Blog
The shark attacks of July 1916
Twelve days of attacks from Beach Haven to Matawan Creek killed four people, emptied the beaches and changed what scientists believed about sharks.
Saturday, July 1: Beach Haven
The summer of 1916 was a hot one, and the shore was full. Charles Epting Vansant, a 23-year-old from Philadelphia, was staying with his family at a hotel in Beach Haven, on Long Beach Island, and on the evening of July 1 he went into the water at the beach of the Engleside Hotel for a swim before dinner.
The lifeguard, Alexander Ott, and a bystander, Sheridan Taylor, pulled him from the water. Vansant was badly bitten, and he bled to death at the hotel at 6:45 p.m. The news was treated at first as an odd event: in 1916 many scientists doubted that a shark would kill a swimmer on the northeast coast. The attack was treated as a freak accident. Five days later it was no longer possible to think so.
Thursday, July 6: Spring Lake
Spring Lake is a resort town in Monmouth County, up the coast from Beach Haven. On July 6 Charles Bruder, a 27-year-old Swiss bell captain, went for a swim and, about 130 yards from shore, was bitten. Two lifeguards, Chris Anderson and George White, reached him in a lifeboat. Bruder died on the way to shore.
By then the shore was alarmed. Two fatal attacks in six days made it impossible to treat them as flukes. Newspapers carried the story. Hotels began to worry about cancellations, and the beaches were still full.
Wednesday, July 12: Matawan Creek
The third day was the strangest. Matawan Creek is a tidal stream that runs through the Monmouth County town of Matawan and on toward Raritan Bay, and on a hot afternoon boys swam in it. Lester Stillwell, 11, was pulled underwater. A local businessman, Watson Stanley Fisher, 24, dove in to find the boy and was bitten himself. He was taken to Monmouth Memorial Hospital in Long Branch and died at 5:30 p.m. Stillwell's body was recovered two days later.
About half an hour after the first attack, and about half a mile away, a 14-year-old, Joseph Dunn, who was visiting from New York City, was bitten on the leg. His age has been disputed. His brother and a friend rescued him, and he survived. He was the only person in the twelve days to live through an attack.
Four people had died in twelve days. The count made the front page of the New York Times, and the story went national. A creek, far from the open sea, was a place no one expected a shark to be.
The panic
Reaction was extreme. The hotels and resorts of the Jersey shore lost an estimated $250,000 in tourism that summer, a large sum in 1916. Asbury Park's Fourth Avenue beach was enclosed with steel-wire mesh and patrolled by armed motorboats. In Matawan people used nets and dynamite in the creek, and the mayor offered a $100 reward to anyone who killed a shark there. No shark was caught in the creek.
Washington took notice. The House of Representatives appropriated $5,000 to deal with the threat, and President Woodrow Wilson, who had been governor of New Jersey only a few years earlier, met with his Cabinet about it. The Treasury Secretary, William McAdoo, proposed mobilizing the Coast Guard. The governor of New Jersey and several coastal municipalities offered bounties, and hundreds of sharks were caught along the East Coast that summer.
Cartoonists used the shark as a symbol. It stood for German U-boats, for the polio epidemic of that year and for the heat wave. The attacks fit with a summer in which many Americans were afraid of things they could not see.
A summer of fears
The sharks arrived in a year when Americans had other things to be afraid of. Europe was in the middle of a world war that the United States had not yet joined, and German submarines were sinking ships. A polio epidemic was spreading through the region that summer, and a heat wave pushed more people to the beaches than usual. Cartoonists who drew sharks in 1916 gave them the labels of those dangers: U-boat, infantile paralysis, heat. The attacks did not cause those fears, but they gave them a shape that newspaper readers could picture.
The victims were ordinary people on ordinary summer days: a young man from Philadelphia on holiday, a hotel employee from Switzerland, a boy of eleven and the neighbor who tried to save him, and a fourteen-year-old visiting from New York. The Matawan deaths in particular hit a small town hard, and the town's response, with its nets and dynamite and bounty, was the instinct of a place trying to do something. None of those methods caught a shark in the creek.
How the shore responded
The resort towns responded in ways that would be familiar to a modern beach manager. At Asbury Park the Fourth Avenue beach was fenced with steel-wire mesh and watched by armed motorboats, an early form of the netted swimming area. Federal money, though small at $5,000, was a signal that the government considered the problem real.
A hotel owner's problem was simple: guests who canceled did not pay. The estimated loss of $250,000 to the shore's tourism in 1916 measures how quickly fear turned into a business problem. The shore recovered, as it has from every setback since. That recovery is a theme of the state's coastal history, and the biggest test of it is covered in After Sandy: the Seaside Heights rebuild.
The shark that was caught
On July 14, two days after Matawan Creek, a Harlem taxidermist and former lion tamer, Michael Schleisser, caught a young great white in Raritan Bay. It was 7.5 feet long and weighed 325 pounds, and its stomach contained human remains. Two scientists, Frederic Lucas and Robert Murphy, examined it and declared it the "Jersey man-eater." The mounted shark was later lost, and only one photograph of it survives.
That has not ended the argument. Later researchers have questioned whether a single great white could have been responsible for all of the attacks, particularly the ones in Matawan Creek, which is brackish and shallow. Some, including Richard Ellis and George Llano, have argued for a bull shark, a species that can swim in fresh and brackish water. George Burgess, who maintained the International Shark Attack File, has said that a great white is still likely. Other explanations, such as a sea turtle or a shark following German submarines, were offered in letters to the New York Times at the time but were not taken up.
The argument turns on habitat. A great white is mainly an ocean animal, and a bull shark is a species known for traveling far into brackish and fresh water, which is why a tidal creek in Monmouth County sits at the center of the debate. Some researchers therefore look at more than one animal. The honest summary is that nobody knows which species did it, or whether it was one animal or more. The identification depends on judgments made a century ago about a shark that no longer exists.
What the attacks changed
Before 1916 many scientists doubted that sharks would fatally attack people in the waters of the northeastern United States. The attacks made ichthyologists take the great white more seriously, and the study of shark attacks, which later grew into a scientific field, can trace part of its beginning to the New Jersey summer.
The popular culture influence is better known. Peter Benchley's 1974 novel Jaws and Steven Spielberg's 1975 film were partly inspired by the events; in the film, the police chief refers to attacks on a "Jersey beach" in 1916. Documentaries have been made about the twelve days, among them 12 Days of Terror in 2004 and Shark Week's Blood in the Water in 2009.
The shore today
A swimmer on a New Jersey beach today is in a very different situation from one in 1916. Lifeguards are trained and patrol the surf, and the beaches are managed under town rules. Most ocean beaches charge a beach tag, and Jersey Shore beach tags and access covers the rules, with the exceptions in Atlantic City, Strathmere and the Wildwoods. Sharks are still in the water, as they were in 1916, and encounters remain rare. State wildlife biologists work on marine life along the coast; the work of the Division of Fish and Wildlife is described in The Division of Fish and Wildlife: who looks after New Jersey's animals.
The places in the story are easy to reach. Beach Haven is on Long Beach Island, covered in Long Beach Island, from the causeway to the bay and Long Beach Island; Spring Lake and Asbury Park are on the North Jersey Coast Line, described in Riding the North Jersey Coast Line to the shore and Asbury Park. For the larger set of shore myths, including a few about sharks, see Myths about the Jersey Shore. The state's other shore catastrophes, such as Hurricane Sandy, appear in Sandy, October 29, 2012.
A fear that was reasonable
The panic of July 1916 can look funny in retrospect, with its dynamite and its mesh nets and armed boats. It was not silly. People had died. Residents of coastal towns did not know whether it would continue, and an economy that depended on summer visitors was threatened. The response was disproportionate in some ways, but it was a response to something that had happened. The story of those twelve days is still told on the shore every summer.