Blog

After Sandy: the Seaside Heights rebuild

The Star Jet coaster stood in the surf for months until May 14, 2013; the boardwalk rebuild, the September fire and what Sandy cost New Jersey overall.

For more than six months, the best-known roller coaster in New Jersey stood in the Atlantic Ocean. It had not been built there. It had ridden on a pier at Seaside Heights, until the night of October 29, 2012, when the surge from Sandy tore the pier out from under it and the structure settled into the surf, twisted but upright, a cartoon of what the storm had done. It stayed there through the winter, and the photograph of it, a coaster with waves breaking around its legs, became the picture the rest of the country had of the Jersey Shore after Sandy. On May 14, 2013, a crane finally tore it down. By then it had become something more than a ruined ride. It was a deadline, a symbol and a question: would the town come back, and as what?

The storm

Sandy came ashore as an extratropical cyclone at about 7:30 p.m. on October 29, 2012, near Brigantine in Atlantic County. It was no longer a hurricane by the technical definition, but the technical definition did not matter to the places it hit. The storm coincided with the high tides of a full moon, and its surge, along with a wide wind field that pushed water against the coast for hours, flooded the barrier islands and bayside towns from Cape May to Sandy Hook.

In New Jersey, the numbers are large. The state counts 38 deaths in the storm, by one standard tally, though the figures differ by source and by how deaths from indirect causes are counted. The damage was about $29.4 billion, which makes Sandy the costliest natural disaster in the state's history. About 346,000 homes were damaged, and about 30,000 were destroyed or significantly damaged. About 2.7 million households and businesses lost power. Those figures cover the state, from the flooded streets of Hoboken to the wiped-out bungalows of the Raritan Bayshore and the barrier islands of Ocean County.

Reading the numbers

Statewide totals are hard to feel, so a bit of arithmetic helps. If about 346,000 homes were damaged and about 30,000 were destroyed or significantly damaged, then roughly one damaged home in twelve was a heavy loss, about 8.7 percent. The other 316,000 or so needed repairs that ranged from a flooded basement to a gutted first floor, and they are the part of the story that rarely made the news: the families who spent a winter in a hotel, a relative's spare room or a house with no heat while insurance adjusters and contractors, in short supply, worked through a long line.

The power numbers carry their own lesson. With 2.7 million households and businesses losing power, the outage was not a coastal event. It reached into suburbs and farm towns far from any boardwalk, because wind brought down trees and lines across the state. It is also why the state's guidance on storm preparation now begins with the basics: know your utility's outage number, keep a charged phone and a battery radio, and sign up for the emergency alerts that your county and the state offer.

Why Seaside Heights

Seaside Heights is a small borough on the Barnegat Peninsula, a narrow sliver of land in Ocean County between Barnegat Bay and the ocean. It borders Berkeley Township, Seaside Park and Toms River. In the 2020 Census it had 2,440 year-round residents, down 15.5 percent from 2010. In summer, the population can swell to anywhere from 30,000 to 65,000. The seasonal swing is enormous: a summer crowd of 30,000 is about twelve times the winter population, and a crowd of 65,000 is more than twenty-six times it. It is a boardwalk town in the full sense: a two-mile boardwalk, two amusement piers, Casino Pier and Funtown Pier, each reaching about 300 feet into the ocean, and a water park across from Casino Pier that was then called Water Works. The borough was incorporated on February 26, 1913, from parts of Berkeley and Dover townships, and Dover Township is now Toms River.

Sandy was hard on the peninsula in a particular way. The island is so narrow that the ocean and the bay can meet over the middle of it, and during the storm the surge ripped pieces off both piers and sent rides collapsing into the ocean. North of Seaside Heights, in Mantoloking, the storm breached the barrier island itself. Seaside Heights was close enough to the center of that damage that its piers, boardwalk and many houses took the brunt.

The roller coaster at the center of the story was technically the Star Jet, a replacement for an earlier ride called the Jet Star that had operated on Casino Pier from 1970 until 2000. Almost every news account used the older name, and the confusion was so common that the ride's own history now has a paragraph about it. Whatever it was called, it fell into the water with the pier, and removing it from the ocean was a project of its own.

The rebuild, in order

Winter 2012-13: Assessment and uncertainty. The first months after the storm were a period of debris removal, power restoration and fighting over what could be rebuilt and where. Homeowners faced questions about elevation requirements and flood insurance, and business owners faced questions about whether the pier, owned by a private company, could be rebuilt before the summer.

May 14, 2013: The coaster comes down. A wrecker dismantled the ride and cleared it from the ocean, a little over six months after the storm. News crews covered it as if it were the end of a chapter, which it was.

June 21, 2013: The boardwalk is whole. Repairs to the boardwalk were completed by June 21, 2013, in time for the first full weeks of summer. Casino Pier reopened about nine months after the storm, with rebuilt rides.

Summer 2013: The season that had to happen. The state's tourism campaign for the shore that year carried the slogan "Stronger Than the Storm," and the argument behind it was simple: the shore economy depends on a single three-month season, and a lost summer would have cost businesses, seasonal workers and the towns that rely on their taxes far more than a repaired boardwalk cost to build. The season went forward, with caution, and visitors came.

The second blow

What residents and visitors remember with almost the same sharpness as Sandy is the fire. On September 12, 2013, less than a year after the storm, a ten-alarm fire started near Funtown Pier and spread north along the boardwalk. Firefighters stopped it at Lincoln Avenue, partly by tearing up the boardwalk that had just been rebuilt after Sandy so the fire could not travel along it. The fire destroyed boardwalk businesses in both Seaside Heights and Seaside Park, and it came with the sense of cruelty that disasters sometimes have, the feeling that a place had been given one chance and then another had been taken away.

Seaside Heights has been here before. On June 9, 1955, a blaze known as Freeman's Fire destroyed 85 buildings and caused an estimated $4 million in damage. The town rebuilt then, as it did after Sandy and after the 2013 fire. A different kind of history is the carousel, built in 1935, which was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2026.

Where things stand

A decade-plus later, Seaside Heights is operating in a different shape. A new coaster arrived on Casino Pier in 2017, a replacement for the one the ocean took. The borough has kept its summer role as the shore's most crowded boardwalk, and the summer weekend traffic on Route 37, which crosses the bay on the Thomas A. Mathis and J. Stanley Tunney bridges to Toms River and meets the Garden State Parkway at exit 82, is a famous annoyance. The year-round population is much smaller than the summer one, and the question of how a town of 2,440 people carries the costs of a boardwalk town is the borough's constant budget problem.

The larger changes are in how the shore handles the next storm. Dunes, rebuilt beaches and elevated houses are all a part of the answer, and so are programs to buy and remove the most flood-prone houses. Blue Acres: buying out flood-prone homes covers the state's buyout program. For what to do before a storm, Emergency alerts and storm preparation in New Jersey and coastal flooding and nor'easters: what to know on the shore are the practical guides, and the state's emergency alert information is on the NJOEM page, which is where residents are directed to sign up for NJOEM alerts and to learn about their county's alert system.

What Sandy changed

Three changes stand out from the storm, and they show up in conversations on the shore even now.

  1. Elevation became ordinary. Houses on stilts, once a curiosity, are a standard sight in Ocean and Monmouth counties. Flood maps and insurance rules push owners to raise their homes, and the skyline of a street can reflect which houses have been done.
  2. Retreat became thinkable. Before Sandy, the idea of the state buying homes and tearing them down was marginal. Afterward, programs that did exactly that moved from the margins to the mainstream in the places most prone to repeated flooding.
  3. The season became a risk. A shore town's economy depends on a narrow window of the year. After 2012 and 2013, municipal leaders talk more about extending it with events, off-season businesses and year-round residents, and about the weather risk that sits underneath.

The coaster is gone, but the picture of it is not. It remains a reminder that on the New Jersey coast the line between a summer postcard and a disaster photograph can be a single night's tide. For the town today, see Seaside Heights and, for the county seat across the bay, Toms River; the boardwalk's long arc is told in Seaside Heights: the boardwalk and the storm.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic