jersey is a state with no history of its own, hemmed in by New York and Philadelphia, the answer is that it was among the very first to say yes to the Constitution, and the first to say yes to the Bill of Rights.

How to see the documents

The ratification document and the convention minutes are part of the State Archives' collections in Trenton, in the Department of State, and the Archives has mounted exhibits on the state's role in the founding. The way the Archives work and who can use them is in The New Jersey State Archives. For the present-day Legislature, the descendant of the body that called the convention, see The New Jersey Legislature, and for the courts that interpret the state's constitution see New Jersey Judiciary.

The corner of Warren and State Streets in downtown Trenton is where the convention met; look for the historical markers there. Trenton's capital district is described in Trenton. If you stand there on December 18, you are in the right place for the anniversary of the day New Jersey voted, with no one against it, to join the Union under the Constitution.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic