Blog
Ocean City, the dry town, and the BYOB vote that failed
Why a Methodist-founded 1879 resort still bans alcohol, how voters turned down bring-your-own in 2012, and what that means for the restaurants and boardwalk.
Drive from Atlantic City to Ocean City on a summer weekend and you cross an invisible line. In one resort, bars and casinos run through the night. In the other, you can buy a funnel cake on the boardwalk, a slice of pizza and a bag of saltwater taffy, but you cannot buy a beer, and you cannot even bring one to dinner. Ocean City is dry, it has been dry since the day it was founded, and when voters were asked in 2012 whether to loosen the rule just a little, they said no by about two to one.
For a New Jersey shore town, that is an unusual position, and it is a deliberate one. Ocean City sells itself as "America's Greatest Family Resort," a motto its chamber of commerce adopted in 1920. The restaurants, the boardwalk and the beaches are all built around it. This is the story of how the town got that way and what the dry rule does to the way people eat and play there.
Founded as a retreat
Ocean City's founding is a religious story. On September 10, 1879, four Methodist ministers, Ezra B. Lake, James Lake, S. Wesley Lake and William Burrell, chose a stretch of barrier island for a Christian seaside retreat. The island was known as Peck's Beach, a sandy strip between the Atlantic and Great Egg Harbor Bay, and the founders meant to build a resort where families could vacation without the saloons and the rowdiness found in other shore towns.
The town was formed as a borough on May 3, 1884, and incorporated as a city on March 25, 1897. Through all of those changes, the rule against alcohol sales survived. Ocean City has not allowed the sale of alcohol since its founding.
Later rules built on that. The town banned public drinking on the beach in 1951 and all public consumption in 1958. A city ordinance of 1984 banned BYOB, the practice of bringing your own wine or beer into a restaurant, which some restaurants had informally tolerated before. Together those rules make Ocean City one of the strictest places on the shore. As of 2016 it was one of 32 dry towns in New Jersey, a state in which most communities sell alcohol freely. A loophole lets private dining clubs next to restaurants serve their members.
The boardwalk that was rebuilt
The boardwalk is the town's centerpiece. It is about 2.45 miles long and was first built in 1880. In 1927, a fire destroyed a large part of it, causing $1.5 million in damage, and the town rebuilt it about 300 feet closer to the ocean. The Music Pier, a landmark on the boardwalk, was completed for the 1929 season. A $10 million rebuild from 5th Street to 12th Street was finished in March 2018.
The boardwalk's amusements have changed. Wonderland Pier, later known as Gillian's Wonderland Pier, opened in 1965 at 6th Street and closed permanently after the 2024 season. Playland's Castaway Cove at 10th Street remains. The rides and the arcades are the ones a family expects, and none of the stands sells alcohol, which is part of the point. Boardwalk food on the Seaside Heights and Wildwood boardwalks compares this kind of food with the neighboring shore towns' boardwalks.
The 2012 vote
By the early 2010s, a group in Ocean City wanted a modest change. They proposed to allow BYOB: diners could bring their own wine or beer to a restaurant, with the restaurant selling none. They did not want bars or liquor stores. They described it as a limited step that would help restaurants.
The argument turned on the competition. Supporters of BYOB said the city's struggling restaurants were losing customers to restaurants on the mainland that served liquor. A family that wanted a glass of wine with dinner would eat across the bay and take their appetite with them. BYOB, they said, would keep that business in town without changing the dry status. One of the supporters put it simply: nobody wanted to lose the dry-town distinction, and with BYOB it would still be a dry town.
Opponents saw it differently. They feared that allowing drinking in restaurants would damage the family atmosphere that gave the town its identity, and they argued that the city's appeal lay in rejecting public drinking altogether. A motel owner who spoke in favor of staying dry said as much.
The question went to the voters. It was first expected to appear on a November ballot, then was pulled over a question about state law, and in the end it was decided in a May 2012 vote. On Tuesday, May 8, the proposal lost, with 68.8 percent of voters opposed. The vote counts were reported as about 3,365 against and 1,526 in favor, close to two to one. The result kept the 1984 ban in place.
