Blog

What a county surrogate does

Every New Jersey county elects a surrogate, the judge and clerk of its probate court. A look at what the office handles, from wills to guardianships.

Most people never think about the surrogate's office until a relative dies. Then, within a week or two, they are standing at a counter in the county courthouse with a death certificate and a folder of papers, asking where to begin. The person behind that counter works for one of the oddest, oldest offices in New Jersey government: the county surrogate, an elected official who is both a judge and a clerk, and whose job is to handle the legal business of the dead and, in some cases, of the young and the incapacitated.

Every one of the state's 21 counties has a surrogate. The office is separate from the county commissioners and the county executive, separate from the sheriff and the county clerk and part of the court system in a way that few other county elected offices are. This is a question-and-answer look at what the office does and why it exists.

What is a surrogate?

A surrogate is the elected head of a county's Surrogate's Court, the probate court of the county. State law says the surrogate is elected in each county for a five-year term, and the term begins on January 1 after the election. The state judiciary describes the office as serving as judge of the court for uncontested probate and estate matters. The surrogate is "both the judge and clerk" of the Surrogate's Court, which means the same person who runs the office's administration also decides routine matters that come before it.

The word itself comes from the colonial period, when the governor of the province held the power over wills and estates and appointed deputies, or surrogates, to act in his place. The 1844 state constitution made the office elective, and it has been elected by county voters ever since. New Jersey's other probate-related institution, the old Prerogative Court, was merged into the Superior Court's Chancery Division in the mid-20th century. The surrogate's office is what remains of the local part of that system.

What does the surrogate handle?

The core business is probate, the legal process of proving a will and putting an estate in order. County offices across the state list the same main items:

  • Probating wills. When someone dies with a will, the person named as executor brings it to the surrogate, who admits it to probate and issues the papers that give the executor authority to act.
  • Appointing administrators. When someone dies without a will, state law decides who inherits, and the surrogate appoints an administrator to manage the estate.
  • Appointing guardians for minors. The surrogate handles the appointment of guardians for children whose parents have died, for the purpose of managing the child's property.
  • Incapacitated persons and conservatorships. Applications to appoint a guardian for an adult who cannot manage their own affairs go through the surrogate's office.
  • Adoptions. Counties process adoption matters through the surrogate.
  • Accountings and trusts. The surrogate reviews accountings that executors and trustees file and handles other matters involving estates and trusts.

If a dispute arises over a will, for example a challenge to its validity, the matter goes to the Superior Court, Chancery Division, Probate Part. The surrogate handles the uncontested work and the contested cases move up.

Why is it elected?

Because that is how New Jersey has done it since 1844. The state's constitution lists the surrogate among the county offices voters choose, along with the sheriff and the county clerk. The reasoning is the same as for other county offices: the office handles matters that are close to residents, and voters can hold the officeholder accountable.

Critics sometimes ask whether a judicial function should be elective, and defenders answer that the surrogate's work is mostly administrative and that the office has long been a point of local contact. Whatever the merits, the arrangement is stable. Candidates run in the June primary and the November general election, and the five-year term is among the longest of any county elected office.

Where do you find the office?

Each surrogate's office is in the county courthouse or a county building at the county seat. The 21 county seats are:

County Seat
Atlantic Mays Landing
Bergen Hackensack
Burlington Mount Holly
Camden Camden
Cape May Cape May Court House
Cumberland Bridgeton
Essex Newark
Gloucester Woodbury
Hudson Jersey City
Hunterdon Flemington
Mercer Trenton
Middlesex New Brunswick
Monmouth Freehold
Morris Morristown
Ocean Toms River
Passaic Paterson
Salem Salem
Somerset Somerville
Sussex Newton
Union Elizabeth
Warren Belvidere

The county's own website has the address, hours and forms. Many offices post checklists for common matters, such as probating a will or applying to be an administrator, and some accept forms by mail or online. The office's staff can explain what is needed for a filing, though they cannot give legal advice.

How does probate work, in outline?

The basic steps are the same in most cases, and the surrogate's office is the place where they begin.

  1. The death. The family obtains certified copies of the death certificate, which the office will require.
  2. The will. If there is a will, the executor files the original with the surrogate and asks that it be admitted to probate. If there is no will, the person who is entitled to serve under state law applies to be administrator.
  3. The appointment. The surrogate reviews the filing and, if it is in order, issues the document that gives the executor or administrator legal authority over the estate.
  4. The work of the estate. The executor or administrator collects assets, pays debts and taxes and distributes what is left according to the will or the state's rules.
  5. The accounting. In some cases the fiduciary files an accounting with the surrogate.

Taxes are a separate track. New Jersey has an inheritance tax, and the Division of Taxation in the Department of the Treasury administers it; the surrogate's office does not collect it, though the office's forms and the state's pages explain how the two fit together. The answers to individual questions depend on the estate, and a lawyer is the right person to ask about a particular situation.

A walk through a hypothetical case

A made-up example shows how the pieces fit. Say a retired teacher living in Ocean County dies, leaving a will that names her son as executor. A week later, the son goes to the surrogate's office in Toms River, the county seat, with the original will and several certified copies of the death certificate. The staff check that the will is in the form the law requires and that the paperwork names the right people. If everything is in order, the surrogate admits the will to probate and the son takes an oath as executor. He receives the document that proves his authority, and he can then show a bank or a motor vehicle office that he is allowed to act for the estate.

Now change one fact: she left no will. The state's intestacy statute sets out who inherits and in what order, starting with a surviving spouse or civil union partner and descendants and then moving outward to other relatives. Someone with a right to serve applies to be administrator, and the surrogate appoints that person. The administrator's job is the same as the executor's, but the rules for who may serve and who inherits come from the statute, not the will. In either case, the office handles the opening steps and the rest of the work happens outside it, at banks, with the Division of Taxation and with the family.

Common misunderstandings

Because the office deals with a subject people prefer not to think about, a few ideas circulate that are not quite right.

  • "Probate takes years." The timing depends on the estate. Opening an estate at the surrogate's office is the first step, and the rest depends on the assets, the debts, any taxes and whether anyone contests the will.
  • "The surrogate decides who gets what." In an uncontested case, the will or the statute decides who inherits. The surrogate admits the will and appoints the fiduciary; it does not rewrite the plan.
  • "You need the surrogate for everything." Some assets pass outside probate, such as property with a named beneficiary or jointly owned accounts, and an attorney can explain which are which.
  • "The staff can advise me." The office's staff are experienced in the forms and the filing rules, but they cannot give legal advice about an individual situation.

Why the office matters beyond probate

The surrogate's office touches people at moments of change, a death, a child who needs a guardian, a parent who cannot manage on their own or a family finalizing an adoption. In each case, the office stands between private grief or joy and a legal record that the rest of the world will rely on. A bank, a title company or a school will ask for the paper the surrogate issues, and the office is the source.

That is a reason the work is done carefully and a reason the office is public. Records in the surrogate's court are generally available to the public, and the county's page describes how to ask for them. Anyone who wants to find out how the office works in their own county can start with the county's website or call the office directly.

What happens when the surrogate has a conflict?

The law has a safeguard. Neither the surrogate nor any employee of the office may act in a matter in which the surrogate is a fiduciary or has an interest. When that happens, the matter is referred to the county's Assignment Judge, the senior Superior Court judge in the county. The rule is intended to keep the office from judging its own affairs.

How does the surrogate relate to the rest of the courts?

The surrogate's office is the local, administrative end of the probate system. Above it are the state's Superior Court judges, who hear contested matters, and above them the Appellate Division and the Supreme Court. The surrogate does not preside over trials; the Superior Court's Chancery Division does. The surrogate is an elected county official who works inside the judicial system, which is part of why the office is hard to classify.

The state's courts are covered in From municipal court to the Supreme Court, and the Sheriffs in New Jersey and what a county clerk does cover the county's other two elected officials. For county government in general, the from freeholders to commissioners looks at the commissioners.

Practical advice for a first visit

Anyone going to a surrogate's office for the first time can save time by doing a few things.

  • Call or check the website first. Each office posts what it needs, and requirements can differ slightly from one county to the next.
  • Bring the originals. The original will and certified death certificates are the key documents.
  • Know which county. Probate is generally handled in the county where the person lived at death.
  • Expect to need more than one visit. Many matters take several steps, and the office can explain the sequence.

Beyond that, the surrogate's office is one of the places in county government where the work is personal. People come in during hard weeks, and the staff handle some of the most sensitive paperwork in the courthouse. It is not a glamorous office, and it is rarely in the news. It is, though, one that nearly every family meets sooner or later.

Related state government

Related guides

Latest on this topic