Blog

How Faulkner Act governments work

The 1950 Optional Municipal Charter Law, known as the Faulkner Act, lets towns pick a modern charter. Paterson's mayor-council form is the worked example here.

If you have ever sat through a New Jersey council meeting and wondered why one town has a strong mayor who vetoes ordinances, while the town next door has a manager nobody elected, the answer is probably a law passed in 1950. The Optional Municipal Charter Law, known to everyone in local government as the Faulkner Act, lets a municipality choose from a menu of modern forms of government, and more than half of all New Jerseyans now live in places that did.

The law carries the name of Bayard H. Faulkner, a former mayor of Montclair who chaired the commission that wrote it. Its premise was simple: the old forms, built for the 19th century, left many towns with weak executives and tangled lines of responsibility, so the state would offer tested alternatives that a town's voters could adopt by referendum. This is how the act works, with Paterson as the running example.

What the act offers

The Faulkner Act gives a municipality four forms, or plans, to choose from:

  1. Mayor-council. An elected mayor is the chief executive, and an elected council is the legislature. The two are separate, and the mayor can veto the council's ordinances, subject to an override.
  2. Council-manager. The council is elected and hires a professional manager to run day-to-day operations. The mayor, where there is one, is typically a member of the council.
  3. Small municipality. A simplified plan for smaller towns, with a mayor and council elected at large.
  4. Mayor-council-administrator. A hybrid in which an elected mayor and council share power with an appointed administrator who handles day-to-day management.

Each form has variations, because the act allows a town to choose features such as the size of the council and whether members are elected by ward, at large or by a mix. The state's Department of Community Affairs publishes the full text of the law, and the Division of Local Government Services answers questions about it.

Adopting a Faulkner Act form is a local decision. A town forms a charter study commission, which examines the options and recommends a form, and the voters then approve or reject the change in a referendum. A town that already has a charter can revise it the same way. That route is how places like Ridgewood, which became a council-manager municipality, and many of the state's larger cities moved to the Faulkner forms.

The mayor-council form, with Paterson as the example

Paterson, the state's third-largest city, with 159,732 residents in 2020, is governed under the Faulkner Act's mayor-council form. It is also a good illustration of how the form distributes power, because it is exactly the kind of city, a big, diverse, historic and often contentious one, that the strong-mayor model was designed for. Newark and Jersey City, the state's two largest municipalities, run on the same basic plan.

Under the mayor-council form:

  • The mayor is elected by all the city's voters and runs the administration. The mayor appoints department heads and a business administrator or equivalent, prepares the municipal budget, and signs or vetoes ordinances passed by the council.
  • The council is the legislative body. It passes ordinances, adopts the budget and confirms or oversees certain appointments. Many charters elect some members by ward and some at large, so every neighborhood has a voice and the whole city has a few members who answer to everyone.
  • The clerk is the council's officer and the keeper of the city's records. The municipal clerk takes minutes, publishes notices of meetings and ordinances and typically serves as the custodian of records for public records requests.

The mayor's veto is the signature feature of the form. A mayor can reject an ordinance, and the council can override with a supermajority specified in the charter. The check keeps either branch from acting alone, and it can also produce standoffs. The arrangement mirrors the federal and state models, an executive and a legislature with separate powers, scaled down to a city.

The budget shows the dynamics. The mayor proposes it and the council reviews, amends and adopts it, and the state's Division of Local Government Services supervises municipal budgets, which have to meet statutory requirements. Because municipal budgets are the largest piece of local government's work, much of the form's politics plays out there.

Council-manager, small municipality and the others

The council-manager form is often compared with the corporate model: the council is like a board of directors and the manager like a chief executive hired for professional skill. The manager serves at the council's pleasure and runs departments, prepares the budget and carries out the council's policies. Ridgewood, in Bergen County, is one of the places that adopted a council-manager charter under the act.

The small municipality plan is for places that do not need a full-scale administration. It gives them a mayor and council and a simpler structure. The mayor-council-administrator form splits the difference: the mayor and council are elected, and an administrator, appointed rather than elected, runs the daily operations of the municipality, which gives a smaller town some professional management without the manager's full powers.

Outside the Faulkner Act, other forms are still in use. The Walsh Act of 1911 created the commission form, in which three or five elected commissioners each run a department. Many boroughs and townships retain their traditional forms, with a borough mayor and council or a township committee. The boroughs, townships, cities, towns and villages compared sorts out how those legal types and forms fit together.

