Blog
Myths about voting by mail in New Jersey
Eight common beliefs about New Jersey mail-in ballots, from who can request one to the postmark rule and why you cannot drop one at a polling place.
Every New Jersey election season, the same arguments start at the same kitchen tables. Somebody's neighbor says a mail ballot has to arrive by Election Day or it is thrown out. Someone else says you need a reason to ask for one. A third person is sure that if you ask for a mail ballot and change your mind, you are locked out of the polls. Each of these has a grain of history in it, and each is wrong in a way that can cost a voter their ballot.
The rules below come from the Division of Elections in the Department of State, which publishes the official instructions. They apply to state and federal elections run by the counties. County clerks and county boards of elections do the actual work, so a call to your county is the final word on local detail. This is general information about the process, not advice about your own situation.
Myth 1: You need an excuse to vote by mail
Fact: Every active registered voter can ask for a mail-in ballot. No reason is required. Before 2020, New Jersey already allowed mail voting without an excuse, and the 2020 election made it ordinary. The request goes to your county clerk, either online or on the county's paper application. An online application asks for your date of birth, a New Jersey driver's license or MVC identification number (or a Social Security number as an alternative) and a digital signature.
If you are not registered, or your registration is inactive, fix that first. The registration deadline is 21 days before an election, and the online form is the quickest route; see How to register to vote in New Jersey.
Myth 2: A mail ballot has to arrive by Election Day
Fact: The deadline is about the postmark, not the arrival. A ballot returned by mail counts if it is postmarked on or before Election Day by 8 p.m. and is received by the county board of elections within six days after the polls close. The Division of Elections also says a ballot without a postmark can still count if it arrives by U.S. Postal Service delivery within 48 hours after the polls close.
Two practical points follow. First, the six days are a safety net, not a plan. The Postal Service's postmark is applied at a processing center, not at your corner mailbox, so a ballot dropped in the box on the evening of Election Day may not get a postmark that day. Second, the earlier you mail it, the less you depend on that rule.
Myth 3: You can hand a mail ballot in at a polling place
Fact: You cannot. A completed mail-in ballot cannot be returned at an early voting site or at an Election Day polling place. Those locations run on the poll books and the voting machines, and they do not accept mail ballots. This is the myth that trips up the most voters on the last day, and it is one of the reasons the county boards of elections get so many panicked phone calls on Election Day.
There are three ways to return a mail ballot:
- By mail, with the pre-addressed envelope and the postmark rule from Myth 2.
- At a secure drop box in your county, by 8 p.m. on Election Day. The Division of Elections lists drop-box locations by county.
- In person at your county board of elections office, also by 8 p.m. on Election Day.
For drop boxes and the board office, the deadline is the same as the polls closing. There is no six-day grace period for a ballot delivered by hand.
Myth 4: If you ask for a mail ballot, you cannot vote in person
Fact: What you can do depends on whether you have returned the ballot. A voter who has requested a mail ballot and has not returned it can still go to a polling place on Election Day, but may vote only by provisional ballot. The county checks the voter's record to make sure the mail ballot was not also counted before the provisional ballot is counted. That is the safeguard against anyone voting twice.
If you ask for a mail ballot and then lose it or decide you would prefer to vote another way, you have options. You can request a replacement from your county clerk before the deadline, or you can vote in person with the provisional ballot. Early in-person voting is a separate system that every county offers; see Early in-person voting in New Jersey. Counties set their own deadlines for stopping a mail ballot or issuing a replacement, so a call to the county clerk is the safe step.
Myth 5: You have to apply by a deadline that has already passed
Fact: The cutoffs are later than most people assume. To have the county mail you a ballot, the Division of Elections says to request it at least seven days before the election. After that, you can still apply in person and pick the ballot up at the county clerk's office by 3 p.m. on the day before Election Day. Those are the state's published times; some counties may have other practices, so ask the county clerk.
Do not read that as an invitation to wait. A ballot you apply for a week before the election and receive by mail needs to be voted and returned in time; for most people who start that late, the practical option is a drop box or the clerk's office.
Myth 6: Nobody can tell you where your ballot is
Fact: New Jersey has a Track My Ballot portal run by the state. First-time users create an account with a voter ID number, a driver's license number or the last four digits of a Social Security number, and the portal shows whether the county has received the application and the completed ballot. If the portal does not show your ballot, call the county clerk, who can look at the same record and help.
A voter who sees "received" has the assurance that the ballot reached the county board. It does not mean the ballot has been counted; counting happens at the board's pace under the county's rules.
Myth 7: You need a witness or a notary
Fact: A mail-in ballot requires the voter's signature on the certificate on the outer envelope. No witness and no notary are required. Most voters do not need to send a copy of an ID, though certain first-time voters receive a notice explaining what to enclose. Read the instructions that come with the ballot, which are specific to your county.
One rule does involve another person. If someone other than the voter carries the ballot to the county, that person is a "bearer" and must sign the bearer portion of the outer envelope in the voter's presence. The state limits how many ballots a bearer can carry: up to three ballots for voters outside the bearer's household, or up to five if the voters are immediate family living in the bearer's household. Anyone who does not fit those categories should use the mail or hand-deliver their own ballot.
Myth 8: Drop boxes are not official
Fact: Secure ballot drop boxes are set up by the county and emptied by county election staff. The Division of Elections lists them by county on its drop-box page, and a ballot placed in a box by 8 p.m. on Election Day counts. If a box on a street corner is not on the county's list, do not use it. The lists are the proof that the box belongs to the county.
A walk-through: two voters, one election
Say a voter in Middlesex County, Maria, applies online two weeks before the election and has her ballot in the mail within days. She signs the certificate, seals the inner and outer envelopes and drops it into a county box a week before Election Day. Track My Ballot shows "received" two days later. She does not need to do anything on Election Day.
A second voter, a hypothetical commuter named Dev, is in the same county and applied at the last minute. He picks up his ballot from the clerk's office by 3 p.m. the day before the election, but then gets caught at work on Election Day. He cannot take the ballot to his polling place, so he has to deliver it to a drop box or the board of elections by 8 p.m. If he misses that and instead votes at the polls, he is allowed a provisional ballot only. The first voter had time to fix any mistake. The second had one chance.
What to do now
- If you plan to vote by mail in a future election, apply as early as the county accepts applications, and read the county's instructions the day the ballot arrives.
- Sign where it says to sign, seal both envelopes, and return it by the method that gives you a receipt, such as a drop box with a Track My Ballot confirmation.
- Never give your ballot to a stranger, and never leave it in an unmarked box.
- If something goes wrong, call the county clerk first. The state's rules apply statewide, but the clerks run the details.
For the full steps, see How to vote by mail in New Jersey. For the state body that sets the rules, see New Jersey Division of Elections. An even shorter list for the final week before a vote is in An election-week checklist for New Jersey voters. The Division of Elections' vote-by-mail page carries the current instructions and the drop-box lists.