Blog
The Highlands Act and the water supply
The 2004 act protects 88 municipalities in seven northern counties because more than 70 percent of New Jerseyans drink water that comes from the Highlands.
Turn on a tap in Newark, in Paterson or in New Brunswick, and there is a fair chance the water began its trip in the hills of northwestern New Jersey. The state's Highlands region, a belt of ridges, forests, lakes and small towns running from the Delaware River in the southwest to the New York line in the northeast, is where much of the water for the densest part of the state falls, collects and flows downhill. The Highlands Council, the state agency that oversees the region, puts the point bluntly: more than 70 percent of New Jersey residents get some or all of their drinking water from the Highlands. That is why the Legislature passed a law in 2004 to protect the land the water crosses, and it is why the law has been argued about ever since.
The place
The Highlands are the New Jersey part of a larger geological province, the New York-New Jersey Highlands, made mostly of ancient Precambrian rock. It runs from the Delaware River, near Musconetcong Mountain, to the Hudson at Storm King Mountain in New York. The southern section, the New Jersey Highlands, covers about 860,000 acres, around 1,340 square miles, roughly 15 percent of the state's total area. It reaches into seven northern counties: Bergen, Hunterdon, Morris, Passaic, Somerset, Sussex and Warren. Eighty-eight municipalities lie wholly or partly inside it.
It is a distinct landscape: forested ridges, river valleys and glacial lakes, with a patchwork of farms, old iron-mining and furnace sites, and some of the state's most expensive and scenic suburbs. It contains headwaters of the Passaic, Raritan and Delaware river systems, along with lakes and reservoirs that supply water to millions of people. Its wooded hills filter and store rainfall, and the streams that leave it carry water south and east to the cities and suburbs that need it. See Stokes State Forest and Kittatinny Valley State Park: Sussex County's ridge and valley for a sense of what the northern end looks like on the ground.
By the numbers
A few simple calculations show the scale. New Jersey has 8,722.58 square miles of total area, so a region of 1,340 square miles is 15.4 percent of it. The state has 564 municipalities, so the 88 in the Highlands are about 15.6 percent, roughly one in six. The Preservation Area, at about 398,000 acres, is a bit under half, 46 percent, of the region's roughly 860,000 acres. On the Council, five municipal seats and three county seats make eight of fifteen, a majority of 53 percent held by local officials. And if more than 70 percent of residents draw some or all of their drinking water from the region, then in a state of about 9.5 million people, the Highlands touch the taps of something like 6.7 million. That last figure is an inference from the Council's percentage, not a count of customers, but it shows why a region under one-sixth of the state's size is treated as a statewide asset.
Why a law, and why in 2004
For decades the Highlands were a place of quiet pressure. As the suburbs of New York pushed west and the Philadelphia area pushed north, the Highlands' hills and farms became prime targets for housing developments, office parks and shopping centers. Each project was permitted on its own merits, one at a time, and the cumulative effect was a gradual loss of forest and an increase in paved surface, which sends more polluted runoff into the streams that feed reservoirs. Conservation groups, among them the New Jersey Highlands Coalition, formed in 1988 to push for protection, and water suppliers worried about the quality and quantity of their source.
The Legislature acted in 2004. The Highlands Water Protection and Planning Act was signed into law on August 10, 2004, by Governor James McGreevey. It was written to protect the region's drinking water supply, and it did so by creating a regional planning body, drawing a boundary and setting different rules for different parts of the region. In the same year, Congress passed the federal Highlands Conservation Act, which acknowledged the national significance of the region and authorized federal help for land preservation.
How the Act works
The Act divides the region in two.
The Preservation Area. This is the core: land that the Act designates as having exceptional natural resource value, including the most important water-supply lands. The Department of Environmental Protection puts it at about 398,000 acres, though other counts have given a somewhat higher figure. In the Preservation Area, the Act and the DEP's rules set strict environmental standards for major development, and a project generally needs approval from the DEP under those rules. The Act also contains exemptions, for example for certain existing uses and small projects, and part of the law's history has been fights over what they cover.