Strong mayor or professional manager: the argument

Which form is better is a long-running argument, and each side makes a case that is fair on its own terms.

Supporters of the strong-mayor model say it puts accountability in one place. Voters know who is responsible for the city's services and its budget, and they can reward or remove that person at the next election. In a large, diverse city, they argue, a mayor elected by everyone has the democratic authority to push through hard decisions, and a veto gives the executive a real voice in lawmaking.

Supporters of the manager model say that running a municipality is a technical job, with purchasing, personnel, public works and finance, and that a professional hired for skill and answerable to the council can run it more steadily than a politician who is distracted by campaigns. They also point out that the council, not a single executive, holds the power, which keeps decisions broad.

Critics of the strong-mayor model worry about concentrated power and standoffs between a mayor and a council. Critics of the manager model say an unelected official holds too much sway and that voters have no direct way to remove one. Neither concern disqualifies a form; towns weigh the tradeoffs and decide for themselves, and a charter study commission's hearings are where those arguments get aired.

What a meeting looks like

For a resident who has never attended, a Faulkner Act council meeting follows a predictable agenda. The presiding officer calls the meeting to order and the clerk confirms that the required public notice was given. Minutes of the previous meeting are approved, then comes a period of public comment on agenda items, followed by ordinances on first reading, ordinances on second reading with the public hearing, resolutions and reports from the mayor, the business administrator and the council's committees. A second public comment period often closes the evening.

Because notice and open meetings are required, the schedule is posted ahead of time, and the minutes become public records. A resident who wants to speak on an ordinance should look for it on the agenda under second reading, since that is when the hearing is held. The clerk's office can say when the meeting is and how to sign up. Not every town uses the same sign-up rules, so the municipal website is the right place to check the local procedure.

How an ordinance becomes law

Local lawmaking follows a standard sequence, and in a Faulkner Act town it runs through the clerk.

  1. Introduction. A member of the council introduces an ordinance, which is read on first reading at a public meeting.
  2. Publication. The ordinance is published in a newspaper of record, together with notice of when it will be considered again.
  3. Second reading and hearing. At a later meeting, the council holds a public hearing and may adopt the ordinance. Residents can speak at the hearing.
  4. Mayor's action. In the mayor-council form, the mayor then signs or vetoes it. If the mayor vetoes it, the council can try to override.
  5. Publication and effect. The adopted ordinance is published again and takes effect after the period the law provides.

Resolutions, which handle routine matters such as approving contracts or appointing people to boards, move faster and do not need the same two-step process. The public can attend any of it. New Jersey's Open Public Meetings Act requires that most meetings of public bodies be open and noticed in advance, and the how to attend and speak at a public meeting explains how to take part. For records, the municipal clerk is usually the first stop, and the How to file an OPRA request covers the process.

Why a town changes its charter

Charter changes usually come from a mix of dissatisfaction and aspiration. A town where the council runs everything may want a stronger executive. A growing town with a complicated budget may want a professional manager. A community that believes a ward system leaves some neighborhoods out may want one, and one that thinks wards fragment the council may want to elect more members at large.

The process is deliberately slow. A charter study commission is elected or appointed, holds hearings, drafts a recommendation and puts the question to voters. If the voters approve, the new form takes effect on a date set by the law, often after the next municipal election. The state does not require the change and does not stop one.

The change does not alter the legal type. A township that adopts a Faulkner Act form is still a township; a borough that adopts one is still a borough. That is why the state's counts by type, 253 boroughs, 240 townships, 52 cities, 15 towns and four villages, do not tell you how a place is governed.

What the form means for residents

A few practical points follow.

  • Find out the form. The municipality's website and the charter are available through the clerk's office, and the form tells you who to call about what.
  • Know who holds the budget pen. In a strong-mayor city, the mayor proposes the budget. In a council-manager town, the manager does.
  • Use the clerk. In every form, the municipal clerk is the person who knows where records, meeting schedules and ordinances are.
  • Watch the second reading. The hearing on second reading is the formal chance for the public to comment on an ordinance before it passes.

Many of the questions that come up in a city like Paterson or Newark, about zoning, budgets, contracts or the mayor's powers, trace back to the structure the Faulkner Act created. The structure explains a good deal of the local politics, and it is a reminder that in New Jersey, how a town is governed is a choice its own voters can make.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic