Blog
Bridges and tunnels, 1926 to 1937
A timeline of the dozen years that connected New Jersey to Philadelphia, Manhattan and Staten Island, from the Ben Franklin Bridge to the Lincoln Tunnel.
Before 1926, getting a car from New Jersey to Manhattan meant a ferry. Getting one to Philadelphia meant a ferry as well. The state sat between two of the largest cities in the country and had almost no fixed way across the water to either. In a stretch of eleven and a half years, from the summer of 1926 to the winter of 1937, that changed. Two suspension bridges, two tunnels, three more bridges to Staten Island and a pair of agencies built the crossings that New Jersey commuters still use every day.
The sequence is worth walking through year by year, because each opening solved one problem and revealed the next.
1919 and 1921: the agencies come first
The structures were preceded by the institutions. In 1919 the two states on the Delaware created a Delaware River Bridge Joint Commission, the predecessor of today's Delaware River Port Authority, to build a bridge between Philadelphia and Camden. In 1921, on April 30, New York and New Jersey created the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, a bi-state agency that would take on the Hudson crossings and, in time, much else. The Port Authority of 1921: how two states agreed to share a harbor tells the founding story, and Port Authority of New York and New Jersey and Delaware River Port Authority describe the two agencies as they are today.
The order of events set a pattern: government created a body that could issue bonds and charge tolls, and the tolls paid for the steel.
July 1, 1926: the Delaware River Bridge
The first of the group to open was in South Jersey. On July 1, 1926, the Delaware River Bridge, which would later be renamed the Benjamin Franklin Bridge, opened to traffic between Camden and Philadelphia. Its 1,750-foot main span was the longest suspension span in the world at completion, a title it held until the Ambassador Bridge in Detroit opened in 1929. The chief engineer was Ralph Modjeski, a Polish-born bridge builder.
The bridge was built for more than cars. Its design included rail space, and in 1936 the outer pair of tracks opened as the Bridge Line subway, the ancestor of the PATCO Speedline. The line was extended to 16th and Locust in Philadelphia in 1952, and PATCO trains began using it in 1969. For the commuter service and the other Delaware crossings, see PATCO and the DRPA bridges and Camden.
November 13, 1927: the Holland Tunnel
The next crossing went under the Hudson. The Holland Tunnel, between Jersey City and lower Manhattan, opened to vehicles on November 13, 1927, a Sunday, after a ceremony the night before. The two tubes run 8,558 feet westbound and 8,371 feet eastbound between portals. It cost about $48 million in 1927 dollars, and it was the first mechanically ventilated underwater vehicular tunnel in the world.
That last fact was the engineering problem. A tunnel full of cars fills with exhaust, and no one had solved the ventilation of a long tube under a river. The system designed by Ole Singstad can replace all the air in the tunnel every 90 seconds. The tunnel's first engineers did not live to see it open. Clifford Holland, the first chief engineer and the tunnel's namesake, died in October 1924, at the age of 41, shortly before the tubes were scheduled to meet. His successor, Milton Freeman, died of pneumonia in March 1925. Singstad finished the work.
The reaction was immediate. On the first day, 52,285 vehicles went through, more than the tunnel's projected maximum capacity, at a toll of 50 cents for a passenger car. The lines that formed on the first day set a pattern that never ended. The Holland and Lincoln tunnels covers the tunnels today, and Jersey City covers the New Jersey side.
June 29, 1928: Goethals and Outerbridge
The Port Authority's first bridges were not over the Hudson. They connected New Jersey to Staten Island. The Goethals Bridge, between Elizabeth and Staten Island, and the Outerbridge Crossing, between Perth Amboy and Staten Island, both opened on June 29, 1928, designed by J.A.L. Waddell. The Goethals was named for George W. Goethals, the Authority's first consulting engineer, and the Outerbridge for Eugenius Outerbridge, its first chairman. The original Goethals span was replaced in 2017 and later demolished. Goethals, Bayonne and Outerbridge: the Staten Island crossings compared covers the three Staten Island crossings, and Perth Amboy and Bayonne have the surrounding places.
October 25, 1931: the George Washington Bridge
The bridge that changed the scale of the whole project opened in 1931. The George Washington Bridge was dedicated on October 24, 1931 and opened to traffic the next day, eight months ahead of schedule. Othmar Ammann was chief engineer, with Cass Gilbert as consulting architect. The main span of 3,500 feet was the longest in the world, nearly double the length of any before it, a record it held until the Golden Gate Bridge opened in 1937.
The design was a double-decked suspension bridge, but only the upper deck was built at first. To save money, the engineers left out the stiffening trusses that other suspension bridges had, and used plate girders under each deck instead, and the result was the plain, open steel the architect Le Corbusier later admired, writing that the structure was so pure and regular that steel architecture seemed to laugh. The upper deck had six lanes, widened to eight in 1946. The original toll was 50 cents for a car, and pedestrians paid 10 cents, lowered to 5 cents in 1934.
A lower deck was added between 1959 and 1962, opening to the public on August 29, 1962, and making the bridge the world's only 14-lane suspension bridge. See The George Washington Bridge, 1931 to the $16.79 toll for the bridge today and Walking the George Washington Bridge approach in Fort Lee for the approach through Fort Lee.
November 15, 1931: the Bayonne Bridge
A few weeks later the Port Authority opened the third of its Staten Island crossings, the Bayonne Bridge, on November 15, 1931, after dedication ceremonies the day before. It connected Bayonne to Staten Island over the Kill Van Kull, the channel that serves Port Newark and Elizabeth. Bayonne and the Bayonne Bridge tells that story.
December 22, 1937: the Lincoln Tunnel
The last in the sequence opened just before the year's end. The center tube of the Lincoln Tunnel, between Weehawken and midtown Manhattan, opened on December 22, 1937, after dedication the previous day. Ole Singstad, who had finished the Holland, was the engineer. The tunnel was built in stages: the north tube followed on February 1, 1945, and the south tube on May 25, 1957. The three tubes today measure 7,482, 8,216 and 8,006 feet.
The New Jersey approach is famous. The Weehawken Helix, a three-quarters circle about 4,000 feet long, lets the road drop down the steep face of the Palisades, and it earned the nickname the Corkscrew. The Port Authority Bus Terminal, approved in 1947 for the block between 40th and 41st Streets and 8th and 9th Avenues, opened in 1950. In 1970 a trial began of a reserved bus lane in the tunnel's center tube, now the Exclusive Bus Lane, on weekday mornings. It carries about 1,850 buses and 70,000 commuters, and the lane is described as the busiest and most productive bus lane in the country.
The dozen years in a table
| Date | Crossing | Connects | Agency |
|---|---|---|---|
| July 1, 1926 | Delaware River (Ben Franklin) Bridge | Camden and Philadelphia | Delaware River Bridge Joint Commission, now DRPA |
| Nov. 13, 1927 | Holland Tunnel | Jersey City and Manhattan | Port Authority |
| June 29, 1928 | Goethals Bridge | Elizabeth and Staten Island | Port Authority |
| June 29, 1928 | Outerbridge Crossing | Perth Amboy and Staten Island | Port Authority |
| Oct. 25, 1931 | George Washington Bridge | Fort Lee and Manhattan | Port Authority |
| Nov. 15, 1931 | Bayonne Bridge | Bayonne and Staten Island | Port Authority |
| Dec. 22, 1937 | Lincoln Tunnel (center tube) | Weehawken and Manhattan | Port Authority |
Reading the numbers
A few comparisons put the decade in scale.
- Span growth. The Delaware River Bridge's 1,750-foot span was a world record in 1926. Five years later the George Washington Bridge's 3,500-foot span was exactly twice as long, a doubling of the record in a single step.
- Holland's first day. The 52,285 vehicles that used the tunnel on its first day, spread over 24 hours, average about 2,180 an hour, or roughly one car every 1.7 seconds. The tunnel had been planned for fewer.
- Tolls. Passenger cars paid 50 cents to use the Holland Tunnel and 50 cents on the George Washington Bridge when each opened. Those are 1927 and 1931 dollars, and today's toll, set under the Port Authority's schedule, is far higher; the year-specific figures are on the Port Authority's page.
- Time to build. The George Washington Bridge opened eight months ahead of schedule, a rare event in public works. The Lincoln Tunnel needed three tubes over twenty years, opening in 1937, 1945 and 1957.
The state on the other side of the water
The crossings also changed what New Jersey was to its neighbors. For two centuries the state had been described as a corridor between New York and Philadelphia, a place people passed through by rail and steamboat. The tunnels and bridges made that corridor drivable. The towns on the Hudson waterfront, such as Jersey City, Weehawken and Fort Lee, became the New Jersey ends of the crossings, and they were reshaped by the approach roads, the toll plazas and the traffic.
What the crossings did
The effect was immediate, and it shaped the state we live in. Once a driver could cross the Hudson without a ferry, the towns of northern New Jersey became accessible from Manhattan, and the suburbs that followed, with their roads, rail stations and school districts, depended on those crossings. Once a driver could cross the Delaware at Camden, South Jersey became part of the Philadelphia region in a way it had not been. The pressure the crossings created also made new roads necessary, and the Turnpike and the Parkway, built two decades later, grew out of it; see The Turnpike opens, 1951 to 1956 and The Garden State Parkway, 1950 to 1957.
The crossings also set a pattern of toll-financed public works run by bi-state authorities, which continues in the toll schedules of today. For how to use the crossings now, see Crossing to New York: bridges, tunnels and tolls and Crossing to Pennsylvania and Delaware. The border these structures cross is itself a legal artifact, as The Ellis Island boundary fight shows.