Blog
Lakewood, the fifth-largest municipality: growth, schools and housing
How a former winter resort became New Jersey's fifth-largest municipality, and the arguments over school funding, busing and housing that come with fast growth.
Lakewood is the quickest answer to the question of where New Jersey is growing. In the 2020 Census it counted 135,158 people, which made it the fifth-largest municipality in the state, behind Newark, Jersey City, Paterson and Elizabeth and ahead of Edison. In 2010 it had about 92,800. That is a jump of roughly 46 percent in ten years, in a state whose overall growth was in the low single digits. No other large New Jersey municipality came close.
The growth has produced a good deal of argument. Some of it is about schools and how New Jersey pays for them; some is about housing and land; some is about how a township government keeps up. It is also, because the growth comes largely from a particular religious community, a subject on which it is easy to say the wrong thing. This piece sticks to the public record: what the numbers are, how the rules work and what each side says.
From winter resort to Ocean County's biggest town
The township was incorporated by act of the Legislature on March 23, 1892, from part of Brick Township. In its first decades it was a resort, drawing wealthy New Yorkers and Philadelphians who wanted a mild winter among the pines and lakes. The most visible remnant of that era is the Georgian Court estate, built for the financier George Jay Gould and now the campus of Georgian Court University, a Catholic university founded by the Sisters of Mercy. The resort economy faded in the mid-twentieth century, and the town began to attract Jewish families, many of them from the New York area.
In 1943 a rabbi named Aharon Kotler founded Beth Medrash Govoha in the town, a rabbinical college that grew into one of the largest Talmudic academies in the world and is the anchor of the community. Over the following decades the town became a center of Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) life, and in recent decades its Orthodox Jewish and Latino populations have been a main source of the township's growth. Large families are the main reason: the community's birth rate is far higher than the state's average, and the township's young population, the number of children under 18, is large.
The schools: a public system and a private one
The most contested numbers in Lakewood are in the schools. New Jersey funds public schools through a formula based on each district's enrollment and its ability to raise money locally, and the state aid for a district goes to its public schools. In Lakewood, most children do not attend the public schools. Far more attend private religious schools, known as yeshivas and day schools, than attend the public district, and those schools are not funded by the state aid formula.
That is where a state law matters. New Jersey requires school districts to provide transportation to nonpublic school students who live within certain distances, up to 20 miles, on the same basis as public-school students, and to provide certain services, such as special education evaluations, for nonpublic students who need them. The district that owes this transportation is the public school district where the children live, so in Lakewood the public district bears the cost of busing a very large number of private-school children, and of special-education services for those who qualify. Say, to take an illustration, that a district with 6,000 public students owes busing to 30,000 nonpublic students. Even at a modest cost per rider, the cost of busing the private-school children would be several times what busing the public-school students costs. The state formula, critics say, does not account for this. Lakewood's public district serves only a minority of the township's school-age children. In 2014 the state appointed a fiscal monitor to oversee the district's finances, and in later years the district has had to turn to a state loan to balance its budget.
The two sides of the argument are familiar. District officials and many residents say that the funding formula counts only the public enrollment, so the district gets far less state aid than its actual obligations require, and that the legislature should recognize the cost of mandated transportation and special education. State officials and some taxpayers elsewhere ask why the cost of serving a mostly private system should be shifted to the state budget or to other districts, and some local residents point to questions about management and priorities. Members of the Orthodox community say that they pay property taxes and receive little in return from the public schools, and that mandated busing and services are a legal right. All of this plays out in the annual school budget and in the state aid debates; How school funding works in New Jersey explains the formula, and New Jersey Department of Education describes the department that administers it.
Housing, land and the pace of building
The second set of arguments is about land. A population that grows by 40,000 in ten years needs housing, and Lakewood has built apartments, townhouses and single-family homes at a pace that has sometimes outstripped its roads and services. The township sits on the edge of the Pine Barrens, and there is limited land to develop; some of what remains is protected, which pushes builders toward denser projects. Some longtime residents complain about traffic and the loss of woodland; many newer residents say they need homes for large families and have few other places in the state where they can find them.
New Jersey's affordable-housing system, which began with the Mount Laurel court decisions, makes every municipality plan for a share of lower-cost housing; how that works and why the state has argued over it for decades is in Affordable housing and the Mount Laurel system. Lakewood's situation shows the tension: a township with a very young population, a very high demand for housing and a small supply of land. The debates over zoning and over how much of the remaining woodland should be built on go to the township's planning and zoning boards and, when a developer or a neighbor disagrees, to court.
Government and services
Lakewood is governed by an elected township committee and a professional administration, and like every New Jersey municipality it is one of 564 with its own police, planning board and school district. The township's size makes it a different place than the small boroughs that make up much of the state's list. Why New Jersey has 564 municipalities explains why the state's local government is so fragmented, and why a place with 135,000 residents has the same basic structure as one with 1,500.
Lakewood's municipal budget and school budget each draw attention, and both draw on the property tax. Property tax bills are the main way the community's growth is felt, and How to read a New Jersey property tax bill explains how they are built.
Getting around a township with no train
Lakewood has no passenger rail station, and the township is built around the car and the bus. Route 9 and Route 70 are its main commercial roads, Route 88 and county roads carry traffic toward the shore, and the Garden State Parkway and Interstate 195 are a short drive away. Buses connect the township to New York and to the rest of Ocean County. Because so many households are large and so many trips are short, the township's streets fill with pedestrians and with buses that carry children to school, which is part of why the cost of mandated school transportation is such a large budget item. Live conditions are on 511nj.org, and the NJ Transit bus information is at njtransit.com.
How to follow the decisions
Most of the decisions described above are made in public meetings: the township committee, the planning and zoning boards and the board of education. The agendas, minutes and budgets are public records. New Jersey's Open Public Records Act gives residents the right to request them, and How to file an OPRA request explains the process. The state's rules for attending and speaking at a meeting are in how to attend and speak at a public meeting. For anyone trying to understand Lakewood rather than argue about it, those meetings and records are the best primary source.
Beyond the school and housing debates
It would be wrong to see Lakewood only as a battleground. The township has a lively commercial center along Route 9 and Madison Avenue, a minor-league ballpark that is home to the Jersey Shore BlueClaws, a growing Latino community with its own businesses and churches and a long Jewish history that predates the modern boom. It is also a township that people from all over the state and the country visit for religious study, family events and shopping.
Right next door, in Manchester Township and the borough of Lakehurst, is the Navy's old Lakehurst Naval Air Station, part of the combined Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst since 2009. On May 6, 1937 the airship Hindenburg burned there while landing, and 36 people died. The disaster is a famous chapter in aviation history, and the site is still a military base; the story is in The Hindenburg at Lakehurst, May 6, 1937.
Why it matters beyond Lakewood
Lakewood is a test of how New Jersey handles three things at once: rapid growth, private schooling funded in part by public rules, and the shortage of land. The answers it finds will shape the school-aid formula, the way mandated services are paid for and the way municipalities plan for growth. For the county's seat and the other large township nearby, see Toms River, the Ocean County seat, in questions and answers; for the township's own guide, Lakewood; and for the state's school-choice options, School choice and charter schools in New Jersey.