Blog

Ellis Island, 1892 to 1954

The station that processed about 12 million people from 1892 to 1954, the 1897 fire and rebuild, and why most of the island is legally in New Jersey.

A visitor in Jersey City looking out across the water from Liberty State Park sees the Statue of Liberty first and Ellis Island second, and the second is the one New Jersey has a legal claim to. Most of Ellis Island is in New Jersey. That fact surprises New Yorkers, who think of it as theirs, and it surprises a fair number of New Jerseyans too. It comes out of a boundary fight that ran for more than a century and was settled by the United States Supreme Court in 1998. The island's other claim on the state is bigger: for 62 years it was the gate through which about 12 million people entered the United States, and a large share of them boarded trains in New Jersey within hours of landing.

This is the history of the station, in order, and of the odd place it occupies on the map.

Before it was a station

The island was small and unimportant. It was a small island in the upper bay, then called Kioshk, and in 1630 the Dutch bought it as a gift for Michael Reyniersz Pauw. In 1774 a merchant from Wrexham, Wales, named Samuel Ellis acquired it, and it took his name. The federal government took ownership in 1808, when it was ceded for $10,000.

January 1, 1892: the first station

The first immigration station on Ellis Island opened on January 1, 1892. The first immigrant processed was Annie Moore, a 17-year-old from Cork, Ireland. The station was built of wood.

It did not last. On June 15, 1897, a fire of unknown origin destroyed the wooden building. The station had to be rebuilt.

December 17, 1900: the second station

The replacement opened on December 17, 1900. It opened without ceremony, processing 2,251 immigrants on its first day. That is the building visitors know, and its main building is the center of the island's history.

The island itself had to grow to hold the station. It was enlarged by landfill, with a second island in the late 1890s and a third, completed in 1906, and the reclamation went on until 1934. By the time the work was finished, the island covered about 27.5 acres. Almost all of that is made land. The original natural island, about 4.68 acres on the northern side, is the only part that remained undisputed New York territory.

What happened on the island

The new arrivals were landed at the island, examined by doctors and questioned by inspectors. Most were admitted, though some were held for medical care or further questions. The peak years of the station came while William Williams was the commissioner of the island, in his terms from 1902 to 1905 and from 1909 to 1913. In all, about 12 million people were processed between 1892 and 1954.

The train in New Jersey

Here is the New Jersey connection that matters most in daily terms. Most of those 12 million people were not staying in New York. They were going somewhere else, and to get there they needed a train. Immigrants bought their railroad tickets on Ellis Island and then took a ferry across the harbor to the Central Railroad of New Jersey Terminal in Jersey City. The state's parks division says that about two-thirds of the newcomers processed at Ellis Island began their new lives through that terminal, and another state source puts the share above 70 percent.

The terminal was built in 1889, and it is the cornerstone of today's Liberty State Park. It closed as a railroad station on April 30, 1967. After Hurricane Sandy damaged it, it reopened in June 2016 after a renovation that cost $20 million, and ferry service to the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island departs from it today. The terminal and the park around it are described in New Jersey State Parks, Forests and Historic Sites and Liberty State Park, the best seat in the house for the Statue of Liberty. For the storm itself, see Sandy, October 29, 2012.

That makes New Jersey an important and often overlooked part of the immigrant story. A person who arrived at Ellis Island and went on to Pennsylvania or the Midwest probably passed through Jersey City on the way. And many stayed. The state's cities were full of newly arrived workers, and the story of one of them, Paterson, is told in paterson and the 1791 manufacturing society and South Paterson and the immigrant city.

November 12, 1954: the last day

The need for a processing island faded, and the station closed on November 12, 1954, when its last detainee, Arne Pettersen, left. The buildings were left to decay for decades.

A monument and a museum

In 1965 the island was added to the Statue of Liberty National Monument, on May 11 of that year. A large restoration followed, and on September 10, 1990, the main building reopened as a museum of immigration. The museum, run by the National Park Service, tells the story of the station and the people who passed through it.

The island in numbers

Item Figure
Opened January 1, 1892
First immigrant processed Annie Moore, aged 17, from Cork
First station destroyed by fire June 15, 1897
Second station opened December 17, 1900, with 2,251 people processed that day
People processed, 1892 to 1954 about 12 million
Closed November 12, 1954
Added to the Statue of Liberty National Monument May 11, 1965
Museum opened September 10, 1990
Total area about 27.5 acres
Natural island about 4.68 acres, a New York exclave

Seeing it from New Jersey

The best way to see the island from the state side is from Liberty State Park in Jersey City, which has a view across the water to the island and the statue and which is run by the Department of Environmental Protection. The park's centerpiece is the Central Railroad of New Jersey Terminal, and the ferry to the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island leaves from there; the state's page says the service runs throughout the year. The terminal is the place where the immigrants' second journey began, so it is a good start for a visit.

The park also has a nature preserve, which was closed for nearly nine years after Hurricane Sandy and reopened in July 2021. A day that combines the terminal, the park and the ferry is described in A day at Ellis Island and Liberty State Park. The Hudson waterfront towns on either side of the park, Jersey City and Hoboken, are described in Jersey City and Hoboken.

Whose island?

The boundary question had a long history. New York and New Jersey had settled the line in the bay by an agreement in 1834, which gave New York the island. New Jersey argued that the agreement applied only to the natural island and that the added land, which made up most of the area, lay on the New Jersey side of the line. The dispute went to the Supreme Court, which ruled on it in 1998 in New Jersey v. New York. The Court held that most of the island, the filled portion, belongs to New Jersey, while the original natural island of about 4.68 acres remains an exclave of New York.

The practical result is a patchwork. The land that most visitors see is in New Jersey and the oldest part is in New York. The part of the island that the National Park Service runs is federally owned in either case, and the legal line matters less to a visitor than it does to a lawyer. But the ruling is part of why Jersey City can claim a share of the island. If you want to see it on the day-trip scale, A day at Ellis Island and Liberty State Park describes how to combine the two places.

One harbor, two states

The island's strange legal status is a reminder of how tightly the two states are tied by water. New York and New Jersey share a harbor, and from the nineteenth century onward they have had to settle who controls what in it. The most lasting solution was the creation, on April 30, 1921, of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, a bi-state agency that today runs the region's major airports, bridges, tunnels, marine terminals and the PATH trains; its origin is in The Port Authority of 1921: how two states agreed to share a harbor. The Ellis Island dispute was settled by a court, but most of the harbor's business has been settled by agreements of that kind.

Reading the history

Ellis Island is often told as a story of arrival, but the station was a place of selection as well as welcome, and a visit includes both stories. The number 12 million is a good place to start. It is about the population of a very large American city, and it passed through a single building on a few acres of fill over 62 years. The immigration of the era came largely from Europe, and the station's closing in 1954 marks the end of that system. The state's relationship with newcomers today is the subject of Citizenship and new Americans in New Jersey, and the state's parks are covered in A guide to New Jersey's state parks and forests.

A good way to think of the island is as a place where a state and a nation met. For New Jersey, the terminal in Jersey City, the filled land under the main hall and the ferry that crosses the water are all part of the same story.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic