Blog
Rutgers football in the Big Ten
A season at SHI Stadium in Piscataway: the 1869 first game, the 2014 move to the Big Ten, the 2006 Louisville night and a Saturday with the Scarlet Knights.
College football season in New Jersey has a calendar of its own, and it starts in late summer in a bowl beside the Raritan River. The Rutgers Scarlet Knights are the state's major-conference football team, the descendants of the first American college team to play a game, and since 2014 they have been a member of the Big Ten, a conference that now reaches from the Atlantic to the Pacific. For a program that spent decades as a modest competitor, that is quite a place to end up.
This piece follows one Rutgers football season, September to December, and stops along the way for the history that explains the stadium, the rivals and the habits of the fans.
The first game, and the claim
Rutgers football begins in New Brunswick on November 6, 1869, when Rutgers beat Princeton 6-4 on the Rutgers campus in what folklore, and a good many record books, count as the first intercollegiate football game. It was nothing like the game played in Piscataway today. Neither team could run with the ball, each side fielded 25 players, and the ball was round, so the contest looked far more like soccer than anything on a modern Saturday.
A week later, on November 13, the teams met again at Princeton under Princeton's rules, in which a player who caught the ball on the fly earned a free kick, a rule that blunted Rutgers' speed advantage. Princeton won 8-0. A third game was planned and never played; one account says officials worried that the games were getting more attention than academics, and others say the schools disagreed about the rules. The result was a 1-1 season for each school, and each later received a share of a retroactively awarded national championship. Rutgers has long claimed the 1869 title on that basis. Princeton, a short ride down the Northeast Corridor, was the original rival, and the football series lasted until 1980. For the Princeton side of the story, see Princeton Tigers and the Ivy League.
The rest of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries were a long, uneven climb. Rutgers won Middle Atlantic Conference University Division titles in 1958, 1960 and 1961, and the 1961 team went 9-0, the school's first undefeated season. The 1976 team went 11-0 and finished No. 17 in the final Associated Press poll. In 1991 the program joined the Big East, where it spent two decades as a modest competitor and shared the conference title in 2012. After a single season in the American Athletic Conference in 2013, it joined the Big Ten.
The stadium
SHI Stadium sits on the Busch Campus in Piscataway, overlooking the Raritan River to the south. It opened on September 3, 1994, as Rutgers Stadium, with a game against Kent State, on the site of the original Rutgers Stadium of 1938. The team had played at Neilson Field on the College Avenue Campus from 1891 to 1938.
A $102 million expansion in 2008 and 2009 raised the capacity from 41,500 to 52,454, and that is the number on the program today. The stadium has been renamed along with its sponsors: High Point Solutions bought the naming rights in June 2011, the building became HighPoint.com Stadium after the company rebranded in 2018, and on July 19, 2019, it became SHI Stadium under a deal with SHI International. The playing surface was natural grass from 1994 to 2003 and FieldTurf from 2004.
The record crowd came recently. On September 19, 2025, a sellout of 55,942 saw Iowa beat Rutgers 38-28. The number is a useful measure of how far the program has come, in a stadium that held fewer than 42,000 for its first fifteen years.
September: non-conference and nerves
A Rutgers season opens in the first days of September with a nonconference schedule, and the games that matter most to the fan base tend to be the ones against teams that Rutgers should beat. In the Big East years, the early season was the time when fans started to think about a bowl. In the Big Ten it is the time when they start to count the games they might win against the league's heavyweights.
The September ritual is the same one that every American college town has: tailgates in the lots around the stadium, the marching band's pregame, the long walk to the entrances. Piscataway is in Middlesex County, and the stadium is reachable by road and by campus bus from the university's other campuses. The Riding NJ Transit: trains, buses and light rail guide covers the trains into New Brunswick, and New Brunswick covers the host city. The New Brunswick on foot: the Hub City, Rutgers and the river piece explains why the city and the university grew up together.
October and November: the Big Ten gauntlet
The Big Ten schedule starts in the fall and runs through November, and for Rutgers it is the toughest in its history. The Scarlet Knights face Penn State, Michigan, Ohio State and a long list of programs with deeper pockets and larger stadiums. The first Big Ten win came over Michigan in 2014, a landmark that the fan base still remembers.
The rivalry that matters in the conference is Maryland, a team that joined the Big Ten the same year Rutgers did. Maryland leads the series 12-9 through 2025. Temple is the old Big East-era regional rival, and Princeton is the historical one, though the football series ended in 1980.
The year's key date, for many Rutgers fans, is not even a Big Ten game. It is the anniversary of November 9, 2006, when Rutgers beat Louisville 28-25 in front of 44,111 at what was then Rutgers Stadium. The Scarlet Knights rallied from 18 points down and won on a field goal by Jeremy Ito. The game is known as Pandemonium in Piscataway, and the stadium's history calls it the most important game in Rutgers history. It was the high point of the Schiano era, and it helped lead to the program's first bowl win, in the 2006 Texas Bowl.
December: bowls, and the people
A bowl invitation in December is the goal. Rutgers has played in 13 bowl games with a 7-6 record. The 2023 team won seven games and beat Miami in the Pinstripe Bowl, and the 2024 team finished 7-6 and lost the Rate Bowl to Kansas State, 44-41. The Pinstripe Bowl is played at Yankee Stadium in the Bronx, an easy trip for the Rutgers fan base.
The people matter to the story. Greg Schiano coached the program from 2001 to 2011, left for the NFL and returned in 2020 on an eight-year contract. Other notable coaches include John Bateman, Frank Burns, Kyle Flood and Chris Ash. The program has retired No. 52 for Eric LeGrand, the defensive tackle who was paralyzed during a game against Army at the Meadowlands in October 2010. The MetLife Stadium: two teams, one field piece notes that the Army game was the first college game in that stadium. Three Rutgers players have been first-round NFL draft picks.
The program in numbers
The history above compresses into a short table of figures, each of them tied to a date in the record.
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| First game | November 6, 1869, Rutgers 6, Princeton 4 |
| First undefeated season | 1961, 9-0 |
| Big East football membership | from 1991; shared 2012 title |
| Big Ten football membership | from July 1, 2014 |
| Stadium capacity | 52,454 after the 2008-09 expansion |
| Record crowd | 55,942, September 19, 2025 |
| Bowl record | 13 games, 7-6 |
| Retired number | No. 52, Eric LeGrand |
The table shows a program with an unusual shape: the oldest history in the sport, a long stretch of middling years and a recent upswing in attendance. The record crowd came in a game the Scarlet Knights lost, which tells you something about what the stadium has become. People now come for the occasion as well as the result.
Planning a Saturday
A game day at SHI Stadium is a car-and-campus event more than a train-and-walk one, because the stadium sits on the Busch Campus in Piscataway, a few miles from the New Brunswick station, and parking lots surround it. Rutgers Athletics sells tickets and publishes the parking and bus information for each game; the schedule, the kickoff times and the gate rules are set by the athletic department, and the television partners often decide the kickoff time late in the week, so check before you travel. If you are coming by train, New Brunswick is on the Northeast Corridor, and the university's campus buses connect its campuses; check the athletic department's page for the game-day service. The Riding NJ Transit: trains, buses and light rail guide has the network.
Fans who want the college-town side of a game weekend usually spend part of it in New Brunswick itself, which sits on the north bank of the Raritan with the older campuses around it. That is the university's original home, and the football team's too: Neilson Field on the College Avenue Campus was where Rutgers played until 1938.
Why it matters beyond Saturday
The Big Ten move was widely tied to money and media as much as football, and to the conference's interest in the New York market. It also tied the university's fortunes to a very different level of expectations: a 7-6 season in 2024 meant a bowl game, but in a league of this size it is a middle-of-the-pack year.
The university has also been through some hard moments, and the football story is not the whole of it. For the university's other campuses and its role in the state, see rutgers: three campuses, one university and the public-institution profile in Rutgers and public higher education.
But the Saturday is the point. On a fall afternoon in Piscataway, a state of nine and a half million people with no NFL team of its own, in the sense that its two teams carry New York's name, has one team that carries its own. It plays in a stadium by a river, it wears scarlet and it has been doing it since 1869.