Blog
The Port Authority of 1921: how two states agreed to share a harbor
How a freight-rate lawsuit led New York and New Jersey to the first interstate compact agency, and the bridges, tunnels and airports that followed.
The most consequential agency in the New Jersey and New York region began with a fight about railroad freight rates. In 1916 New Jersey sued New York, arguing that the rates charged to move goods across the harbor discriminated against the Jersey side, where most of the rail lines ended and the freight had to be floated across the water on lighters. The Interstate Commerce Commission, which heard the dispute, did something unusual for a regulator. It told the two states to stop litigating and start cooperating.
That order is the root of the Port of New York Authority, which most people now call the Port Authority. It was created on April 30, 1921, by a compact between the two states, and it was the first agency of its kind in the country: an interstate body created under the clause of the U.S. Constitution that lets states make compacts with each other, with the consent of Congress. A century later it runs the Hudson crossings, the region's major airports, the container ports and the PATH trains. For the agency as it stands in 2026, the government record covers the structure. This piece covers how it started.
A harbor with two governments
By the 1910s the Port of New York was a physical unit and a political mess. Ships tied up on both sides of the bay. Rail lines from the west stopped on the New Jersey shore, in places such as Jersey City and Hoboken, while the money, the warehouses and the city's largest market sat in Manhattan. Cars and cargo crossed by float and ferry. Every improvement needed two legislatures, two governors and two sets of local interests to agree, and they rarely did.
A Harbor Development Commission, set up in 1917, studied the problem and recommended a single bi-state authority to plan and manage the port as one district. The idea was not a government that would replace the states. It was a public corporation that would take on specific jobs, borrow money for them and pay the debts out of what the projects earned. The compact signed in 1921 followed that outline. It was approved by both state legislatures and by Congress, and its first chairman, from 1921 to 1924, was Eugenius Harvey Outerbridge, a businessman whose name is now carried by one of the Staten Island crossings.
The early years were not triumphant. The Authority's first big plan, a belt of rail freight lines and terminals around the harbor, never got built the way its authors wanted, because the railroads would not cooperate and the Authority had no power to compel them. What saved the agency was a change of subject. If it could not rebuild the rail system, it could build the roads and crossings that were becoming more important every year, and charge a toll to pay for them.
The crossings come first
The first crossing built under the Authority's name, as distinct from the ones it later took over, went up between Staten Island and New Jersey. The Goethals Bridge, named for the chief engineer of the Panama Canal, and the Outerbridge Crossing both opened in 1928. They were meant to tie Staten Island to the Jersey road network and the Pennsylvania routes beyond it, and they gave the young agency its first toll revenue and its first track record in the municipal bond market. Goethals, Bayonne and Outerbridge: the Staten Island crossings compared follows these three Staten Island crossings through the years.
The Holland Tunnel, which opened in 1927, was not a Port Authority project. It was built by a separate bi-state commission, but it had a problem that the Port Authority could solve: it was a toll road whose revenue and management were an awkward fit for a commission set up only to finish the job. In 1930 the Port Authority took control of the tunnel, and its toll receipts became the foundation of the agency's finances.
The next large project was the one that put the Authority in the public mind. The George Washington Bridge, designed under chief engineer Othmar Ammann and opened in October 1931, was finished ahead of schedule and under its estimated cost, and the agency's engineers got credit for both. The Bayonne Bridge opened the same year. Six years later, in 1937, the Lincoln Tunnel opened as a single tube, with a second tube following in 1945. You can read the full engineering story of the biggest of these in The George Washington Bridge, 1931 to the $16.79 toll and The Holland and Lincoln tunnels, and a wider survey of the decade in bridges and tunnels, 1926 to 1937.
What mattered to the Authority's finances was not just the number of crossings, but the way the bonds worked. In 1935 it issued general and refunding bonds secured by all of its revenues rather than the earnings of a single bridge. That let it pool the money from busy crossings and borrow against the whole, a model that would carry it through the next ninety years. It also gave the Authority a permanent interest in growing traffic. A toll-funded agency that borrows against its crossings has every reason to build more of them.
Airports, then trains
The Authority's job grew in the 1940s. In 1939 LaGuardia Field was already close to capacity, and the city of New York wanted someone with money to expand its airports. On May 31, 1947, a 50-year lease from New York City took effect, giving the Authority LaGuardia, Idlewild (which became John F. Kennedy International) and Floyd Bennett Field. It turned the airports into self-supporting enterprises, and the Authority added Newark Liberty, which it operates under a lease from the cities of Newark and Elizabeth. By 2025 Newark Liberty served about 47 million passengers, the third-busiest year in its history, including a record 15.4 million international passengers. The history of that airport is in Newark Liberty at 47 million passengers.
The Port Authority's most notable change of subject came in 1962, when it took over the bankrupt Hudson and Manhattan Railroad and reorganized it as PATH. That was a rail line, after all, which is what the agency had been created to deal with, though by an odd route. The same period brought the rights to build the original World Trade Center. PATH today runs Newark to the World Trade Center, Journal Square to 33rd Street and Hoboken to both 33rd Street and the World Trade Center; the single fare rose to $3.25 in May 2026. See Riding PATH between New Jersey and New York for the practical side, and PATH's fare path to four dollars by 2029 for the fare schedule the Authority approved.
Who runs it, and who answers
The Port Authority is governed by a board of commissioners, with each state's governor appointing six. The commissioners must be confirmed by their state's senate, serve overlapping six-year terms and are unpaid. Each governor holds a veto over the actions of the commissioners from his or her own state, which means a decision usually needs the blessing of both statehouses to go forward. By an informal arrangement the New Jersey governor picks the chairman and the deputy executive director, and the New York governor picks the vice chairman and the executive director.
That structure is the source of most of the Authority's reputation, for better and for worse. Supporters say it is the only body that could build and run a regional system of bridges, tunnels, airports and ports across a state line, and that a century of paying its own way proves the point. Critics point out that an agency answerable to two governors and no legislature can be hard to audit and slow to turn away from a project, and that New Jersey drivers who pay the highest tolls are not always the ones who use the airports, bus terminals or ports the money supports. Both arguments are about the same design choice made in 1921, to give the harbor one body with the power to tax itself through tolls and fares.
The port itself
The harbor that sent two states to court is still the Authority's reason for existing. The Port of New York and New Jersey handled about 5.96 million loaded containers in 2025 and roughly 8.9 million containers in all, second in the nation by loaded volume. The Port Newark-Elizabeth Marine Terminal, built in the 1950s on the New Jersey side, was by 1985 the busiest container port in the world, a record that tells you how far the freight business had moved to the Jersey shore of the harbor. The 1916 lawsuit had been about freight rates, and the answer the region found was to build the largest freight facilities in the world on the side that had been disadvantaged. See Inside Port Newark and the Elizabeth Marine Terminal for how the terminals work.
What the date means
April 30 is not a holiday and nobody takes a day off. But the 1921 compact is the reason a commuter can cross three kinds of structure, a bridge, a tunnel and an underground rail line, and pay a single agency for the trip. It is also the reason the same agency is the target of the region's longest-running arguments over tolls, fares and priorities. When a Port Authority commissioner from Trenton and one from Albany disagree about where to spend a billion dollars, they are working inside the structure the two states built in 1921, to settle a problem about freight that neither could solve alone.
The official history, board information and current toll schedules are on the Port Authority's own site, panynj.gov.