Blog
The 1938 "War of the Worlds" broadcast and New Jersey
Orson Welles landed Martians at Grovers Mill on October 30, 1938; the panic the papers reported was far smaller than legend says.
On the night before Halloween in 1938, at 8 p.m. Eastern time, the Columbia Broadcasting System put on a radio play. It was a Sunday, the program was The Mercury Theatre on the Air, and the director and narrator was a 23-year-old named Orson Welles. The play was an adaptation of H. G. Wells's novel The War of the Worlds, and its authors had moved the story from England to the United States. The Martian cylinder came down in a farm field in Grovers Mill, an unincorporated village in West Windsor, New Jersey, a few miles from Princeton.
That is the whole connection, and it has been enough for New Jersey to claim the broadcast for eighty-eight years. Almost everything else that people believe about the night is wrong or exaggerated, which makes it a better story than the legend.
How the script was written
The adaptation was a rush job. The writer, Howard Koch, was assigned the script on October 24, a week before air, and he finished the first draft on October 26. He was credited as author, though Welles and others contributed, and Welles later disputed the credit. The time pressure shows in the way the play is built. It starts as an ordinary evening of dance music, interrupted by news bulletins that become more urgent, a form that radio listeners knew from real events.
The setting was an American one: a farm field in central New Jersey, and a scientist from Princeton. The astronomer in the script, Professor Richard Pierson, is based at "Princeton Observatory," a modified version of the real Princeton University Observatory. The fictional expert, a university astronomer called to a farm field to examine a crater, was a plausible figure, and a Princeton professor was the sort of authority that listeners trusted.
Grovers Mill
Grovers Mill is a crossroads, a mill pond and a few houses, in West Windsor Township in Mercer County. In the play a farmer describes a falling object, a crowd gathers, and the reporter on the scene, in a famous passage, describes something emerging from the cylinder. Because the village is real, it has been a place that listeners and later fans wanted to visit.
In 1988, for the 50th anniversary of the broadcast, West Windsor held four days of events, including a parade and film festivals, and dedicated a bronze monument to the fictional Martian landing. A plaque commemorating the broadcast is also in the township.
What happened that night
The legend says that millions of Americans heard the broadcast, believed that the Earth was being invaded and fled their homes. The record is more modest. Newspapers in the following days portrayed a nationwide panic. Within three weeks, they had published at least 12,500 articles about the program, most of them describing panic.
But the evidence for a mass panic is weak. A study directed by Hadley Cantril, a Princeton professor, published in 1940 as The Invasion from Mars, estimated that about 6 million people had listened to the broadcast, that 1.7 million had thought it was real news and that 1.2 million had been frightened or disturbed. These were estimates from surveys taken after the fact, and the numbers are contested. A contemporary survey of radio listening by the research firm C. E. Hooper found that only 2 percent of households had been tuned to the play that night, which suggests that the audience was smaller than the legend requires. Most of the radio audience was listening to something else.
Historians who have looked at the question have generally concluded that the panic was limited. W. Joseph Campbell, a media historian, wrote that it "did not occur on anything approaching a nationwide dimension." Two other scholars, Michael Socolow and Jefferson Pooley, called the panic "practically immeasurable" on the night. Later checks failed to confirm claims such as hospital admissions and a heart-attack death. Some police and emergency agencies in New Jersey did report calls that night in numbers above the normal, as much as 40 percent more in some cases. That suggests that a number of people were alarmed enough to ask for information, which is not the same as flight.
Why the papers made it a panic
If the panic was small, where did the idea come from? The newspapers had reasons. The Depression had cost them advertising revenue to radio, and a story about the danger of the new medium was a story that favored the old one. Editor & Publisher and others used the episode to argue that radio could not be trusted with news. The Hearst papers urged broadcasters to regulate themselves. The Chicago Tribune ridiculed listeners as mentally slow. The press had a financial interest in the idea that radio could mislead the public, and the nation's papers carried a story that fitted that interest.
