Blog
Goethals, Bayonne and Outerbridge: the Staten Island crossings compared
Three Port Authority bridges link New Jersey to Staten Island, each with a different shape, a different New Jersey end and a different job.
New Jersey touches New York by water in two places that matter to drivers: across the Hudson, where the George Washington Bridge and the tunnels carry the famous traffic, and across two narrow tidal straits on the south side of Staten Island, where three Port Authority bridges carry the rest. Nobody writes songs about the Goethals Bridge, the Bayonne Bridge or the Outerbridge Crossing. Truck drivers, port workers and people headed for the Staten Island Expressway know them by heart.
They look alike on a map: three lines drawn across the Kill Van Kull and the Arthur Kill. In practice they are three different structures with three different jobs, and the quickest way to see that is to take them one at a time, from the New Jersey end.
The quick comparison
| Goethals Bridge | Bayonne Bridge | Outerbridge Crossing | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waterway | Arthur Kill | Kill Van Kull | Arthur Kill |
| New Jersey end | Elizabeth | Bayonne | Perth Amboy |
| Opened | 1928; replaced 2017-2018 | November 15, 1931 | June 29, 1928 |
| Type | Cable-stayed twin spans | Steel through arch | Steel cantilever |
| Carries | Interstate 278 | Route 440 | Route 440 |
| Lanes | 6 | 4 | 4 |
| Toll direction | Eastbound, into New York | Southbound, into New York | Eastbound, into New York |
All three are run by the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which also runs the George Washington Bridge, the Hudson tunnels and the Newark airport. All three charge the toll in one direction only, and all three have been cashless for several years. The numbers in the table matter less than what they say about how New Jersey connects to its neighbor.
Goethals Bridge: the Elizabeth link
The Goethals Bridge joins Elizabeth, in Union County, to Howland Hook on Staten Island, about two and a half miles south of Newark Liberty International Airport on the New Jersey side. It is named for Major General George Washington Goethals, who supervised construction of the Panama Canal and later served as the Port Authority's first consulting engineer.
The first Goethals Bridge opened in 1928, a four-lane steel truss cantilever designed by John Alexander Low Waddell, with a main span of 672 feet and a width of just 62 feet. It was too narrow for modern traffic almost from the day trucks got bigger, and by the 2000s it was undersized, uncomfortable and obsolete. The Port Authority replaced it with a pair of cable-stayed spans built alongside. The old bridge closed on June 9, 2017, and the new eastbound span opened the next day. The old bridge came down starting in January 2018, and the westbound span opened on May 21, 2018.
The result is a six-lane Interstate 278 crossing 7,109 feet long, with a main span of 672 feet and more clearance below than the old bridge had. The Port Authority financed the replacement as a public-private partnership.
For drivers the Goethals matters because of what is at each end. On the New Jersey side it ties into the Turnpike near Exit 13, which is where the Turnpike meets Elizabeth, the airport and the Port Newark-Elizabeth Marine Terminal. On the Staten Island side it feeds the Staten Island Expressway and, through it, the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge to Brooklyn. The Turnpike exit by exit, from the Delaware Memorial Bridge to the GWB follows the Turnpike past Exit 13, and Inside Port Newark and the Elizabeth Marine Terminal explains the freight that crosses it.
Outerbridge Crossing: the Perth Amboy link
The Outerbridge Crossing opened on June 29, 1928, on the same day as the first Goethals Bridge. It spans the Arthur Kill between Perth Amboy and Staten Island, a few miles downstream from the Goethals. Waddell designed it too, and it was built under the Port of New York Authority, as the Port Authority was then called.
It is a steel cantilever bridge, 8,800 feet long including approaches, with a longest span of 750 feet and four lanes. It carries Route 440 on both sides of the river, which meet at the state line in the middle of the water.
The name is a small piece of local folklore. Many people assume "Outerbridge" refers to the bridge being the farthest from Manhattan, and a joke has grown around the idea. It does not. The crossing honors Eugenius Harvey Outerbridge, the first chairman of the Port Authority and a Staten Island resident. The Port Authority chose the word "crossing" for the name.
It carried about 13.66 million eastbound vehicles in 2025, roughly 38,000 a day, which is about 12 percent of the Port Authority's bridge traffic. Perth Amboy covers the Middlesex County waterfront where the crossing lands.
Bayonne Bridge: the arch over the Kill Van Kull
The Bayonne Bridge is the odd one out. It opened on November 15, 1931, the same autumn as the George Washington Bridge, and it was designed by Othmar Ammann with Cass Gilbert as architect, the same team. Its steel through arch has a main span of 1,675 feet over the Kill Van Kull, which made it the longest through-arch bridge in the world when it was finished. It connects Bayonne, in Hudson County, to Port Richmond on Staten Island, and it carries Route 440 on both sides.
Its story is about what is underneath. Ships going to and from Port Newark and the Elizabeth marine terminal sail through the Kill Van Kull, directly under the arch. For decades the bridge's clearance of 151 feet was a ceiling on the size of vessel that could reach the port. When the Panama Canal was widened, larger container ships were coming, and the Bayonne Bridge was in the way.
The Port Authority did not replace the bridge. It raised the roadway, a project that kept the arch and lifted the deck inside it by about 64 feet, from 151 to 215 feet of clearance. The clearance was reached on June 8, 2017. The northbound roadway opened in February 2017 with one lane each way, and two lanes in each direction were restored in February 2019. A pedestrian and bicycle path opened on May 24, 2019.
The Bayonne Bridge toll is collected southbound, from New Jersey to New York, with open-road gantries at the Staten Island end since 2017. For Bayonne itself, see Bayonne and Bayonne and the Bayonne Bridge.
Why they are called kills
Both straits carry the Dutch word for a channel or creek, which is a reminder that New Jersey's place names are layered. The Kill Van Kull runs between Bayonne and Staten Island and links Upper New York Bay to Newark Bay. The Arthur Kill runs south from Newark Bay along the western side of Staten Island, past Elizabeth and Perth Amboy, and out toward Raritan Bay. Together they wrap Staten Island in a loop of tidal water that the Port Authority has spent a century bridging, dredging and monitoring.
That water is the reason the bridges exist and the reason they were built the way they were. Ships still use both kills to reach Port Newark and the Elizabeth marine terminal, so a fixed span has to clear the ships. The Bayonne Bridge's arch rises high enough to give them room, which is why the arch was the right design in 1931 and why raising its deck was the right answer in 2017. The Goethals and Outerbridge bridges are cantilever and cable-stayed structures with long spans in the middle of the channel, and the water below them is a working waterway, not a view.
Three bridges, one agency
It helps to remember that the Port Authority built all three bridges in a burst between 1928 and 1931, and that the three opened within about three and a half years of each other. The agency's twin 1928 crossings, the Goethals and Outerbridge, were designed by the same engineer, John Waddell, and opened on the same day, June 29, 1928. The Bayonne Bridge followed in 1931, as the George Washington Bridge was opening to the north.
Each bridge answered a particular problem. The Goethals and Outerbridge tied the industrial Union and Middlesex County waterfront to the island's southern shore, and the Bayonne Bridge joined the island's north shore to the Hudson County peninsula. Together they closed the loop around Staten Island.
How the toll works
The three crossings follow a single rule that surprises first-time visitors: pay going to New York, not coming back. This was not always so. Tolls were once collected in both directions. In August 1970, the Port Authority abolished the westbound toll on the Goethals and Outerbridge crossings and doubled the eastbound toll, a one-way system that stayed.
Tolling is cashless. The Outerbridge Crossing went to open-road tolling on April 24, 2019, and the Goethals followed on September 4, 2019. Drivers with E-ZPass are read by sensors overhead, and cars without a tag are photographed and billed. The Port Authority lists the current Staten Island crossing rates on its tolls page. Crossing to New York: bridges, tunnels and tolls covers the whole toll system and How E-ZPass and tolls work in New Jersey explains the tags.
Which one to use
There is no single answer, which is why drivers argue about it. A few rules of thumb.
- Going to Brooklyn or the Verrazzano: the Goethals Bridge connects most directly to Interstate 278 and the Staten Island Expressway.
- Coming from the Central Jersey shore corridor: the Outerbridge Crossing joins Route 440, which meets the Garden State Parkway and Interstate 287 on the New Jersey side. Perth Amboy is the entry.
- Heading to the North Shore of Staten Island or the Bayonne peninsula: the Bayonne Bridge ties into Route 440 at Bayonne, and its path gives walkers and cyclists a way across.
- Trucks: the Goethals is the main freight route because it connects to the Turnpike and the port's roads.
All three rely on the same incident signs and the same live traffic sources, and any of them can be shut down by an accident. Check 511NJ at 511nj.org before a trip.
What the three bridges say about the state
New Jersey's relationship to New York is often described by the Hudson crossings, but the Staten Island bridges tell a slightly different story. They connect industrial, working places. Elizabeth, Perth Amboy and Bayonne are not suburbs of Manhattan, and what crosses these bridges is mostly freight, tradespeople and workers rather than commuters. The Port Authority's other big job, the airports and the port, sits behind them.
They are also a reminder of how the Port Authority was built. bridges and tunnels, 1926 to 1937 tells how its early bridges, from the 1920s and 1930s, created the agency's public role, and The George Washington Bridge, 1931 to the $16.79 toll covers the biggest of them. Two of the three have been rebuilt in the last decade: the Goethals was replaced span by span, and the Bayonne Bridge was reworked while it stayed in service. Only the Outerbridge Crossing is still the bridge it was in 1928.