Blog
Thomas Mundy Peterson and the first vote under the 15th Amendment
On March 31, 1870, a Perth Amboy school custodian voted in a charter election, and New Jersey has marked Thomas Mundy Peterson Day ever since.
Every March 31, Perth Amboy marks an anniversary that is a lot smaller than it sounds and much larger than it looks. On that date in 1870, in a municipal election to revise the city charter, a man named Thomas Mundy Peterson walked to a polling place and cast a ballot. It was the day after the 15th Amendment was certified, and he is widely credited as the first African American to vote under it. New Jersey made the date a day of observance in 1998. The story is simple to tell, but what it rested on, and what it did not mean, is more complicated, and New Jersey's own record is part of that.
The man
Peterson was born in 1824 in Metuchen, in what is now Middlesex County. His mother, who had been enslaved, was freed by a will. He later lived in Perth Amboy, a port city on Raritan Bay. He worked as the custodian of the city's School No. 1 from 1871 to 1878, and he was active in the Republican and Prohibition parties. He also served on a committee that revised the city charter, which is the committee behind the election he voted in. He died in 1904.
Those details have the ring of ordinary life, and that is the point. Peterson was not a general or a senator. He was a working man whose neighbors put him on a charter committee, and the vote he cast was an act of ordinary citizenship that happened to take place on a day when the law had just changed.
The amendment and the date
The 15th Amendment, which says the right to vote shall not be denied on account of race, color or previous condition of servitude, was ratified on February 3, 1870, when enough states had approved it. It was not officially certified until March 30. The next day, March 31, was the day of the Perth Amboy charter election.
So when historians say Peterson voted under the amendment, they mean that the law of the land had just guaranteed him the right to do it. The claim that he was the first is the kind of thing that is hard to prove absolutely. Black men had voted in some Northern states before 1870, and New Jersey itself had once allowed some of them to. What is stated for Peterson is the narrower claim: the first to vote after the amendment took effect. That claim has been repeated for 150 years, and the town that honored him believed it.
What New Jersey had done before
Here is where the state's own record comes in. New Jersey had once been among the most generous states in the country on the question of who could vote, and then it had changed its mind.
The state's first constitution, adopted in 1776, set voting qualifications by property and residence and did not say "male" or "white." As a result, single or widowed women who owned property and free Black men who met the property test voted in New Jersey in the late eighteenth century. Evidence exists that they did vote, although slavery remained legal in the state, ended only gradually under an 1804 act, and being a Black voter cannot have been easy.
That ended in 1807. The Legislature that year restricted the vote to free, white, male citizens who paid taxes, stripping the franchise from women, people of color and recent immigrants. The National Park Service has explained the move as partly a matter of party advantage ahead of the 1808 presidential election. The second state constitution, in 1844, wrote "white male" into the document. For 63 years, from 1807 to 1870, New Jersey law kept Black men from the polls.
New Jersey then did not rush to embrace the change. The state Legislature first voted against the 15th Amendment and did not approve it until early 1871, almost a year after it took effect. State records and secondary sources differ on the exact day in February 1871. The amendment was already in force by then, because enough other states had acted, and Peterson had already voted.
A timeline of the franchise in New Jersey
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1776 | The first state constitution sets property and residence qualifications, without the words "white" or "male" |
| 1804 | The Legislature passes a gradual abolition act |
| 1807 | The vote is restricted to free, white, male taxpaying citizens |
| 1844 | The second constitution writes "white male" into the franchise |
| February 3, 1870 | The 15th Amendment is ratified |
| March 30, 1870 | The amendment is officially certified |
| March 31, 1870 | Thomas Mundy Peterson votes in Perth Amboy |
| Early 1871 | New Jersey's Legislature, which had first voted no, approves the amendment |
| May 30, 1884 | Perth Amboy presents Peterson with a gold medal |
| 1989 | School No. 1 is renamed for him |
| 1998 | The state designates Thomas Mundy Peterson Day |
The table shows how long and uneven the road was. The state that allowed a Black man to vote in the 1780s took the right away in 1807 and approved the amendment that restored it only after first voting no. That is not a comfortable record, and it is part of why the story deserves to be told in full and not as a simple tale of progress.
The medal
Peterson's neighbors did something unusual. After the election, the citizens of Perth Amboy raised $70 to buy a gold medal in his honor. It was presented to him on May 30, 1884, and its inscription credits him as the first "colored voter" under the amendment, at the election of March 31, 1870. The medal is now held by Xavier University of Louisiana.
A school followed. The building where Peterson had worked, School No. 1, was renamed the Thomas Mundy Peterson School in 1989. Perth Amboy has also built a Thomas Mundy Peterson Park with state and municipal funding, and the park is on the state's Black Heritage Trail. In 1998 the state designated March 31 as Thomas Mundy Peterson Day.
What the vote meant, and what followed
It is tempting to treat 1870 as a clean break. It was not. The 15th Amendment banned discrimination in voting on the basis of race, but it did nothing to guarantee that women could vote. Women's rights advocates opposed the amendment as written, because it extended the franchise to Black men and left women out. The 19th Amendment would not come until 1920. And throughout the country the guarantee of the 15th Amendment was undercut for generations by tests, taxes and intimidation, in the South above all.
New Jersey's later history on voting is more straightforward. Today every eligible resident may register to vote, and the state has made the process easier in recent years, with online registration, early in-person voting and vote by mail. The Division of Elections, part of the Department of State, runs the system; see New Jersey Division of Elections, and for the how-to, How to register to vote in New Jersey. The state's rules on voting by mail, which have been the subject of both policy changes and myths, are explained in Myths about voting by mail in New Jersey, and a checklist for election week is An election-week checklist for New Jersey voters.
The state's constitutions are part of the story, too. The 1844 version that wrote race and sex into the franchise was replaced in 1947, and the 1947 constitution and the state it built tells how the current document came to be. And the state's first constitution, written in the middle of the Revolution, is part of why New Jersey's story of voting begins earlier and more surprisingly than most; see Ratification: the third state, December 18, 1787 for the Constitution the state joined in 1787.
Voting in New Jersey today
The mechanics of voting in the state are very different from those of 1870. A resident must register at least 21 days before an election, online or on paper. Every county offers early in-person voting for primary and general elections, with sites open at least from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. on Sunday. Every active registered voter can request a mail-in ballot. On Election Day the polls are open from 6 a.m. to 8 p.m.
None of these details was part of Peterson's world. On March 31, 1870, he voted at a local polling place in a city election, and the right he exercised was brand new. The infrastructure that now surrounds the right, the county clerks, the Boards of Elections and the Division of Elections in Trenton, grew up over the following 150 years.
The anniversary
Perth Amboy has marked Thomas Mundy Peterson Day every year, with the mayor and descendants of Peterson taking part in some years. The city of Perth Amboy is described in Perth Amboy. The state's archival record, including the amendment's New Jersey approval document, is held at the State Archives in Trenton, which is covered in The New Jersey State Archives.
If you want to mark March 31 yourself, there are small ways to do it. Visit the park in Perth Amboy, or read the state's own account of Peterson on the New Jersey Historical Commission's pages. Or simply check that you are registered. Peterson's vote was one of the first in a long series of such votes, and every one of them was cast by a person who was not supposed to have the right a few years or decades earlier.
The point of the story is not that Perth Amboy was ahead of its time. It is that a law, which had been in the way for 63 years, was lifted, and that on the first day it could be used, a man used it.