There is a second reason, which is that the story was good. An audience that has just come through the crises of the 1930s, with Europe heading toward war and radio bulletins from abroad a regular part of the evening, was ready to believe that a radio news bulletin could be bad. The scare story and the real fear of world events fed each other.
Radio in 1938
The play worked because of what radio had become. A decade earlier, broadcasts were mostly music and speeches. By the autumn of 1938, radio was a source of news. The crisis over Czechoslovakia in September 1938, which ended in the Munich Agreement, had been followed by millions of Americans through live bulletins and commentary from European capitals, and the listening habits formed that month were fresh when the Martians arrived. The play used those conventions: a program interrupted for a special report, an announcer reading a bulletin, a reporter at the scene, an official speaking from Washington.
That is the craft in Welles's production. He did not need listeners to be fools. He needed them to know the form, and in 1938 they did. The sound effects, the pauses and the sense that the broadcast was happening in real time all belong to the grammar of radio news, and the production's skill in using them is the main reason it is still studied by people who work in media.
The cast of the Mercury Theatre was a company of stage and radio actors, and the show was one of a weekly series that ran on CBS without a sponsor. It was not a hit at the time. That fact helps explain why the audience estimate from the survey firm was so small, and why the week after the broadcast made the program a national story it had not been before. The publicity, more than the play itself, was what carried the story to people who had not heard it.
Reading the numbers again
It helps to set the figures side by side, because they do not agree, and the disagreement is the point:
- About 6 million listeners: the estimate in the 1940 study.
- 1.7 million who thought it was news and 1.2 million who were frightened or disturbed: the same study's estimates, from after-the-fact surveys.
- 2 percent of households listening: the figure from a rating survey taken at the time.
- 12,500 newspaper articles in three weeks: the coverage the papers gave the story.
- Up to 40 percent more calls than normal: reported by some New Jersey agencies that night.
A rating of 2 percent of households is a small audience, and a small audience cannot panic a nation. The 6 million listeners estimated by the study and the 2 percent rating are hard to reconcile. What can be said with confidence is that some people were alarmed, some called police and newspapers for information, and a much larger national story was built by the press afterward.
Princeton and the aftermath
The broadcast also changed the university in the story. The Princeton professor who directed the study, Hadley Cantril, turned the night into a research project, and the book is considered an early work in the study of mass media. The observatory was in the script because Princeton lent credibility. For the place itself, see Princeton, Princeton University and the town it made and A day in Trenton and Princeton, in the order Washington took them.
The broadcast also made Welles famous, and it is part of the background to his 1941 film Citizen Kane. But for New Jersey the effect was local and lasting. A small village that had been a place on the road became a name that people recognized around the world.
A state that gets landed on
New Jersey has been the setting for other events that made headlines in the 1930s. In 1937 an airship burned at Lakehurst, and that story is in The Hindenburg at Lakehurst, May 6, 1937. The Martian landing is a fiction, and it is the only thing in this list that did not happen. But it belongs with the other event of the decade because both were media events: they reached audiences far larger than the people at the scene, through radio, newspapers and film. In both cases the technology of the day carried the story farther than the facts.
For readers who like to follow stories from the screen to the map, the state's other screen history is in Films shot in New Jersey, and the film commission behind them. Anyone who wants to visit Grovers Mill can find the monument in West Windsor; it is a short drive from Princeton Junction and from the Northeast Corridor. Local calendars and the township's own site give details of anniversary events, and the state calendar in A month-by-month New Jersey calendar puts the late-October date in context.
The lesson, if there is one
It is easy to tell the story as a joke about gullible people. The better lesson is about how a story spreads. A radio play made one dramatic night. The newspapers turned it into a national event, and the version they gave the public lasted for generations. The real record, which includes survey data, ratings and the behavior of emergency agencies, is a more modest one, and in its way a more interesting one: a play so well made that some listeners were convinced, and a press that made the most of it.