Blog

Protecting the Pinelands

How a 1978 federal law, a governor's 1979 order and the Pinelands Commission in New Lisbon turned 1.1 million acres of pines into a regulated landscape.

In 1979, builders in southern New Jersey had a problem, and it was not the sand. They had plans and options on land for houses on a stretch of pine forest that had seemed too poor to farm and too remote to matter. Then the governor signed an executive order declaring a development moratorium across the Pinelands, and an entire region froze. Builders sued. The law was, to put it mildly, contested. What emerged from that fight, over the next two years, is one of the most ambitious land-use experiments in American history: a regional plan imposed on 1.1 million acres, administered by a single commission, spread across seven counties and dozens of municipalities, and still in force more than four decades later. It is worth understanding how it works, because it is the reason the forest still exists.

The two laws

The story has a federal part and a state part, and they were written together.

The federal law. On November 19, 1978, Congress passed the National Parks and Recreation Act, which included a section creating the Pinelands National Reserve. The Pinelands provision was a compromise bill introduced by Republican Senator Clifford P. Case and Democratic Senator Harrison A. Williams Jr. of New Jersey. It was the first National Reserve in the country, a designation that is different from a national park. A reserve is not federal land that the government owns and runs. It is a region the federal government has recognized as nationally significant, to be protected through a plan carried out by state and local governments, with federal approval. Other members of the state's congressional delegation had backed different ideas, including a federal wildlife refuge, but the reserve approach won out.

The state law. Governor Brendan T. Byrne established a Pinelands planning commission by executive order on February 8, 1979, and imposed a moratorium on development while a plan was drawn up. Builders challenged the order in court. In June 1979 the Legislature passed the Pinelands Protection Act at the governor's request, which confirmed the commission, gave it a legal footing and required county and municipal master plans and land use ordinances to conform to the plan the commission would adopt.

The commission

The Pinelands Commission has 15 members. Seven are appointed by the governor, seven are county appointees, one from each of the seven Pinelands counties, and one is appointed by the U.S. Secretary of the Interior. That mix was deliberate. The state and the counties have the power to approve or reject; the federal member is a reminder that the reserve is a federal designation, too. The commission's office is in New Lisbon, in Burlington County, at 15 Springfield Road, and it is open to the public on weekdays. It has a professional staff of planners and scientists.

The seven counties are Atlantic, Burlington, Camden, Cape May, Cumberland, Gloucester and Ocean. The Pinelands cover all or parts of dozens of municipalities in those counties. The commission's authority is unusual. It reviews certain development applications itself, certifies local ordinances as consistent with the plan and can disapprove them if they are not. Seven counties and 53 municipalities in the Pinelands Area have completed the conformance process, meaning their local plans and rules have been certified as consistent with the regional plan.

The Comprehensive Management Plan

The plan the commission was required to write is called the Comprehensive Management Plan, or CMP. The commission approved the Preservation Area Plan on August 8, 1980, and the Protection Area Plan on November 21, 1980, and the plan took effect under state law on January 14, 1981. The Secretary of the Interior approved it two days later, on January 16, 1981. The CMP has been amended many times since, but its structure has held.

The key idea is zoning at regional scale. The plan sets up nine land use management areas, each with its own goals and rules, and the boundaries are drawn on the Pinelands Land Capability Map. Among them:

  • The Preservation Area District covers about 39 percent of the Pinelands Area and holds the largest unbroken tracts of forest. Development is tightly restricted, new mining is prohibited and buildings generally must be set back 200 feet from major public roads.
  • The Forest Area is subject to the same road setback and mining ban, and development credits are not allocated from it.
  • Agricultural Production Areas and Special Agricultural Production Areas protect farmland, notably the cranberry and blueberry farms. Farming is generally exempt from commission review, and landowners can receive development credits.
  • The Rural Development Area allows lower-density growth with screening requirements for sites that store more than ten vehicles.
  • The Regional Growth Area is where development is meant to go. It is the primary destination for development credits, and it can take housing at up to eight units an acre when credits are used.
  • Pinelands Towns are existing centers where growth is allowed under local zoning and the plan's standards.

In other words, the plan does not freeze the Pinelands. It sorts it. Some land is to be left alone, some used for farming and some intended for houses, shops and roads, and the rules are different in each.

The development credit: a market for not building

The most inventive part of the plan is the Pinelands Development Credit, known as a PDC. It answers the question that haunts every land-protection law: if you tell a landowner they cannot build, who pays? The Pinelands approach is to give the landowner a credit and let the market do the rest.

In the Preservation Area District, and in the agricultural areas, landowners are allocated PDCs based on the size and character of their land. A landowner can sell those credits to a developer who wants to build in a Regional Growth Area. Each credit entitles the holder to four additional housing units on the receiving site, which allows density above what local zoning would otherwise permit. The seller keeps title to the land and may continue any non-residential use the plan allows, such as farming or forestry, under a deed restriction that binds all future owners and bars the development rights from being used.

A hypothetical shows how it works. Say a farm in an Agricultural Production Area has been allocated five credits. The farmer sells them to a builder with a site in a Regional Growth Area. The builder can then construct 20 additional housing units there, four for each credit, beyond the base density. The farmer is paid, the farm stays a farm forever and the houses go where the plan wants them. The numbers in this example are made up, but the mechanism is the plan's own.

A state Pinelands Development Credit Bank was created in 1985 to buy and sell credits and to give the market a floor. The Pinelands Commission took over administration of the bank in 2011, although the bank board remains a separate entity. As of June 2021, 55,951 acres had been permanently preserved through the PDC program.

What the plan has meant

Judged by its main purpose, the plan has worked: the Pinelands are still there. The forest and its aquifer, the Kirkwood-Cohansey, which holds an estimated 17 trillion gallons, have been shielded from the kind of sprawl that covered much of the rest of the state. The region has been recognized internationally as a biosphere reserve. Its farms, including the cranberry and blueberry operations, have been able to stay in business, and the forest's fire ecology (see The Pine Barrens: ecology and fire) has been preserved along with its plants and animals.

The plan has also drawn criticism, and the criticism is the other side of the same coin. Landowners in the Preservation Area, who once could have sold land for houses, have been told to use it as forest or farm, and some have argued that a development credit is worth less than a building lot. Municipalities have complained that the rules limit growth and the tax base that comes with it. Builders and some local officials argue that the regional commission overrides local control. Defenders reply that the plan came about because local control had left the forest to be nibbled away, one subdivision at a time. Both claims are true to some degree, and the debate has returned in different forms whenever a new project, whether a housing development, a utility line or a solar farm, tests the boundaries of the rules.

How a resident or visitor meets it

Most people meet the Pinelands as a place to go. State forests, rivers and trails are open to the public, with the state park system managing them; see New Jersey State Parks, Forests and Historic Sites and Visiting the Pine Barrens. Property owners meet it as a set of rules: a house in the Pinelands Area may need local permits and, in some cases, commission review. The commission's website carries the plan, a map of management areas and the contact information for staff, and the commission can be reached at its New Lisbon office, (609) 894-7300, from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. on weekdays. The Pinelands Commission and Highlands Council page links to both the commission and its northern counterpart, the Highlands Council, whose own law came in 2004; see The Highlands Act and the water supply.

The place itself is described in The Pine Barrens. It is a rare thing: a landscape that is protected not by owning it, but by agreeing, county by county and town by town, what may be done there.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic