Blog
Seton Hall basketball at the Prudential Center
A winter with the Pirates: the 1989 run to the title game, Big East history, the 2024 NIT title and what a game night at the Prudential Center is like.
The basketball season at Seton Hall begins when the weather turns, runs through the coldest months and, if it goes well, ends at Madison Square Garden. The Pirates, the men's team of the Catholic university in South Orange, play their home games a few miles east of campus, in the arena in downtown Newark, and have done so since 2007. The arena is two blocks from Newark Penn Station.
This piece follows a Seton Hall season, November to March, and uses the calendar to explain what the program is: a Big East charter member with one national championship game in its past, a pair of conference titles in the last decade and a loyal fan base that fills a hockey arena on winter nights.
The program
Seton Hall's first basketball season was 1903-04, though the school did not field a team again until 1908-09. The program has been a fixture of the Big East since the conference began in 1979. It has won Big East tournament titles in 1991, 1993 and 2016 and regular-season titles in 1992, 1993 and 2020.
Three coaches define the modern era. P.J. Carlesimo coached the Pirates from 1982 to 1994 and took them to the heights described below. Kevin Willard coached from 2010 to 2022. Shaheen Holloway has run the program since 2022. Along the way the team won the NIT in 1953 and again in 2024, with a championship that sits oddly alongside the larger accomplishments of the 1980s.
The alumni list is a mix of old and new. The Naismith Hall of Fame includes the Seton Hall coach John "Honey" Russell and the players Bob Davies and Bobby Wanzer, and the FIBA Hall of Fame includes Nikos Galis and Andrew Gaze. NBA alumni include Walter Dukes, Richie Regan, Frank Saul, Terry Dehere, Angel Delgado and Sandro Mamukelashvili.
The season at a glance
| Stretch | What happens | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Early to mid-November | Season opener and nonconference games | Prudential Center, Newark |
| December | Nonconference games, then the start of league play | Prudential Center and on the road |
| January to early March | Big East regular season | Home and away in the league |
| Early March | Big East tournament | Madison Square Garden |
| Mid-March onward | NCAA Tournament or NIT, if selected | Neutral sites |
The exact dates change every year, and the athletic department publishes them. What does not change is the order.
November and December: the nonconference stretch
A season begins in early November, and the first game is often at home. The Pirates play at the Prudential Center in Newark, which has been their home since the arena opened. The first collegiate game in the building was on November 11, 2007, when Seton Hall beat Monmouth 89-81 in overtime, an apt debut for an arena that has since hosted a lot of close finishes. Before that the program played at what was then the Meadowlands Arena from 1985 to 2007, and before that on campus at Walsh Gymnasium in South Orange.
The Prudential Center's basketball capacity is 18,711, which is far larger than a typical college gym, and the program's fans come from across northern New Jersey. For the arena's story, see Prudential Center in Newark. The building is two blocks from Newark Penn Station, which is the reason many fans arrive by train rather than car. Newark covers the city, and the Riding NJ Transit: trains, buses and light rail guide covers the trains.
The nonconference schedule gives a team a chance to work out its rotation before the league starts. It also tests the fan base. Many Pirates fans only start paying attention when the Big East begins.
January and February: the Big East
Conference play runs from the new year to early March, and it is a demanding league. The Big East is made up largely of private, urban and Catholic schools, and Seton Hall has been in it since the start.
The best proof is the program's record in the conference. In 2020 the Pirates won the Big East regular-season title, one of three regular-season championships in program history, along with 1992 and 1993. A team that wins the regular season in that league has earned something.
The Saturday game at the Prudential Center is the fixture that most fans know. The building does not feel like a college gym, and that is both a drawback and an asset: the sightlines are those of an NBA arena, and the crowd comes in from the train station two blocks away.
March: the Garden and the tournament
The Big East tournament has been held at Madison Square Garden since the 1980s, and for Seton Hall it is a destination. The Pirates won the tournament in 1991, in 1993 and in 2016, each time at the Garden. A good run there is the usual road to the NCAA Tournament, and the Pirates have gone from the Garden to the Big Dance in some of the program's best years.
The program's other tournament, the NIT, has been kinder to it than the larger one. Seton Hall won its first NIT title in 1953, and its second came in 2024. On April 4, 2024, at Hinkle Fieldhouse in Indianapolis, the Pirates beat Indiana State 79-77 in the title game after erasing a seven-point deficit in the final three minutes; Dre Davis scored the go-ahead layup with 16 seconds left, and Indiana State's Ryan Conwell missed a three-pointer at the buzzer. Al-Amir Dawes scored 24 points and Kadar Richmond added 21. It was Seton Hall's first NIT title since 1953, and Holloway's team had beaten Georgia and Indiana State in Indianapolis to claim it.
The 1989 run
Every Seton Hall fan of a certain age will tell you about 1989. The team was a No. 3 seed in the West Region, coached by Carlesimo, and it beat Southwest Missouri State 60-51 and Evansville 87-73 in Tucson, then Indiana 78-65 and UNLV 84-61 in Denver. In the Final Four in Seattle it beat Duke 95-78 and reached the championship game for the first time in program history.
The title game was on April 3, 1989, against Michigan. It was tied 71-71 at the end of regulation and went to overtime, where Seton Hall lost 80-79. John Morton scored 35 points, Gerald Greene had five assists and D. Walker had 11 rebounds. It was the program's first Final Four, and it remains its only one. The Pirates have been trying to recapture the feeling ever since, and the team's identity as a New Jersey Catholic school that nearly won it all is part of why the program matters to the state.
Put the six tournament games side by side and the team's strength is visible. Seton Hall beat Southwest Missouri State by 9, Evansville by 14, Indiana by 13, UNLV by 23 and Duke by 17, then lost to Michigan by one in overtime. Across the six games the Pirates scored 483 points and allowed 408, a margin of 75 points, or 12.5 per game. Morton led the scoring early, with 26 against Southwest Missouri State and 17 each against Evansville and Indiana. Andrew Gaze, the Australian star who later entered the FIBA Hall of Fame, scored 19 against UNLV and 20 against Duke, and Ramon Ramos had 12 rebounds in the Duke game. The team lost the title game by the narrowest margin there is, and it did so after regulation ended 71-71.
The 1989 run is a useful measure of what a good year looks like for Seton Hall. A No. 3 seed that wins four games on the way to the national championship game is not the usual outcome for a program of its size, and it explains the permanent mixture of pride and regret in the fan base.
What the Pirates are in the state's life
A program like Seton Hall plays a larger role in New Jersey than its record suggests. It is the state's major-conference basketball team in a private university with a long local history, its home arena is in the state's largest city and its alumni include players who went on to the NBA and to international fame. Nikos Galis, the Greek star, is in the FIBA Hall of Fame, and Angel Delgado and Sandro Mamukelashvili are among the Pirates who have reached the NBA.
The 2024 NIT title also showed what the program can do when it has a good team and a good coach, and that a late rally in a title game can turn a season. Seton Hall's place in a big metropolitan area, with the New York market on one side and a rail network that delivers fans to the arena door, is the structural advantage that its fans point to.
A night at the arena
If you are going to a game, the logistics are simple. The Prudential Center is at 25 Lafayette Street in Newark, two blocks from Newark Penn Station. From the station, walk toward the arena, and expect a crowd that includes students, alumni and local fans. Seton Hall's athletics site publishes the schedule, and the Big East games are generally scheduled with television in mind, so tip times change.
For the arts and the rest of downtown, see NJPAC and Newark's arts district. If you want to see the campus, South Orange is on NJ Transit's Morristown Line, and the university's page lists its programs and events. For the private colleges of the state, Seton Hall, Monmouth and the private colleges of New Jersey has the longer view.
The state's basketball map
Seton Hall's place in New Jersey basketball is clearest on the map. Rutgers plays in the Big Ten, Princeton in the Ivy League and Seton Hall in the Big East. The three are a few exits apart along the Turnpike and the Northeast Corridor. For the other two, see Princeton Tigers and the Ivy League and Rutgers football in the Big Ten, and for the pro game that used to share the arena, see The Nets' New Jersey years, 1977 to 2012.