Blog
From freeholders to commissioners
New Jersey's county boards dropped the title "freeholder" in 2021. A look at where the word came from, what county boards do and what changed and what did not.
For more than two centuries, a New Jerseyan who wanted to know who ran the county had to learn an odd word. The county's governing body was the Board of Chosen Freeholders, and its members were "freeholders," a title that sounds more like a feudal estate than a job in county government. Out-of-staters assumed it was a joke. Nobody in New Jersey thought it was one, and nobody thought much about the word at all, until the state decided to retire it.
On August 21, 2020, the governor signed legislation, bill S855, that replaced "chosen freeholder" with "county commissioner" and "board of chosen freeholders" with "board of county commissioners." The change took effect on January 1, 2021. Counties had a year to update their letterhead, signs and websites. The work of the boards did not change at all, which is the main reason the story is worth telling carefully: it is about a name, and about what is underneath the name.
Where the word came from
A freeholder, in the English legal tradition that New Jersey inherited, was a person who owned land outright, a "free hold," as opposed to renting it or holding it from a lord. In the colonies, owning land was the ticket to political life. In colonial and early-statehood New Jersey, property ownership was a condition for voting and for holding office, and the county boards were made up of people chosen by the townships, hence "chosen freeholders."
The term stuck long after the property qualification disappeared, and it survived in the state's statutes until 2021. Supporters of the change pointed to the title's roots in a time when only property owners could take part in government, a group that included slaveholders, and argued that a modern county government should not carry that label. The Legislature agreed, and the title went.
What the boards looked like for most of their history
For much of the state's history, a county board was built from the bottom up. Each township or municipality sent one or two freeholders to the county board, which meant boards of widely varying size. The system gave tiny towns the same weight as large cities, and a county with dozens of municipalities could have a big, unwieldy board.
That ended in the 1960s, when federal court decisions on "one person, one vote" required local governing bodies to represent equal numbers of people. New Jersey restructured its county boards, and the result is the system you see today: boards of three, five, seven or nine members elected countywide or by district, serving staggered three-year terms. Whether a county uses a board of three or nine depends on the county's size and its own choice under state law.
What county commissioners do
The title changed; the job did not. A board of county commissioners is the legislative body of a county, and in most counties it is also the executive. The board adopts the county budget, sets the county's property tax levy, passes resolutions and ordinances and oversees county departments.
What the county does is a long list.
- Roads and bridges. County roads and bridges are a county responsibility, separate from the state highways and local streets.
- Parks and open space. Many counties run large park systems and fund open-space preservation.
- County colleges and vocational schools. County colleges, the community colleges, and vocational technical school districts are county institutions.
- Corrections. County jails, in most counties, are run by the county's corrections department or by a warden answering to county government.
- Health and human services. Counties run public health programs, offices on aging and services for children and families.
- Courts and the prosecutor. The county pays for much of the courthouse and the prosecutor's office, though the courts themselves are run by the state judiciary.
The money comes from the county's slice of the property tax bill, along with state and federal aid and fees. The county piece is one of the three parts of a bill, along with the municipal and school taxes, and the How to read a New Jersey property tax bill shows where each sits.
Boards and executives
County government comes in two broad shapes. In 16 of the 21 counties, the board of commissioners is the center of power: it sets policy and hires an administrator or manager to run the day-to-day work. In five counties, Atlantic, Bergen, Essex, Hudson and Mercer, voters elect a county executive directly, and the executive is the chief of the administration while the board acts as the legislature. The county executive or commissioner board and how five counties differ from sixteen compares the two models in detail.
Where there is no executive, the board picks its own leaders. Each January, boards hold an annual reorganization meeting, choosing a director (or chair) and a deputy director for the year, and setting the meeting schedule. A reader who sees a "Director of the Board of County Commissioners" is looking at the board's presiding officer, not the head of the administration.
Other county officials who are elected separately
The commissioners are only part of the county's elected officials. Voters in each county also elect a sheriff, a county clerk and a surrogate, and in the five counties with executives, the executive as well. Those offices are separate from the board and have their own jobs: the sheriff provides courthouse security and serves legal papers, the clerk records documents and runs elections paperwork, and the surrogate handles wills and estates. The Sheriffs in New Jersey, what a county clerk does and what a county surrogate does cover them. The county prosecutor is not elected; the governor appoints the prosecutor with the Senate's consent.
A timeline of the title
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| Colonial era | County boards of "chosen freeholders" take shape, made up of landowners chosen by the townships |
| 1947 | The current state constitution takes effect, and county government continues |
| 1960s | "One person, one vote" rulings push county boards toward equal representation |
| August 21, 2020 | The governor signs S855, replacing "chosen freeholder" with "county commissioner" |
| January 1, 2021 | The new titles take effect |
| 2021 | Counties finish updating letterhead, websites and signs within the year the law allowed |
The timeline is short because the change was short. What took centuries was getting to the point where it seemed worth making.
A worked example: the county's slice of a bill
Because the commissioners set the county levy, their budget vote shows up in every property tax bill in the county. A hypothetical example makes it concrete. Say a home in a New Jersey county is assessed at $400,000, and the county's tax rate is $0.30 per $100 of assessed value. The county portion of that homeowner's bill would be 400,000 divided by 100, or 4,000, times $0.30, which is $1,200 a year. If the board of commissioners were to raise the rate by a penny, to $0.31, the county portion would rise by $40, to $1,240. The municipal and school portions are set by other bodies and would not change.
The example is invented, and real rates vary by county, but it shows why county budgets matter even though they rarely make headlines. A small change in the rate, applied across every taxable property in the county, is a large sum of money, and it pays for the roads, parks, jail, college and health services that a county supplies. The county's budget is adopted in public, usually in the spring, and county residents can attend the hearing and comment.
How a board is elected
Voters pick commissioners in a few different ways. In some counties all commissioners are elected at large, so every voter in the county votes for every seat that is up. In others, some seats are filled by district and some at large. Terms are three years and staggered, so that only some seats come up in a given year. Primaries are held in June and the general election in November, and candidates run for specific seats.
Because the commissioners' terms are staggered, a county board changes gradually. A single election seldom changes its whole membership. For voters, the result is that a county commissioner race is often on the ballot in a year without a governor's race, and many voters skip it. The county clerk, who prints the ballots, can tell you which seats are up in a given year, and the Division of Elections in the Department of State publishes the calendar.
Reading the county's website
If you want to see the new title in action, open your county's website. You will find a page for the board of commissioners, with the members, the director and deputy director, the meeting schedule and the agendas and minutes. County meetings, like municipal ones, are subject to the Open Public Meetings Act, and the minutes are public records. The budget page usually lists the adopted budget and the tax rate.
What changed in 2021, and what did not
The 2021 law was narrow. It changed titles in the statutes and required counties to update their materials. A statute that once spoke of "chosen freeholders" now speaks of county commissioners, and the law defines references to freeholders elsewhere in the statutes to mean county commissioners. The law did not change the powers of the boards, the number of members or how they are elected.
A few results of the change are still visible. Older documents, historic buildings and long-standing local names use "freeholder," and a reader may see the old title on a plaque or in a news archive. County websites, once updated, now use the new title, and people running for the board now run for "county commissioner."
One confusion worth clearing up: a county commissioner in New Jersey is not the same as a commissioner in a municipality that uses the Walsh Act commission form. Those commissioners run municipal departments. A county commissioner sits on the county's board. Both are called commissioners, but they work for different governments.
Why it matters
County government is the least familiar layer in the state's three-part local structure, of municipalities, counties and school districts. Most people can name their mayor and cannot name their county commissioners. A name change is a small thing, but it gives a reason to look at who serves and what they do. For New Jersey's 21 counties, the commissioners are the people who decide the county's budget, run its roads and parks and oversee the services that residents use without thinking about who is responsible.
To find out who sits on your county's board, start with your county's website and the county clerk, who administers the elections that choose them. The Why New Jersey has 564 municipalities shows how the municipal layer below the counties was built, and the state's overview of county government is the next step for anyone who wants the full map.