Blog
Seton Hall, Monmouth and the private colleges of New Jersey
From South Orange and West Long Branch to Rutherford and Jersey City, the private schools of the state, their histories and their basketball identities.
On a winter night in Newark, the crowd streaming from the Prudential Center in blue and white after a Seton Hall game is, in its own way, a map of the private colleges of New Jersey. Some of them are alumni from South Orange, where the campus sits on a hill with a chapel built in the 1860s. Some are law students from the school's tower on Newark Center. Some are people who have never set foot on the campus and simply adopted the team. New Jersey's private colleges are not a single sector so much as a collection of institutions with different religious roots, different founders and a shared habit of defining themselves through a single sport.
Seton Hall: the oldest diocesan university
Seton Hall University was founded on September 1, 1856, by Bishop James Roosevelt Bayley, the first bishop of Newark, and named for his aunt, Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton. It is described as the oldest diocesan university in the United States. It began in Madison, New Jersey, as Seton Hall College and moved to its present site in South Orange in 1860, where it has been ever since. Its preparatory and college divisions were separated in 1897, and it was organized as a university in 1950.
The campus in South Orange covers about 58 acres, and its Immaculate Conception Chapel was built in 1863 and dedicated in 1870. The university's School of Law is in a 22-story building at One Newark Center, a few blocks from Newark Penn Station, and its Interprofessional Health Sciences campus is in Nutley. Its enrollment was 9,529 in fall 2023, with 6,109 undergraduates and 3,420 graduate students, spread across nine schools and colleges, including the Immaculate Conception Seminary School of Theology.
Seton Hall has an unusual history in medicine. A College of Medicine and Dentistry opened in 1954 in Jersey City and was sold to the state in 1965, where it became part of the system that eventually folded into Rutgers (see rutgers: three campuses, one university). A later medical school partnership produced the Hackensack Meridian School of Medicine, which became independent in 2020. The university has also had its tragedies. On January 19, 2000, an arson fire in Boland Hall killed three students and injured 54, an event that led to stricter fire-safety rules for college dormitories across the state.
The Pirates and the Prudential Center
For most of the public, Seton Hall means basketball. The Pirates play in the Big East Conference, and the men's team plays its home games at the Prudential Center in Newark, the arena that is also home to the Devils. The smaller Walsh Gymnasium, which opened in 1939 and seats about 2,600, hosts women's basketball and volleyball. The high point of the program is the 1989 season, when the Pirates reached the NCAA championship game and lost to Michigan, 80 to 79, in overtime. Fans of a certain age can recite the details of that night, and the program has lived in its shadow ever since. See Seton Hall basketball at the Prudential Center and Prudential Center in Newark for how the arena and the team fit into Newark's downtown.
Monmouth: a junior college that grew up
Monmouth University in West Long Branch is the shore's university, and its history is a good example of how New Jersey's colleges grew from local needs. It opened on November 21, 1933, as Monmouth Junior College, meeting in the evenings at Long Branch High School, with 325 students and 12 instructors. It was a two-year school for Monmouth County high school graduates who could not afford to go away to college during the Depression.
In 1947 the state approved it to grant associate degrees. In 1955 and 1956 it moved to the Shadow Lawn estate in West Long Branch, and the following year, as Monmouth College, it gained approval to offer four-year degrees, awarding its first bachelor's degrees in 1958. The Guggenheim family's old house became the library, and the mansion, where Woodrow Wilson stayed during his 1916 campaign, was named Woodrow Wilson Hall and renamed the Great Hall in 2020. Graduate programs began in 1967, athletics moved up to NCAA Division I in 1983, and in 1995 the state granted university status, with Rebecca Stafford, the school's first woman president, leading the effort.
The university has about 6,000 students today, close to the shore and a short drive from Asbury Park and Long Branch. Its athletics reflect the same expansion. The Hawks moved from the Northeast Conference to the MAAC in 2013 and to the Coastal Athletic Association in 2022, and they play at the OceanFirst Bank Center, which opened in 2009 as the Multipurpose Activity Center and took its present name in 2016. For the surrounding towns, see Freehold, Monmouth Park and the long history of Monmouth County and Long Branch and its oceanfront: from the presidents' summer capital to Sandy.
The other private schools
New Jersey's private nonprofit sector is larger than people tend to assume, and it grew in fall 2025. The state's preliminary report found that enrollment at private nonprofit colleges rose 3.2 percent, the second-largest rise of any sector. A few more names are worth knowing.
- Fairleigh Dickinson University was founded in 1942 in Rutherford as a two-year college by Peter Sammartino and his wife, Sylvia, and became a university in 1956. It has campuses in Teaneck and Madison and is among the largest private universities in the state.
- Saint Peter's University in Jersey City is a Jesuit institution chartered in 1872 as Saint Peter's College, which became a university in 2012. Its men's basketball team became the talk of the country in March 2022, when the Peacocks, a fifteenth seed, reached the Elite Eight of the NCAA tournament.
- Rider University in Lawrenceville, in Mercer County, dates to 1865.
- Princeton University, of course, is a private institution too, and in a class by itself; see Princeton University and the town it made. Stevens Institute of Technology in Hoboken is private as well; see NJIT, Stevens and Rowan: the technology schools and the state's other universities.
Most of these schools are small by the standards of the public sector. They compete on size of classes, location and a sense of community, and some have faced financial pressure in recent years, which is why the enrollment numbers in each annual report are closely watched.
The part of the sector most people never see
The state's report on fall 2025 enrollment has a line that surprises people who think of private higher education as a few familiar campuses. Enrollment in the religious sector, which consists of seminaries and yeshivas, rose 6.2 percent in a single year, and over the five years from fall 2020 to fall 2025 it grew 41.1 percent. The report notes that about four or five new yeshivas gained state licensure to operate as degree-granting institutions in the past five years. In the same five years, independent public-mission colleges, the traditional private nonprofits, grew 3.6 percent, while for-profit degree-granting institutions shrank 6.9 percent, and in the most recent year fell about 20.6 percent. The shape of private higher education in New Jersey is shifting, and the biggest movement is not on the campuses that fill the sports pages.
What a campus feels like
The three best-known private campuses could not be more different. South Orange is a village on the Morris and Essex rail lines, with the university's green hill a few minutes' walk from the station, which makes it one of the most transit-friendly campuses in the state. West Long Branch is a shore community, with a campus built around a mansion and a wide lawn, a short drive from the beaches of Monmouth County. Rutherford, where Fairleigh Dickinson began, is a Bergen County borough close to the Meadowlands. A student choosing among them is choosing among three of the state's regions as much as three schools.
Why a Newark address matters
Seton Hall's choice to keep its law school in Newark, and to put its basketball team in the Prudential Center, ties the university to the city in a way few suburban campuses manage. The law school's tower at One Newark Center sits a short walk from Newark Penn Station, which puts its students in the middle of the city's courts, law offices and transit, and its graduates practice across the state. The arena brings thousands of visitors downtown on game nights, which is part of how Newark's restaurants and hotels fill up in the winter. A university that began on a hill in Madison, grew in South Orange and then built an urban presence in the state's largest city is a good illustration of how New Jersey institutions spread out across the map. For the city, see Newark.
The basketball identity
It is no accident that so many of these schools are known through basketball. The sport is cheap to field, plays well on television and gives a small institution a way to be noticed. Seton Hall's relationship with Newark, Saint Peter's run in 2022 and Monmouth's years at the OceanFirst Bank Center are all versions of the same story. A New Jersey private college has a hard time competing with Rutgers on size or with Princeton on prestige. A hot basketball team is a way to compete on the same night.
What it costs
Private tuition is higher than the public price, sometimes much higher, but the net price is often far lower than the sticker because of institutional aid. New Jersey students at private colleges may be eligible for the state's Tuition Aid Grant, which covers part of tuition at eligible in-state colleges, and the Educational Opportunity Fund, which operates at both public and independent institutions. The rules, deadlines and income limits are explained in College costs, HESAA and the Office of Higher Education. For how the state oversees all of its colleges, public and private, see Rutgers and public higher education.