Blog

Boroughs, townships, cities, towns and villages compared

New Jersey has five legal types of municipality, from 253 boroughs to 4 villages. This compares how each came to be and why size says little about type.

A visitor looking at a New Jersey road map might reasonably assume that "city" means big and "borough" means small. It would be a reasonable guess, and it would be wrong about half the time. The state has five legal types of municipality, and the label on the sign tells you how the place was incorporated, not how many people live there. Lakewood Township had 135,158 residents on the 2020 Census, within shouting distance of the city of Elizabeth's 137,298, while Loch Arbour, a village on the Monmouth County shore, is one of the tiniest governments in the state.

Before the comparison, a reminder of the counts. New Jersey has 564 municipalities: 253 boroughs, 240 townships, 52 cities, 15 towns and 4 villages. Those add to 564 and they cover every acre in the state. What follows sets them side by side.

The short version

Type Count Where it comes from A few examples
Borough 253 The Borough Act of 1878, which let a township split off by petition and referendum Paramus, Fort Lee, most of Bergen County's 56 boroughs
Township 240 The oldest local form, many dating to the colonial era Lakewood, Edison, Woodbridge, Toms River, Hamilton, Cherry Hill
City 52 Charters and later general laws for urban places Newark, Jersey City, Paterson, Elizabeth, Trenton, Camden
Town 15 The Town Act of 1895, rewritten in 1988 Kearny, Harrison, Secaucus, Morristown
Village 4 The Village Act of 1891, effectively ended in 1989 Loch Arbour, Ridgefield Park, Ridgewood, South Orange

Boroughs: the most numerous and the most scattered

Boroughs outnumber every other type. The first, Elizabeth, was created by royal charter in 1740, and for a long time boroughs were individual acts of the Legislature. A constitutional amendment in 1875 stopped special legislation of that kind, and the Borough Act of 1878 replaced it with a general route: a part of a township could petition, hold a referendum and become its own borough. The wave of small boroughs that followed earned its own nickname, "boroughitis," and a 1894 school law prompted another round.

The result is a type that is typically small in area and population, concentrated in the north. Bergen County has 56 boroughs, the most of any county. Paramus, where Route 17 meets Garden State Parkway exit 163, is a borough, and so is Fort Lee at the George Washington Bridge approach. Boroughs tend to be compact, closely built places, and many of the state's commuter towns are boroughs. The traditional borough form of government has a mayor and a council, but many boroughs now use other arrangements.

Townships: the original unit

Townships are older than the state itself, and they were the basic local unit for much of New Jersey's rural history. A township covered a wide area, and when villages and neighborhoods grew inside it, some chose to leave and become boroughs. What remains are townships that are often large in land area, such as those in the Pinelands and along the Delaware River, and townships that have grown into some of the state's largest municipalities.

Lakewood Township, in Ocean County, had 135,158 people in 2020, and Edison Township in Middlesex had 107,588. Woodbridge Township had 103,639, Toms River Township 95,438, Hamilton Township in Mercer County 92,297 and Cherry Hill Township in Camden County 74,553. The label "township" can sit on a place bigger than most cities in other states.

Of the state's 240 townships, 141 use the township form of government, with a committee that is elected and chooses a mayor from among its members. The others have adopted other forms, including those offered by the Faulkner Act. That point matters: a township is a legal type, but its government can look like a city's.

Cities: fewer than you would guess

There are 52 cities. They include the state's best-known urban centers: Newark with 311,549 people in 2020, Jersey City with 292,449, Paterson with 159,732, Elizabeth with 137,298, Trenton with 90,871 and Camden with 71,791. Atlantic City, at 38,497 people, is a city as well, and so are Clifton, Bayonne, Passaic, East Orange and Union City.

What makes a city a city is its charter and its history, not a population threshold. Cities can have any of the forms of government, including a mayor-council system under the Faulkner Act, a council-manager system or a commission, and some cities are much smaller than the biggest townships.

Towns: a small club

The 15 towns are a small group. The Town Act of 1895 let any area with more than 5,000 people petition to become a town, and the law governing the form was rewritten in 1988. Kearny, Harrison and Secaucus, all in Hudson County, are towns, and so are Morristown, the Morris County seat, and Newton, the Sussex County seat. A town is governed by a mayor and council.

With only 15, towns are a little like a club: each has its own story, and their legal type does not tell you much about size. They run from tight urban places along the Hudson to the seats of mostly rural counties.

Villages: a form that outlived its law

Villages are the rarest type, with four: Loch Arbour, Ridgefield Park, Ridgewood and South Orange. The Village Act of 1891 set up a board of trustees elected to three-year staggered terms, and the Village Act of 1989 effectively eliminated the form, so that from January 1, 1990 villages had to follow the laws for the township form. None of the four still uses the original village form. Loch Arbour switched to the Walsh Act commission form after a 2011 vote, Ridgefield Park moved to a Walsh Act form years earlier, Ridgewood adopted a Faulkner Act council-manager charter, and South Orange has a six-member Board of Trustees and a directly elected Village President under a special charter modeled on the old form.

