Blog
The Hindenburg at Lakehurst, May 6, 1937
The landing at Naval Air Station Lakehurst that ended in fire, the 36 people who died, how it was investigated, and what visitors can see there now.
The airship was late. It had left Frankfurt on the evening of May 3, 1937, on the first of ten scheduled round trips to North America that season, and strong headwinds over the Atlantic had slowed it. A line of thunderstorms over central New Jersey delayed the landing further, so the LZ 129 Hindenburg spent the afternoon of Thursday, May 6, cruising along the coast while the weather cleared. At about 7:25 p.m., it made its approach to the mooring mast at Naval Air Station Lakehurst, in Ocean County, a few hundred feet up, in what airship men called a flying moor.
Within about half a minute the stern was on fire. The flames ran forward through the hydrogen cells, the ship dropped tail-first, and the biggest aircraft ever built was a burning frame on the sand and scrub of the Pine Barrens. Thirty-six people died. The images and one radio report from that evening ended a form of travel, and they are still the best-known pictures in New Jersey history.
Why Lakehurst
Lakehurst is an odd place to be famous. The site began in 1916 as a test range for ammunition and was later an Army camp in World War I. The Navy bought it in 1921, named it Naval Air Station Lakehurst, and built what was then the largest enclosed space in the world: Hangar No. 1, a vast shed meant to house rigid airships. The base had a long run with the Navy's airships, including the Shenandoah, the Los Angeles and the Akron. Its flat sandy ground, in Manchester and Jackson townships about 25 miles east-southeast of Trenton, gave a big landing field in a part of the state that had few buildings in the way. The field sat inside the Pine Barrens, a region described in The Pine Barrens: ecology and fire.
In 1937 it was the American terminal for a German commercial service. The Hindenburg was in its second season of service, after a series of North Atlantic crossings in 1936. The trip was far faster than an ocean liner, and the passengers had cabins, a dining room, a lounge and a promenade with windows. The ship could carry 70 passengers, and on this trip it was at about half capacity: 36 passengers and 61 crew, which includes 21 trainees, for 97 people in all.
The ship and its gas
The Hindenburg was more than 800 feet long, longer than three football fields, and its framework of light metal girders held a series of huge gas cells. It was filled with hydrogen, which is lighter than helium and also flammable. German designers had planned for helium, which does not burn, but at the time the United States was the main source of the gas and restricted its export, so the ship flew on hydrogen. The Zeppelin company had a long record of safe passenger flights with the gas, and airship men had learned to keep ignition sources away from it. That record is part of the reason the fire at Lakehurst came as such a shock.
Landing was the most delicate part of any airship flight. A heavy ship had to be brought to a standstill over the field and held in place by ground crews, who grabbed ropes dropped from the bow and worked the ship down to the mast. At Lakehurst the crews were Navy men and civilian workers who had done the job for years with American airships. The landing in the afternoon thunderstorms of May 6, with the ship coming in late and a front of stormy weather behind it, was the kind of operation that left little margin. Eckener, who later chaired the German inquiry, noted that a second, smaller storm front following the first created conditions in which static sparks were possible, and that the officer who called the ship in for landing believed the weather had cleared.
The landing
The approach was delayed by the weather, and when the landing started, the ship had to make sharp maneuvers to get into position. Investigators later looked hard at those turns. The captain brought the ship in with the crew dropping landing lines, and the ground crew began to take hold of them. Spectators and newsreel camera crews were at the field, many of them standing near Hangar No. 1 and watching from the side and rear of the ship.
Then a fire appeared at the stern. Photographs and film show a flame at the tail, and then the fire running forward along the length of the ship. The hull collapsed from the rear, the nose pointed up, and the burning wreck settled onto the field. The whole sequence took well under a minute. Many on board, especially crew near the bow, survived by jumping from the windows as the ship came down.
Of the 97 aboard, 62 survived and 35 died: 13 passengers and 22 crew. A ground crewman, Allen Hagaman, a civilian linesman, also died, which brings the figure at the scene to 36. Several of the severely burned died in the hours or days afterward. Most of the dead had burns, and others were hurt in the fall.
The voice from the field
What made the disaster a national memory was radio. Herbert Morrison, a reporter for the Chicago station WLS, was at Lakehurst with an engineer to record the landing for a later broadcast, which was a new idea in 1937. When the fire started, his voice broke. His account, with its sobs and its repeated cry of horror, was broadcast the next day and is still one of the most famous recordings of the twentieth century.
There is a historian's footnote to the story. Parts of Morrison's recording were later added to newsreel footage, which led many viewers to believe the pictures and the sound were recorded together. They were not. The film came from cameras at the field; the audio came from a recording machine running on its own. The combined version became the standard way of presenting the disaster, and it has colored how most people think they remember it.
What caused it
Two official investigations looked at the cause. A U.S. Commerce Department inquiry, led by Colonel South Trimble Jr., sat at Lakehurst, and a German commission was led by Hugo Eckener, the head of the Zeppelin company and the most famous airship commander in the world. Both found that hydrogen leaking from the ship was set off by a static electric spark. The U.S. report published in August 1938 also considered a structural failure plausible.
Other theories have been argued ever since. Sabotage was suggested early on, notably by some of the crew and by the Navy commander at Lakehurst, but neither inquiry adopted it. Lightning was proposed, though no lightning was observed during the final approach. An engine backfire was suggested after a ground crewman reported sparks, which Eckener rejected. More recently, a researcher argued that the flammable coating on the fabric helped the fire spread; experiments have since cast doubt on the idea that the skin alone could have driven the fire. Eckener himself believed that a punctured gas cell, the result of a rushed landing with the ship badly out of trim in poor weather, set up the conditions for a static spark. The question is still debated, and the usual summary is that a hydrogen leak met an ignition source.
What nobody disputes is the effect. The disaster, the newsreels and Morrison's report destroyed public confidence in the passenger airship almost overnight. Heavier-than-air passenger aircraft, which were improving rapidly, were already competing for the same customers. The age of the great passenger zeppelin ended in New Jersey.
The days after
The survivors were taken to hospitals in the surrounding area, and the Navy and the Commerce Department began their inquiries at the base within days. Newspapers across the country ran the images, and the story of the disaster spread quickly through radio and newsreels, which together reached a much larger audience than the few hundred people at the field. The Zeppelin company's planned transatlantic service for the season ended with the first round trip, and the airship era, which had begun with such confidence in the 1920s, did not return in passenger service.
For Ocean County the event left a mark that is still visible. Lakehurst, a borough of a few square miles, is known around the world for less than a minute on a May evening, and the base that surrounds it has kept the history close. Books, documentaries and tours keep the date alive. The cause is still discussed in terms that would have been familiar to the inquiry boards of 1937, and the debate has never changed the central fact that 36 people died there.
Lakehurst now
The base is now part of Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst, formed in October 2009 when Lakehurst was consolidated with McGuire Air Force Base and Fort Dix. The disaster site is on the Lakehurst side. A black ground marker outlined with a yellow chain shows where the gondola came to rest, in the field behind the large hangars, and a bronze plaque was dedicated on May 6, 1987, the 50th anniversary. Hangar No. 1 still stands, and it was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1968. Because the site is on an active military installation, visits are arranged through the Navy Lakehurst Historical Society, which offers pre-registered tours. Check the society's site for current rules.
For visitors planning a trip, the area around Lakehurst is covered in Visiting the Pine Barrens, and the county seat of Ocean County, Toms River, is the nearest large town. The state's other great media event of the 1930s, and one that had its own New Jersey setting, is the subject of The 1938 "War of the Worlds" broadcast and New Jersey. For other places where New Jersey history meets aviation and the military, see The New Jersey National Guard.
The date
In 1937, the crash was a tragedy with 36 deaths, and the place where it happened is still a working base. If you stand at the marker, the pines are on all sides and the sky is large. The hangar behind is bigger than anything near it, which gives you some idea of the scale of the ship that was meant to fit inside.