The arithmetic of the result
The reported counts add up to a clear picture. If 3,365 voters said no and 1,526 said yes, that is 4,891 votes in all, and the no side took 68.8 percent of them, which matches the percentage reported for the result. Another report gave unofficial tallies of 3,137 and 1,425, which comes out to a similar ratio of just over two to one. However the final count was counted, the margin was not close, and it was the same answer the city had given in one form or another for 133 years.
The dry rule in dates
| Date | Rule or event |
|---|---|
| September 10, 1879 | Four Methodist ministers choose the island for a Christian retreat |
| May 3, 1884 | Ocean City becomes a borough |
| March 25, 1897 | Ocean City is incorporated as a city |
| 1920 | The chamber of commerce adopts "America's Greatest Family Resort" |
| 1951 | Drinking on the beach is banned |
| 1958 | All public consumption is banned |
| 1984 | A city ordinance bans BYOB |
| May 2012 | Voters reject a BYOB proposal, about two to one |
What the dry rule does to restaurants
The practical effects fall on three groups.
Restaurant owners compete without a liquor license and without BYOB. They sell food and soft drinks, and their margins depend on volume and on families. A restaurant in a resort town with a short season has little room for error, and supporters of BYOB argued that the ban made it harder.
Visitors adapt. A group that wants a drink with dinner has a choice: skip it, or eat somewhere else. The mainland towns across the bay serve alcohol. Ocean City's own answer is the boardwalk and the beach, the family activities that the town markets.
Residents live with a rule that most of them chose. The year-round population was 11,229 in the 2020 census, down from 11,701 in 2010 and 15,378 in 2000. In summer, an estimated 115,000 to 130,000 people are within the city limits.
None of this is a secret in the shore economy. It is the reason Ocean City markets itself to families with children and multi-generational groups. Ocean City covers the town, and Atlantic City is the contrast.
The money side
A family resort still has a business model, and Ocean City's shows in its beaches. The city earned $5.9 million from beach tags in 2025, the most of any New Jersey municipality. The beach has been replenished more than 30 times since 1951. Jersey Shore beach tags and access explains how tags work around the shore.
The town's bridges tie it to the mainland: a drawbridge at 34th Street dating to 1883, the 34th Street (Roosevelt Boulevard) Bridge to Marmora, the Ocean City-Longport Bridge to Egg Harbor Township and the 9th Street Bridge on Route 52 to Somers Point. The Route 52 causeway is the main road in, and it is where the town's summer traffic piles up.
Dry towns across the state
Ocean City is not alone. In 2016, it was one of 32 dry towns in the state, which leaves the other 500-plus municipalities on the opposite path. Most New Jersey towns allow alcohol sales, and in many of them restaurants are BYOB by choice. Ocean City's rule is the exception, and a source of its distinct reputation.
The question of who decides is itself a New Jersey story. Alcohol rules here are a mix of state law and local choice, and a town like Ocean City can set its own limits within that framework. That is part of the home-rule tradition that explains why the state has 564 municipalities. Why New Jersey has 564 municipalities tells that story.
What to expect as a visitor
A short guide for a first trip.
- Plan dinner without wine. Restaurants in town do not serve alcohol, and BYOB is not permitted.
- Pack the family items. The beach, the boardwalk and the rides are the draw. Beach tags are required in season.
- Bring cash for the boardwalk and a card for the rest. Stands vary.
- Check the pier schedules. The boardwalk's amusements change with the years, and one major pier closed after the 2024 season.
- Drive in early or late. The Route 52 causeway and the bridge approaches back up on summer weekends.
Ocean City remains one of the most deliberately designed places on the Jersey Shore. The beach, the boardwalk and the dry law all serve a single idea, set down in 1879 by four ministers and reaffirmed by voters in 2012. Whether that idea is a charm or a limit depends on the visitor, and the town has been content to let people choose. Ocean City's dry boardwalk: myths and facts about a Methodist resort looks at the broader picture of the town as a dry resort.