So a village is a legal name that survives, not a government structure.

What size tells you, and what it does not

A quick check of the 25 largest municipalities by 2020 population shows how little the type correlates with size. Of the 25, 11 are cities and 14 are townships. The cities are Newark, Jersey City, Paterson, Elizabeth, Trenton, Clifton, Camden, Bayonne, Passaic, East Orange and Union City. The townships are Lakewood, Edison, Woodbridge, Toms River, Hamilton, Cherry Hill, Brick, Franklin in Somerset County, Middletown, Old Bridge, Gloucester, North Bergen, Irvington and Piscataway. No borough, town or village makes the list. The largest municipalities are therefore either old industrial cities or big suburban townships, while the boroughs, with their small footprints, make up the long tail.

That is why a statement like "the city of Lakewood" is wrong in a way locals notice. The correct name is Lakewood Township. Likewise there is no "city of Edison."

Type versus form: a second label

It helps to keep two labels apart. The type is the legal category set at incorporation: borough, township, city, town or village. The form is how the municipality is governed today. The forms in use across the state include the traditional borough and township structures, the commission form created by the Walsh Act of 1911, a municipal manager form from a 1923 law that seven municipalities use and the four plans of the Optional Municipal Charter Law of 1950, the Faulkner Act. Some places run on special charters that predate the general laws.

The Walsh Act was a Progressive Era reform meant to reduce political influence and corruption. Under it, voters elect three or five nonpartisan commissioners to four-year concurrent terms, and each commissioner holds both legislative and executive powers, usually by heading a department such as public safety or public works. Of the 240 townships, 141 still use the township form, which means about 99 have moved to something else. That is the sort of detail that makes municipal government in New Jersey look like a quilt.

Three counties, three mixes

The mix of types varies by region, and a quick look at three counties shows how.

  • Bergen County is the borough stronghold, with 56 boroughs among its municipalities, and it is also the most populous county, at 955,732 people in 2020. Its county seat is Hackensack, which is a city.
  • Hudson County is the opposite: a small, dense county of about 724,854 people where the biggest players are cities, such as Jersey City, the county seat, along with towns like Kearny, Harrison and Secaucus.
  • Ocean County is dominated by two large townships. Lakewood Township and Toms River Township, which is also the county seat, together held 230,596 people in 2020 (135,158 plus 95,438), more than a third of the county's 637,229 residents.

The arithmetic in that last bullet is worth a second look: 230,596 divided by 637,229 is about 36 percent, so more than a third of Ocean County lives in just two townships.

Reading a place name

Newcomers sometimes trip on the naming conventions, and a few rules of thumb help.

  1. The type is part of the legal name. The "Borough of Paramus" and the "Township of Lakewood" are the formal names, and the type often appears on forms, tax bills and court filings.
  2. A shared name does not mean a shared government. Franklin Township in Somerset County, with 68,364 people, has the same name as townships elsewhere in the state; the county name is how you tell them apart. The same is true of Washington, Hamilton and Union, which recur around the state.
  3. A town and a township are different things. "Town of Kearny" and "Township of Lakewood" sound alike and mean different legal types.
  4. Villages are a footnote. If you meet a village, it is one of four.

County clerks and the Department of Community Affairs list the official names, which is the safest source when you need to be exact on a form.

How the type affects daily life

In legal terms, all five types have the same basic powers. Any of them can pass ordinances, set a tax rate, run a police department and adopt a master plan. The differences are in structure and in history, and in practice the more important distinction is the form of government, which is a separate choice. The How Faulkner Act governments work explains the most common alternative forms.

For residents, the type matters in a few specific ways.

  • The name on the sign and the mail. The municipality's name, including its type, appears in official records, so use the full name when searching for a government's website.
  • Who is in charge. In some places the head of the governing body is a mayor elected by the voters, in others a mayor chosen by the council from among its members, and in a commission government each commissioner runs a department.
  • Where the money goes. The type does not set the tax rate, but a municipality's size, tax base and services do.
  • School districts. Most school districts follow municipal boundaries, though regional and consolidated districts serve multiple towns.

The Why New Jersey has 564 municipalities tells how the map came together, and the from freeholders to commissioners covers the county layer above it. If you want to see these types in action, the cities of Newark and Paterson are two of the biggest examples of the city type, both set in the state's northeast.

A note on names

One more wrinkle: municipalities often go by names that differ from the type. A "township" may call its government "Township of Lakewood," and a "borough" may be "Borough of Paramus." Some places use unexpected combinations. The state's Department of Community Affairs keeps the official list in its municipal data, and the county clerk's website lists the official name of every municipality in the county. When a document asks for a municipality, use the official name, type and all.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic