Blog
County executive or commissioner board and how five counties differ from sixteen
Atlantic, Bergen, Essex, Hudson and Mercer elect a county executive, while sixteen counties run through a board of commissioners. A side-by-side look.
New Jersey's 21 counties look the same on a map and a little different on a payroll. In 16 of them, a board of county commissioners sets policy and hires an administrator to run things. In five, voters elect a county executive, a single person who runs the county the way a mayor runs a city or a governor runs a state, while the commissioners serve as the legislature.
Those five, Atlantic, Bergen, Essex, Hudson and Mercer, are not a random group. They include the most populous county in the state, the home of its largest city and the home of its capital. Together they held about a third of the people in New Jersey on the 2020 Census. This is a comparison of the two models: what each does, where each lives and what the difference means for the people who use county services.
The five counties with an executive
Here are the five, with their county seats and their 2020 Census populations.
| County | County seat | 2020 population |
|---|---|---|
| Atlantic | Mays Landing | 274,534 |
| Bergen | Hackensack | 955,732 |
| Essex | Newark | 863,728 |
| Hudson | Jersey City | 724,854 |
| Mercer | Trenton | 387,340 |
Add the population column and the five counties held 3,206,188 residents, about 34.5 percent of the state's 9,288,994. Three of the five, Bergen, Essex and Hudson, are among the four most populous counties in the state, and Atlantic includes Atlantic City and the casino district. Three of the counties have a big city at their center: Newark in Essex, Jersey City in Hudson and Trenton, the state capital, in Mercer. Bergen's seat of Hackensack is a smaller city in the middle of the state's most populous county.
The sixteen with a board
The other 16 counties, among them Burlington, Camden, Cape May, Cumberland, Gloucester, Hunterdon, Middlesex, Monmouth, Morris, Ocean, Passaic, Salem, Somerset, Sussex, Union and Warren, run through the board of county commissioners, which hires an administrator or, in a few places, a manager. Together they held about 6,082,806 residents in 2020, roughly 65.5 percent of the state, and they range from Salem County, with 64,837 people, to Middlesex, with 863,162, and Monmouth, with 643,615.
The range matters. The commissioner-board model is used by the smallest counties and by large ones, which suggests that size does not by itself decide which form a county uses. The choice is historical and political as much as practical.
How the executive model works
Counties adopt an executive form through a referendum under a state law, the Optional County Charter Law of 1972, which lets a county choose among an elected executive, an appointed manager or an elected supervisor. The five counties that chose the elected executive made a particular bet: that a county of their size needed a single leader answerable to the voters.
Under the executive model:
- The county executive is elected countywide and is the chief executive of the county. The executive prepares and proposes the budget, appoints department heads, signs or vetoes legislation passed by the board and represents the county in public.
- The board of commissioners acts as the legislature. It reviews and adopts the budget, passes ordinances and resolutions, confirms certain appointments and oversees the executive. The board can override a veto under the rules in the county's charter.
The result is a separation of powers on a county scale: an executive and a legislature, each elected separately, each with its own base. When the same party controls both, the arrangement is smooth. When it does not, it can mean friction over the budget and appointments.
How the board model works
In the other 16, the board does both jobs. The commissioners set the budget and policy and appoint an administrator or manager, a professional who runs the county's departments and answers to the board. The board chooses a director and deputy director at its January reorganization meeting, and the director presides over meetings.
This model puts the power in a group of elected commissioners and in the appointed administrator they hire. It has the virtue of professional management: the administrator is hired for competence, and the board can replace the administrator if the work falls short. Its drawback, critics say, is that voters have no single person to hold accountable for how the county is run, since the board is a group and the administrator is not elected.
Supporters of the executive model say it supplies that single person. Supporters of the board model say that a board shares responsibility and that professional administrators bring steadiness. Both arguments are made in the counties that have debated switching, and in practice the form that a county has often reflects its history. The from freeholders to commissioners tells how the boards got their current name.
What both models have in common
Whatever the form, every county in New Jersey does the same set of jobs and elects the same set of independent officials. The county builds and maintains county roads and bridges, runs parks and open-space programs, supports a county college and vocational schools, operates the jail, provides public health and human services and funds much of the prosecutor's office and the courthouse. Voters in each county also elect a sheriff, a county clerk and a surrogate, who are separate from the board and the executive.
Funding comes in much the same way as well: the county's piece of the property tax bill, state and federal aid and fees. The county levy appears as one line on every homeowner's bill, along with the municipal and school taxes, and the commissioners (and, where there is one, the executive) set it.
Reading the difference in practice
A resident of an executive county will find a county executive's office on the county website, with the executive's name, press releases and a cabinet of department heads. The board of commissioners has its own page with the members and the meeting calendar. In a board-model county, the website lists the commissioners, with the director and deputy director identified, and an administrator or manager's office.
For a resident with a problem, the practical difference is who to call. In an executive county, a question about a county service usually goes to the department, and the executive's office takes escalations. In a board county, it goes to the department, and the administrator's office takes escalations, with a commissioner available as an elected voice. In both models, the commissioner who represents you can help find the right office.
Meetings work the same in both. Boards meet in public under the Open Public Meetings Act, with agendas and minutes posted, and a resident can comment on agenda items. The county budget hearing is the most important meeting of the year, since it is the moment when the county's tax levy is adopted.
Big counties, small counties: an averages check
The executive form is a big-county habit, though not a rule. The state's 21 counties averaged about 442,000 residents in 2020 (9,288,994 divided by 21 is 442,333). The five executive counties averaged about 641,000 each (3,206,188 divided by 5), while the 16 board counties averaged about 380,000 (6,082,806 divided by 16). The gap is real, and it is partly an accident of which counties include which cities. It does not mean a board county is small: Middlesex, with 863,162 residents, is among the biggest counties in the state and runs on a board.
Who proposes the county budget
The best single test of the difference is the budget. In an executive county, the executive prepares the county budget and sends it to the board of commissioners, which can amend and must adopt it. The executive can then use the veto on parts of the legislation the board passes, and the board can override within the limits set by the county's charter. The back-and-forth is visible and public: the executive's proposal, the board's changes and the final vote.
In a board county, the administrator or manager prepares the budget under the board's direction, and the board introduces and adopts it. The board is both the author and the approver, so the public sees the commissioners' fingerprints on every line. A commissioner who wants a change can propose it directly.
In both models the state steps in at one point: the Division of Local Government Services in the Department of Community Affairs supervises county budgets and requires that they meet statutory standards, such as limits on how fast the levy can grow. The state review does not choose what the county funds, but it makes sure the budget is legally adopted and balanced.
What to ask on election day
For voters, the two models raise slightly different questions.
- In an executive county, there are two races to watch: the county executive, elected countywide, and the commissioners who serve as the legislature. Voters can ask whether they want the same party in both offices or a check between them.
- In a board county, there is one body to watch. Voters can look at the full slate of commissioners, who are accountable as a group, and ask who is hiring the administrator and how the county's budget is run.
In either case, county races often appear on the ballot in years without a governor's race, and turnout is lower. The seats that are up in a given year are listed by the county clerk, who prints the ballots and who is the office to ask if you are not sure what is on yours.
A few comparisons worth knowing
Some contrasts show how different the counties are, even inside the same model.
- Bergen vs. Salem. Bergen has an executive and 955,732 people, while Salem has a board and 64,837, a ratio of nearly 15 to 1 (955,732 divided by 64,837 is 14.7). The two counties do the same jobs at very different scales.
- Hudson vs. Middlesex. Hudson, an executive county, had 724,854 residents on a small piece of land along the Hudson River. Middlesex, a board county, had 863,162 and covers a much wider area of central New Jersey.
- Mercer vs. Camden. Mercer, with the capital at Trenton, has an executive. Camden County, across the Delaware from Philadelphia, has a board and about 523,485 residents.
The Bergen County profile covers the largest county, and cities such as Newark, Jersey City, Trenton and Atlantic City show what the county seats and big cities look like on the ground.
Can a county change?
Yes, but it is a deliberate process. A county can form a charter study commission, hold hearings and put a question on the ballot. If voters approve, the county adopts the new form and holds an election for the new offices. The change does not happen often. Most counties have kept their form for decades, and the 16-to-5 split has been stable.
If you want to know how your county works, the county clerk's office and the county website are the best starting points, and the state's Division of Local Government Services in the Department of Community Affairs supervises county budgets. When the county's executive or commissioners are on the ballot, the Division of Elections lists the dates, and your county clerk prints the ballots.