Blog
Myths about the Jersey Shore
It is not one place or one price. Seven myths about 141 miles of coast, from beach tags and boardwalks to dry towns, Sandy and public access.
Say "the Shore" to a New Jerseyan and the first thing you get is a question: which one? The phrase covers a coast of about 141 miles of oceanfront, from the sandy hook at the mouth of New York Harbor to the point at Cape May, and in that distance it holds a loud boardwalk, a dry Victorian-era resort, a casino city, and a string of quiet barrier islands. Inland New Jerseyans say they are going down the shore. The rest of the country, when it thinks of the place at all, thinks of a television show.
The Shore is one of the most mythologized places in American life, and many of the myths are simply wrong in ways that cost visitors money or time. This post takes seven of them in turn. The facts here are on the geography and the rules, which are stable, and the post leaves out prices and fees that change every season.
Myth 1: The Shore is one place
The state's tourism writers and its geographers draw the Jersey Shore differently, but the usual description runs through five counties: Middlesex, Monmouth, Ocean, Atlantic and Cape May. Middlesex's piece is along Raritan Bay, with no ocean beach. The ocean begins in Monmouth County at Sandy Hook, runs south through Ocean County's long peninsula and barrier island chain, continues through Atlantic County, where Absecon Island holds Atlantic City, and ends in Cape May County at the state's southern tip, a peninsula that points toward Delaware Bay.
Those stretches are different in kind. North Monmouth has commuter towns with rail lines to New York. Central Ocean County has Seaside Heights and its boardwalk, Long Beach Island and Island Beach State Park. Atlantic County has the casinos. Cape May County has Ocean City, Wildwood, Cape May and its Victorian houses. A family that has a favorite shore town is rarely talking about the same place as the family in the next beach chair, and the loyalty is usually to a single town, not to the coast. For the longer tour, Long Beach Island, from the causeway to the bay and Cape May: the end of the Parkway describe two very different ones.
Myth 2: The Shore is the boardwalk
Some of the most famous places in the state sit on a boardwalk, and many beach towns do not have one at all. Atlantic City built the first boardwalk in 1870, and the boardwalks that followed in Ocean City, Seaside Heights and Wildwood set the image of the Shore for generations. Their lengths vary: Seaside Heights has a boardwalk of about two miles, Ocean City's runs about two and a half miles and Wildwood's about 1.8 miles. Other beach towns, especially on the barrier islands, have beach, dunes and houses and no boardwalk, no rides and no amusements.
Even the boardwalk towns are not alike. Atlantic City's is a casino promenade. Seaside Heights' is an amusement boardwalk that was badly hit in Hurricane Sandy; the Casino Pier roller coaster was damaged by the storm, a ride called the Star Jet fell into the ocean, and the coaster was demolished on May 14, 2013. Ocean City's is family-oriented. The differences are described in A walk down the Atlantic City Boardwalk, Seaside Heights: the boardwalk and the storm and wildwood: the boardwalk and the free beaches.
Myth 3: Every Shore town allows alcohol
Ocean City is dry. It has been since its founding in 1879 by Methodist ministers, and the sale of alcohol is not permitted in the city, so that diners at its restaurants bring their own bottles. The state's regulations on liquor licenses are strict and local, and in a dry town the licensing question never arises. Ocean City's dry boardwalk: myths and facts about a Methodist resort tells the story, and Ocean City, the dry town, and the BYOB vote that failed covers how the bring-your-own rule works in practice. Other places have different rules, and a few towns on the Shore have little nightlife at all.
The reverse myth is also true. Plenty of Shore towns have a lively bar scene, and in Atlantic City the state's gaming regulations apply to casinos that can serve alcohol on the gaming floor. The point is that the Shore does not have a single rule. The town you are in decides.
Myth 4: You always have to pay to use the beach
Most of the ocean beaches on the Jersey Shore charge for access through a beach tag, a badge for the season, the week or the day. That fact is true often enough that visitors assume it is true everywhere. It is not. Atlantic City, Strathmere, North Wildwood, Wildwood and Wildwood Crest do not charge for the beach. The Wildwoods in particular have built a reputation for free beaches, and wildwood: the boardwalk and the free beaches tells why.
In the towns that charge, the rules vary. Tags are sold by the town, and each sets its prices, its dates, its hours when tags are checked and its discounts for seniors, children and residents. The guide Jersey Shore beach tags and access explains how to find a town's rules before you go. A pricing note: this post leaves out the dollar amounts, because they change each season and are posted by each municipality.
