Blog

The Tax Court and property tax appeals

How New Jersey property tax assessment appeals move from the county board of taxation to the Tax Court, with the April 1 deadline and a worked example.

Every New Jersey homeowner has opened a property tax bill and felt the same small jolt. The bill is large, it comes four times a year, and it seems to bear only a loose relationship to anything the homeowner can control. Most people grumble and pay. A smaller number look at the assessment, the dollar value the town has put on the property, and ask whether it is wrong. For them, the state has built a path with two main stops: the county board of taxation, and above it, the Tax Court of New Jersey.

The path is more accessible than many people assume, and it is narrower than many people hope. It can change what a property is assessed at, but it does not reduce the tax rate or settle whether a town spends too much. This is how the system works, with the deadlines and a worked example.

Assessment versus tax rate

The first thing to understand is what an appeal can challenge. A property tax bill is the product of two numbers: the assessed value of the property and the tax rate. The assessor, an official of the municipality, sets the assessed value. The rate comes from the budgets adopted by the municipality, the county and the school district, divided over the town's total assessed value.

An appeal challenges the assessed value. It asks whether the assessment is too high, or unfairly high compared with similar properties in the town. It does not challenge the tax rate, and it does not give a homeowner a way to contest how the town spends its money. The state's property tax appeal guidance addresses only assessments, and that is what the system is built to decide.

The distinction is important because it limits what an appeal can achieve. If the town's rate is high because of its budget, an appeal of one property's assessment will not change that. What it can do is make sure the property is carrying its fair share, and no more, of the rate that applies.

Step one: the county board of taxation

Every county has a board of taxation, and the board is where most assessment appeals begin. Any property owner can appeal to the county board, regardless of the assessment amount. The appeal is filed on a form from the county board, and the owner has to show that the assessed value is unreasonable by a market value standard.

The state describes two ways an assessment can fail. It can fail the true market value standard, meaning the assessed value exceeds what the property would sell for on the open market. Or it can fail the common level range standard, which compares the property's assessment to the town's average ratio of assessed value to market value. The common level range is plus or minus 15 percent of the district's average ratio. A property assessed well above that range, relative to its neighbors, can be a candidate for relief even if the assessment looks reasonable on its own.

Evidence matters. Owners who appeal usually submit comparable sales, meaning recent sale prices of similar properties nearby, and some hire an appraiser. The county board holds a hearing and issues a judgment. The judgment can leave the assessment alone, lower it or, in some cases, raise it.

The deadlines

The most important thing about the process is that the deadlines are firm. The state's guidance says petitions to a county board of taxation or to the Tax Court must be filed and received on or before April 1. Where a municipal revaluation or reassessment has been carried out, the deadline moves to May 1. Three counties, Burlington, Gloucester and Monmouth, use an alternative assessment calendar, with a deadline of January 15.

The statute also contains an alternative: the later of April 1 or 45 days after the bulk mailing of assessment notices. In practice, a property owner should check the county board's website for the date that applies to their town, because the dates differ with the calendar and with a revaluation.

A deadline missed is usually a deadline lost, and the appeal for that tax year is barred. The consequence is that the time to act on an assessment is in the first months of the year, after notices arrive and before the filing date.

Step two: the Tax Court

The Tax Court of New Jersey is a specialized court that hears property tax and state tax matters. It is part of the state judiciary and has 12 authorized judgeships, and its judges are chosen the same way as Superior Court judges, nominated by the governor and confirmed by the Senate. The Seven-year terms and age 70, how New Jersey judges are chosen describes that process.

An owner who is dissatisfied with the county board's judgment can appeal to the Tax Court. The deadline is 45 days from the date of the county board's judgment. The court's judges hear the evidence anew, with each side presenting its case, and issue a decision. In many appeals the parties settle before trial.

Owners of larger properties have a shortcut. Property assessed above $1,000,000 can be appealed directly to the Tax Court without going through the county board first, and for added or omitted assessments the threshold for a direct appeal is an aggregate assessed valuation over $750,000. Direct appeals are subject to the same April 1 deadline, or the equivalent date described above.

A worked example

A hypothetical, with the arithmetic shown, makes the stakes concrete. Say a homeowner's property is assessed at $450,000, and the town's combined tax rate is $2.00 per $100 of assessed value, which is a plausible number for illustration but not a real town's rate. The annual bill is:

450,000 divided by 100 is 4,500, multiplied by $2.00, which equals $9,000.

The homeowner looks at recent sales of similar houses on the same streets and concludes the house would sell for about $420,000. The assessment looks out of line with the market. The homeowner files a petition with the county board of taxation before the April 1 deadline and presents the comparable sales.

Suppose the board agrees and reduces the assessment to $420,000. The new bill, at the same rate, is:

420,000 divided by 100 is 4,200, multiplied by $2.00, which equals $8,400.

That is a saving of $600 a year (9,000 minus 8,400). The homeowner has to weigh that against the effort of the appeal and the risk that the board leaves the assessment unchanged, or in some cases raises it.

The numbers also show why a revaluation, in which a town re-appraises every property, can be a trigger for appeals. When assessed values are reset, some owners see large changes, and the deadline moves to May 1 for that year.

Appeals are not just for homeowners

Commercial and industrial property owners are the heaviest users of the Tax Court. A shopping center, an office building or a warehouse can carry an assessment of millions of dollars, and a small percentage reduction is worth a great deal. The court's docket reflects that, and the direct appeal route for properties assessed above $1,000,000 was designed with those cases in mind. Municipalities, in turn, have a stake in defending their assessments, because a successful appeal can mean refunds and a shift in the tax base. That is why towns often hire attorneys and appraisers to respond to large appeals.

Other tax disputes also reach the Tax Court. The court hears appeals from certain decisions of the state's Division of Taxation. That work is separate from the property tax docket, and it follows its own deadlines.

What an appeal costs

The state's guidance lists no filing fee on its property tax appeal page for the county board, and fees can differ by court and by the type of filing, so the county board and the Tax Court post current fee information. Beyond fees, the main costs are the owner's time and, if the owner chooses, the cost of an appraiser or an attorney. The county boards provide forms and explanations.

Where to start

A homeowner who thinks an assessment is too high can follow a short checklist.

  1. Look at the assessment notice and the tax bill. The How to read a New Jersey property tax bill shows where the assessed value appears.
  2. Gather comparables. Look for recent sales of similar properties nearby.
  3. Check the deadline. It is April 1 in most places, May 1 after a revaluation and January 15 in Burlington, Gloucester and Monmouth counties.
  4. File with the county board of taxation. The board's website has the forms.
  5. Know the next step. If the board's judgment is unsatisfactory, the Tax Court appeal is due within 45 days.

For how the pieces of a tax bill fit together and where the money goes, the the property tax bill and where the money goes is the next read. This is general information, not advice about a particular property; the Division of Taxation's property tax appeal page and the county board are where the official rules and forms live.

Related state government

Related guides

Latest on this topic