The Planning Area. Everything else in the Highlands region is the Planning Area. Here the rules are lighter. Municipalities and counties are encouraged to bring their local plans into line with the regional plan, and the approach is largely voluntary. A town that chooses to take part gets assistance from the Council, including planning grants, and in return commits to follow the Highlands plan.
The Council. The Act created the Highlands Water Protection and Planning Council, a 15-member body. Five members must be municipal officials from the Highlands region and three must be county officials from the region, so that local officials hold a large share of the seats. The Council wrote the Regional Master Plan, which was adopted in 2008, and it staffs the effort with planners, environmental scientists and mapping specialists. Its executive director is named on the Council's own website, and its public meetings follow a posted calendar.
The tools
The Highlands approach relies on three kinds of tool.
- Mapping and standards. The Council maintains maps of the region's resources, including its forests, streams, wetlands, steep slopes and groundwater recharge areas, which feed into the plan's rules about where development is appropriate. The Council offers an online Resource Explorer tool, so a landowner or town can see what lies on a given parcel.
- Conformance. Towns and counties that bring their master plans and ordinances into line with the regional plan are said to conform. Conformance is where the plan meets local zoning.
- Preservation money and credits. The Act pairs regulation with programs to buy land and to move development rights from protected land to places where growth is appropriate, a counterpart to the credit system used in the Pinelands; see Protecting the Pinelands. The Council also tracks land preserved through state, county and municipal programs.
What the Council works on now
The Council's website shows the range of its present work. The topics listed include the Regional Master Plan and conformance, an economic sustainability plan, open space and preservation, planning grants, affordable housing, warehousing, agriculture, climate, forests, lakes, stormwater, wastewater and watersheds. It posted a 2025 annual report and, in January 2026, a State of the New Jersey Highlands report prepared for the incoming administration. The mix says something about how the region has changed: the pressures of the twenty-first century are not only housing subdivisions, but large warehouses near highways, the demand for affordable housing and the effects of heavier rain and hotter summers.
Affordable housing deserves a special note, because the Highlands law and the state's affordable-housing system have a complicated relationship. Towns in the Highlands must meet housing obligations under the court-created system known as Mount Laurel, and the Highlands rules limit where large developments may go. The Council's pages treat the topic directly, and Affordable housing and the Mount Laurel system explains the housing side.
The argument
The Highlands Act has always had both defenders and critics, and the dispute is not a simple one.
Supporters say that the region's water is a shared resource that serves millions of people, and that protecting its source is cheaper than cleaning polluted water later. They argue that the Act's regional approach was needed because individual towns, each trying to expand its own tax base, could not protect the watershed by themselves.
Critics make several points. Landowners in the Preservation Area say the Act reduced the value of their land by limiting what they can build, and that compensation through credits and purchases is incomplete. Some towns complain that they lose development and tax revenue and that the rules override local zoning. Builders say that permitting is slow. And some residents in the Planning Area worry that voluntary conformance will turn into pressure.
The Act's design, with local officials holding eight of the Council's 15 seats and a Planning Area that is largely voluntary, was an answer to exactly those concerns.
What it means for a resident
For most people the Act is invisible. Water comes out of the tap, and the process that protects its source is far away. For people who live or own land in the 88 municipalities, the Act shapes what can be built and how, and the Council and the DEP are the places to ask. For anyone who wants to know where their water comes from, the answer begins with the utility on the bill, and power outages and gas leaks: utility emergency numbers lists the companies and emergency numbers by region. For the wider water picture, see The Passaic, the Raritan and the Mullica: three rivers, three Jerseys and Drought and the water supply: how New Jersey declares a dry spell, and for the agency, the Pinelands Commission and Highlands Council page.
The Highlands are not a park. They are a working landscape of farms, houses and small towns that happens to sit above a great deal of the state's water. The Act is the state's attempt to let people keep living there while keeping the water clean.