Myth 5: The beaches are private
They are not. New Jersey law treats the tidal shore, up to the mean high water line, as held in trust for the public, a principle known as the public trust doctrine. The state's Supreme Court extended it in 1984 in a case called Matthews v. Bay Head Improvement Association, which held that the public has a right to use the dry sand area, too, where it is needed to reach and enjoy the ocean, and that a private beach club could not exclude the public from that stretch. That case is the reason people can walk along the beach in front of expensive houses. Municipalities that charge for beaches may do so for the upkeep of beaches, lifeguards and services, but they may not shut the public out. Specific rules on access points, fees and hours are in the Department of Environmental Protection's coastal regulations and in each town's ordinances, and anyone who thinks access has been blocked can ask the Department.
The practical part: a public beach in a tag town needs a tag, and a public beach with no tag requirement is free. A person who walks along the water's edge is within the public's rights. A person who sets up a chair on a private beach club's dry sand may be on someone's property, depending on what the town and the court decisions allow; the guide above has the details.
Myth 6: Sandy destroyed the Shore and it never came back
Superstorm Sandy, which made landfall near Brigantine on October 29, 2012, did enormous damage. Published estimates put the damage at about $29.4 billion, the costliest natural disaster in New Jersey history, with about 346,000 homes damaged and about 30,000 destroyed or significantly damaged. Some 2.7 million households and businesses lost power. The Shore took the brunt: the storm flooded barrier islands, tore up boardwalks, pushed houses off foundations and carved new channels. Sandy, October 29, 2012 tells the storm, and After Sandy: the Seaside Heights rebuild tells the recovery.
The Shore did come back. Boardwalks were rebuilt, dunes were raised, businesses reopened and the summer season returned. But the long tail of Sandy is still visible in the way the state talks about the coast: in the elevation of houses, the buyouts of flood-prone homes in programs like those in Blue Acres: buying out flood-prone homes, the dune projects and the debates over how to rebuild. The truth is neither that it is as it was nor that it was lost. The Shore is a place that has to be rebuilt after storms and keeps choosing to.
Myth 7 (a bonus): The Shore is only a summer place
The season is real. Memorial Day weekend and Labor Day weekend mark the edges of it, and the busiest weeks are in July and August. But the Shore is a year-round place, with permanent residents, schools, shops and a calendar of events from fall festivals to winter walks. Prices fall, crowds thin, the light changes, and many people consider the shoulder seasons the best time to go. The Jersey Shore summer calendar covers the season and the shore in the off-season covers the rest of the year. Asbury Park's boardwalk and music scene, the subject of Asbury Park and the music scene, are an example of a Shore town that does not close in September.
A worked example: reading one town's rules
Say a family from Morris County wants a Saturday in July at a Monmouth County beach town they have not visited. Before leaving, one of them opens the town's website and looks for four things. First, whether the beach requires a tag, and if it does, where tags are sold and what hours are enforced; some towns check tags only while lifeguards are on duty. Second, parking: whether the town uses meters, permits or a lot, and how early the lots fill on a summer weekend. Third, the rules on dogs, alcohol, grills and umbrellas, all of which are set locally. Fourth, the lifeguard schedule, because a beach without a guard on duty is a beach to stay out of the water.
The answers differ from town to town, and a town twenty minutes down the coast may give opposite ones. The exercise takes ten minutes and prevents the most common ruined Saturday.
Rip currents and the flags
The most serious risk on any ocean beach is the water. Rip currents are narrow channels of water that pull swimmers away from shore, and they form on calm days as well as stormy ones. Swim where a lifeguard is on duty, follow the flags and instructions, and if you are caught in a rip, swim parallel to the beach until you are out of the channel and then angle back. The National Weather Service forecast offices that cover New Jersey, at Upton, New York, and Mount Holly, issue surf and rip current statements, and the guards' flags and the town's website carry the same warnings. coastal flooding and nor'easters: what to know on the shore covers the winter side of the coast.
A short, honest guide for visitors
- Decide which Shore you want. A boardwalk and rides, a quiet barrier island, a casino city or a Victorian town.
- Check the town's rules before you go. Beach tags, alcohol, parking, dogs, and hours differ.
- Keep local cash and a charged phone. Parking meters and tag checkers do not accept excuses.
- Watch the weather and the tide. Storm surge and rip currents are real hazards; follow lifeguards' flags and instructions.
- Go off-season at least once. It is a different place.
None of the myths is harmless in the way a tall tale is harmless. Each leads to a wrong assumption about cost, access or what the day will be like. The facts are better than the legends, and they are on the town's own website.