Blog

Affordable housing and the Mount Laurel system

How a Burlington County township gave its name to a constitutional rule that reaches all 564 municipalities, and how the 2024 law changed who counts the units.

Mount Laurel is a township in Burlington County, a few miles east of Camden, with the sort of subdivisions and shopping centers that most people would not cross a state line to see. It is also the name of a legal doctrine that has shaped what gets built in every town in New Jersey for fifty years. People say "Mount Laurel" in planning board meetings the way they say "home rule," and they do not always mean the same thing. This is an attempt to say what the system is, how it has changed, and where the arguments are.

The short version: the state Supreme Court held that the New Jersey Constitution requires every municipality to give a realistic chance for housing that low- and moderate-income households can afford. The Legislature then tried several times to turn that duty into a process, and the courts kept getting pulled back in. In 2024 the state passed a new law, and the current round of obligations is running under it.

The decisions

In 1975 the Supreme Court decided Southern Burlington County NAACP v. Township of Mount Laurel. The township's zoning had made it nearly impossible to build anything but single-family houses on large lots, which priced out poorer residents, many of whom had grown up in the township. The court held that a developing municipality could not use its zoning power to exclude people by income, and that it had to provide, by its land-use rules, a realistic opportunity for its fair share of the region's low- and moderate-income housing.

The decision had little effect on the ground at first. Many towns found ways to comply on paper. In 1983 the court returned to the case in what is called Mount Laurel II. It said more plainly that the obligation reached every municipality that had land the state's growth plan treated as suitable for growth, and not only a handful of fast-developing suburbs. It created the "builder's remedy," under which a developer who sues a town that has not met its obligation can win the right to build, with a share of the units set aside as affordable. The court also directed that the work be handled by a few trial judges, to get consistency.

Two years later, in 1985, the Legislature passed the Fair Housing Act, which created the Council on Affordable Housing, known as COAH, and gave towns a chance to work through an agency instead of in court. COAH was supposed to calculate each town's obligation, review its plan and give it a certificate that protected it from builder's remedy suits. It adopted rules for what are called "rounds" of obligations, the first beginning in the late 1980s. Its rules became the subject of repeated litigation, and the agency stopped functioning as an effective body years before the 2024 law formally ended it. In 2015 the Supreme Court held that, because COAH was not doing the job, towns could go to court to get a judge's approval of their plans, and the trial courts took the work back.

What "fair share" means

A town's obligation has two parts. The "present need" counts existing housing that is substandard or overcrowded in the municipality, and the "prospective need" is the share of the region's expected growth in low- and moderate-income households that the town must plan for. Under the Fair Housing Act, moderate-income households are those at or below 80 percent of the region's median income, and low-income households are at or below 50 percent. The rest is arithmetic and negotiation.

The way a town meets its obligation is partly zoning and partly money. The usual tools are:

  • Inclusionary zoning. A town lets a developer build at a higher density than the zoning otherwise allows, on condition that a portion of the units is set aside as affordable.
  • Overlay zones and rezoning. A town designates sites where apartments are allowed that were not before.
  • Rehabilitation. Repairing existing homes that need work and keeping them affordable.
  • Municipal affordable housing trust funds, fed by development fees on non-residential construction and some residential building, which pay for projects.
  • Mixed-income projects and 100 percent affordable developments, often financed by the state's Housing and Mortgage Finance Agency.
  • Bonus credits. In some cases a unit counts for more than one against a town's obligation.

The units carry deed restrictions that keep them affordable for decades, and an administrative agent for each project handles the income qualification and the lottery or rent-up.

The 2024 law

On March 20, 2024, the governor signed a package of bills led by A-4 and S-50. The Department of Community Affairs described it as a new framework for setting and enforcing municipal affordable housing obligations under the Mount Laurel doctrine and the Fair Housing Act, replacing a process that had played out entirely in the courts.

Its main features:

  1. COAH is formally abolished. The council, which the state's own release called defunct for over a decade, is gone as a legal matter.
  2. DCA publishes the numbers. The Department of Community Affairs calculates each municipality's present and prospective need, starting with the compliance period that began in 2025, using a formula based on earlier court decisions. The calculations are non-binding, but they set the reference point.
  3. Towns adopt their own number. A municipality sets its figure by binding resolution and files it with the court, and the courts look at whether it is in line with the state's calculation.
  4. A dispute program. Disagreements over obligations and plans are handled quickly by the judiciary, with help from a new dispute resolution program, the Affordable Housing Dispute Resolution Program. Advocates say disputes that used to take years now take months.
  5. Bonus credits with limits. Certain units, such as age-restricted housing, special-needs housing and housing near mass transit, can count as 1.5 or 2 units, with bonus credits capped at 25 percent of a municipality's prospective need.
  6. Related bills. The package included a Housing and Mortgage Finance Agency pilot to support insurance premiums for eligible affordable projects, accelerated depreciation, a sales tax exemption for materials and services used in 100 percent affordable projects, and authority for payment-in-lieu-of-taxes agreements on projects funded from municipal affordable housing trust funds.

The current period is the fourth round, covering 2025 to 2035. A group of 27 municipalities, led by Montvale, sued to challenge the law, and a judge rejected the challenge, so towns have continued preparing plans. A town that does not submit a plan is exposed to a builder's remedy suit, which is the incentive built into the system: a town that wants control of where the housing goes has a reason to file its own plan.

Where the Housing and Mortgage Finance Agency fits

The agency, HMFA, is the state's housing bank. It does not decide how many units a town owes. It finances them. The developers of affordable projects use its loans, its federal low-income tax credits and its programs, and the Housing and Mortgage Finance Agency's role in the 2024 package was to help projects pencil out. It is the difference between a plan and a building. The agency is part of the Department of Community Affairs' orbit; New Jersey Department of Community Affairs is the profile.

The arguments

The people who care most about this are not neutral, and a fair account gives both sides.

Supporters of the system say it is a rare case of a court holding the state to a promise in its own constitution. They point out that for generations suburban zoning kept out lower-income families, and that the rule has put affordable homes in suburbs that had built none. Housing advocates argue that a rule is meaningless without enforcement, and that builder's remedy suits are the enforcement.

Critics make three kinds of points. Some towns argue that the state's formulas are too large for their land, their roads and their schools, and that home rule means a municipality should decide what its density can bear. Some local officials say they feel they are asked to take on obligations the state has not paid for. And some on the other side say the system's reliance on market-rate development to produce affordable units, through set-asides, means that few affordable homes get built where there is no strong demand for the market ones.

There is also a debate about what the system is for. The doctrine began as a rule against exclusion, and critics on every side say that what it produces is a mixed set of apartments and townhouses, not an answer to a statewide shortage of affordable homes. Advocates counter that no other tool in the state has produced as many.

How it shows up in a town

A resident usually meets the system at a planning board meeting or a council meeting about a rezoning, a redevelopment plan or a development application with a set-aside. The headings are always the same: a "housing element and fair share plan," an "inclusionary overlay," an "affordable housing trust fund," a "settlement agreement" with a developer or an advocate. Reading those terms as pieces of one structure, rather than separate fights, is the way to follow the debate. Why New Jersey has 564 municipalities explains why the state has so many separate zoning authorities in the first place, and boroughs, townships, cities, towns and villages compared sorts out the municipal types. The tax side of any new development is in the property tax bill and where the money goes.

For people who want to apply for an affordable home, units are listed and rented or sold through the administrative agents for each project, and the income limits and the rules differ from one development to another. Buying a home in New Jersey and Renting in New Jersey: Truth in Renting and tenant rights cover the rest of the housing process. The state's courts, which handle the compliance cases and the builder's remedy suits, are described at New Jersey Judiciary, and the county governments whose planning offices help municipalities are at County government. Burlington County, where the story began, is the subject of Burlington County: Mount Holly and the Pines.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic