Blog

Seven-year terms and age 70, how New Jersey judges are chosen

New Jersey's judges are nominated by the governor, confirmed by the Senate, serve seven years and then earn tenure to age 70. Here is how the system works.

Voters in many states pick their judges at the ballot box. New Jersey's voters do not. In the Garden State, the people who sit on the state's courts get there through a process that involves exactly two elected officials: the governor, who nominates, and the Senate, which consents. After that, the judges are on their own, with no elections, no campaign fundraising and no reason to ask anyone for a vote.

The system has a distinctive rhythm that explains a good deal of what happens in Trenton: a first term of seven years, a second look from the governor and the Senate and then, if the judge is reappointed, tenure that lasts until a fixed birthday. Seventy, the constitution says, is when a judge must go. This is how it works and why it matters.

Who is covered

The rules apply to the judges of the state's main courts. The Supreme Court of New Jersey has a chief justice and six associate justices. The Superior Court, the state's trial court, includes the Law Division and the Chancery Division, and its Appellate Division is the intermediate appeals court. The Tax Court follows the same pattern, with judges serving on the same terms and conditions as judges of the Superior Court. The From municipal court to the Supreme Court lays out the courts and how they fit together.

Municipal court judges, who handle traffic and minor matters, are a separate group. They are appointed under a different system, typically by the municipality's governing body for set terms.

Step one: nomination

The governor nominates. The constitution does not require a screening panel or a list the governor must pick from. The nominee's name is sent to the Senate, which holds public notice before acting. The nomination is one of the most consequential decisions a governor makes, since judges serve long and outlast the governor who appointed them.

Because the governor can only serve two consecutive four-year terms, a judge appointed in a governor's final year may serve for decades after that governor leaves. That is the reason court nominations draw close attention from lawyers, advocacy groups and legislators.

The Senate must give its advice and consent. A nominee typically appears before the Senate Judiciary Committee at a public hearing, where senators can ask about the nominee's background and approach, and the committee votes before the full Senate does. The Senate's role is a real check: a nominee who lacks the votes will not be seated.

New Jersey has a long-standing custom known as senatorial courtesy, under which senators from a nominee's home county have had an informal say in whether the nomination moves forward. The custom is not written in the constitution, and its strength has varied over the years, but it has been part of the politics of judicial confirmation. A related tradition holds that the Supreme Court should be balanced between the two major parties, which has led to fights when a seat opened and the balance was at stake.

Because the Senate has 40 members who are elected on the "2-4-4" cycle, the makeup of the body that confirms judges can change with each election. The The 2-4-4 Senate cycle explains the schedule.

Step three: the seven-year term

A newly appointed judge does not receive a lifetime job. The constitution gives judges of the Supreme Court and the Superior Court an initial term of seven years. At the end of that term, the judge must be renominated by the governor and confirmed again by the Senate, or the judge's service ends.

The initial term serves as a probationary period. The governor and the Senate get to look at the judge's record, such as the pace of the docket, the quality of the opinions, the judge's conduct on the bench, before deciding on tenure. A judge who is not renominated, or whose renomination fails, leaves the bench at the end of the seven years.

Step four: tenure until 70

If the governor renominates and the Senate confirms, the judge receives tenure, which means the judge serves "during good behavior" until reaching the mandatory retirement age. The constitution says judges "shall be retired upon attaining the age of 70 years." There is no way to stay beyond that birthday, other than recall to serve temporarily in some circumstances, a practice that exists in the judiciary for retired judges.

The age is part of the constitution, not just a statute. The constitution can be amended if three-fifths of both houses approve a proposal, or if a majority of each house approves it in two successive years, and voters approve it at the next general election. Proposals to change the retirement age have been introduced in the Legislature over the years, and any change to the constitutional age would have to follow that route.

A worked example

A hypothetical shows how the numbers fit together. Say a lawyer is nominated and confirmed as a Superior Court judge at age 52. The judge serves a first term of seven years, until age 59. If the governor then renominates and the Senate confirms, the judge has tenure and can serve until age 70, which is another 11 years. In all, that is 18 years on the bench, from 52 to 70.

Now suppose the lawyer is appointed at 60. The first term runs to age 67, and if tenure follows, the judge has only three more years before reaching 70, so the total is ten years. The arithmetic of the age limit is one reason age matters when a governor picks a nominee.

Timeline of a judge's career

Laid out in order, the path looks like this.

  1. Nomination. The governor names a nominee and sends the name to the Senate.
  2. Hearing. The Senate Judiciary Committee holds a public hearing and votes.
  3. Confirmation. The full Senate votes on the nomination. If it consents, the judge takes the oath.
  4. Initial term. The judge serves seven years.
  5. Reappointment. Near the end of the term, the governor decides whether to renominate, and the Senate decides whether to confirm.
  6. Tenure. If reappointed, the judge serves until age 70.
  7. Retirement. At 70, the judge retires. Retired judges may be recalled to hear cases in some circumstances, subject to the court's rules.

At each step, the governor and the Senate are the only elected officials involved. The steps are also the points where the public can watch: nominations are announced, hearings are open and votes are recorded.

Why the second look matters

The reappointment decision is one of the least discussed and most important parts of the system. Most judges who are renominated are confirmed, and the process is usually quiet. But the possibility of a second review gives the governor and the Senate a chance to look at a judge's record on the bench before giving tenure. It also means that a judge's first seven years are spent knowing that a future governor and Senate will evaluate the work. Supporters say that is a sensible compromise between independence and accountability. Critics worry about any process that links a judge's future to politicians.

Because the governor who reappoints may be a different person, from a different party, than the one who made the first appointment, tenure decisions can become part of the larger partisan landscape. That has happened in New Jersey, most visibly around Supreme Court seats, where a governor's decision whether to renominate a justice has sometimes drawn national attention.

What this means for people in court

For a litigant, a lawyer or a juror, the selection system might seem remote. It is not. The judge in the courtroom got there through this process, and the judge's term and tenure shape how the court operates. A judge in the first seven years is likely to be newer to the bench, and many assignment judges and presiding judges have long experience. Rotations, retirements and new appointments are constant: with hundreds of judges across the state, vacancies arise regularly, and the Senate's calendar includes judicial confirmations throughout the year.

The system also explains why court vacancies attract so much coverage. When a seat on the Supreme Court opens, whether through retirement at 70 or for another reason, the governor's choice shapes the court for years, and the Senate's response sets the political tone.

The chief justice

The chief justice is appointed as chief justice, a distinct nomination from the one that places a person on the court, and the chief justice has an administrative role that goes beyond the bench. As the head of the state's judicial branch, the chief justice oversees court operations across the state and works with the court to set the rules of practice. The chief justice also performs ceremonial duties, such as administering oaths: on November 9, 2026, the chief justice swore in the state's new lieutenant governor.

The associate justices vote with the chief justice on cases. A decision of the Supreme Court is the final word on state law, which is why the makeup of the seven seats attracts so much attention.

What the system aims to do

Supporters of the New Jersey model say it balances accountability and independence. The governor and the Senate, both elected, choose the judges, so the courts are tied to democratic institutions, but the judges do not run for election and cannot be removed by voters, so they can decide cases without worrying about the next campaign. Tenure to age 70, they argue, protects the courts from political pressure and gives judges time to build expertise.

Critics raise a few concerns. Some argue that a system without elections gives voters no direct say, and that nomination fights reflect politics more than merit. Others have said that a mandatory retirement age forces out experienced judges at a point when many are at their best, a view that has fed periodic calls to raise the age. Defenders of the age limit respond that it creates predictable turnover and a regular flow of new judges.

Both sets of arguments are about trade-offs, and neither is settled by the constitution alone. They are part of the continuing discussion about how the third branch of government should be built.

Other officials in the system

Several other offices in the justice system are filled through the same governor-and-Senate route. County prosecutors, who bring criminal cases in each county, are appointed by the governor with the Senate's consent, and the Attorney General, the state's chief law enforcement officer, is appointed the same way. The Attorney General, Jennifer Davenport as of 2026, was confirmed by the Senate on February 24, 2026. The Office of the Attorney General page describes the office.

Voters do elect some officials who work in the justice system, including county sheriffs, county clerks and surrogates. Judges, though, are not among them.

How to follow it

Nominations to the courts are announced by the governor's office and reviewed by the Senate Judiciary Committee, whose hearings are public and are listed on the Legislature's website at njleg.state.nj.us. The judiciary's site, njcourts.gov, lists the judges of each court. For residents who want to know how the courts affect them, from jury service to a property tax appeal, the Jury duty in New Jersey is a good first stop.

Related state government

Related guides

Latest on this topic