Blog

Standard Oil of New Jersey and the 1911 breakup

Why the biggest oil company in the world was chartered in New Jersey, what the Supreme Court ordered on May 15, 1911, and what the state kept.

The most powerful corporation of its day had its legal home in a state it hardly needed. Standard Oil's offices were at 26 Broadway in lower Manhattan, its refineries stood on the Hudson and the Arthur Kill, and its founder lived in New York. But its corporate shell was a New Jersey company, and when the United States Supreme Court ruled against it on May 15, 1911, the case was called Standard Oil Co. of New Jersey v. United States. That caption is part of the state's history: for about two decades New Jersey was the place where American business came to be incorporated, and the biggest case of the age bore its name.

The trust, and the laws that suited it

Standard Oil began as an Ohio business, and in 1882 its owners put their holdings together under the Standard Oil Trust Agreement, which pooled the securities of dozens of companies under a group of trustees. A trust was a device for running many companies as one without merging them, and it drew attacks from the start. On March 21, 1892, the Ohio Supreme Court ordered the trust dissolved. Its holdings were reorganized into a group of companies that kept working together informally.

New Jersey became the answer. In 1885 the trustees of Standard Oil of Ohio chartered Standard Oil Company of New Jersey, and the state's laws of 1888 and 1889 allowed one company to own the stock of another. Most states did not. That feature made New Jersey the preferred place to incorporate a trust, and it became known as the home of big corporations. In 1899, Standard Oil of New Jersey bought the shares of the other companies in the group and became the holding company for the whole business. A trust that had been illegal in Ohio had found a legal form in Trenton's statute book.

Refineries on the New Jersey shore

The company's connection to the state was not only a charter. Standard Oil bought 176 acres at Constable Hook in Bayonne in 1872, and the site became a major base for marine transfer and refining in the Port of New York and New Jersey. By 1885 a pipeline connected the site to an oil field in Texas, and in 1906 the company expanded Constable Hook to more than 300 acres. On July 4, 1900, lightning struck large oil tanks at the refinery, and the fire burned for three days, injured nine people and caused about $2.5 million in damage, a large figure at the time.

In 1907 the company bought several hundred acres in Linden and Elizabeth, along with land on the harbor, and built a large crude-processing facility there that became known as Bayway. It was a research center as well as a refinery and was described as the northernmost oil refinery on the East Coast. The two sites tie the story to places that are covered on this site: Bayonne, Bayonne and the Bayonne Bridge and Elizabeth. They also explain why the New Jersey waterfront, from Bayonne to Linden, became a landscape of tanks, pipes and flares. The container port that grew up alongside in the 1950s, in Inside Port Newark and the Elizabeth Marine Terminal, did not replace that industry so much as join it.

The lawsuit

The federal government filed its antitrust suit in November 1906 under the Expediting Act, which let the Justice Department ask for fast-tracked appeals in major cases. The trial took about 15 months, and in November 1909 the federal circuit court issued a decree dissolving the combination. The company appealed to the Supreme Court, which heard arguments on March 14 to 16, 1910, and then ordered the case reargued, which took place on January 12 to 17, 1911.

The ruling came on May 15, 1911. Chief Justice Edward D. White wrote the opinion for the court, joined by seven other justices. The court held that Standard Oil had conspired to restrain trade and to monopolize the petroleum business, in violation of the Sherman Act, and affirmed that the company should be broken up. John D. Rockefeller and other individuals were fined.

The rule of reason

The part of the opinion that lawyers still teach is the "rule of reason." The Sherman Act, passed in 1890, said that "every contract, combination ... or conspiracy, in restraint of trade" was illegal. Read literally, that would ban nearly every business agreement. The Court said that the act bans only unreasonable restraints on trade, and it adopted the formulation that William Howard Taft, then a federal judge, had used in an 1899 decision about pipe manufacturers. The Court identified three consequences of monopoly that made a restraint unreasonable: higher prices, reduced output and reduced quality.

Justice John Marshall Harlan agreed with the result but dissented from the rule of reason. He argued that the act had long been read to ban any contract that restrained trade directly, and that the Court was changing the law by adding a test. That disagreement has run through American antitrust law ever since.

A timeline

Date Event
January 2, 1882 Standard Oil Trust Agreement signed
1885 Trustees charter Standard Oil Company of New Jersey
1888-1889 New Jersey laws let one company own another's stock
March 21, 1892 Ohio Supreme Court orders the trust dissolved
1899 Standard Oil of New Jersey becomes the holding company for the group
November 1906 Federal antitrust suit filed
November 1909 Circuit court decree dissolving the combination
March 14-16, 1910 Supreme Court arguments
January 12-17, 1911 Reargument
May 15, 1911 Decision and order of dissolution

Read down the table and you can see that the case was a contest between two kinds of law: a state that was happy to let companies grow by owning each other, and a federal government that had decided, with the Sherman Act, that some kinds of ownership were illegal. The state lost.

Why a state would want to be the home of trusts

It is fair to ask why New Jersey wrote laws that favored corporate combinations. The answer is revenue and competition among states. A corporation can choose where to incorporate, and the state it picks collects fees and franchise taxes. A state with permissive laws attracts companies and income, and New Jersey gained income from the businesses that chose its charter. Other states, unwilling to lose the business, loosened their own laws. Delaware later became the leading home of large corporations, and the pattern of states competing to be the preferred home has never gone away.

For New Jersey the bargain had a cost. The companies chartered in Trenton were run from offices elsewhere, and the connection between the state and the corporation was a filing, not a workforce. That was not true of Standard Oil, whose refineries were in Bayonne and Linden, but it was true of many others. When reformers looked for a symbol of corporate power with a legal home, they found one in New Jersey, and the state's reputation suffered. The Wilson years were partly an effort to turn the page, and the later story of the state's economy, built on pharmaceuticals, finance and the port rather than on charter fees, is in The largest employers: Amazon, RWJBarnabas and Wakefern.

The breakup, and what it made

The decree split the company into a group of independent firms. Counts differ, from the 30s to the 40s depending on whether subsidiaries are counted. The firms that mattered became household names. Standard Oil of New Jersey was renamed Exxon in 1973 and ExxonMobil in 1999, and it uses the Esso name overseas and in Canada. Standard Oil of New York became part of the Mobil line, which merged with Exxon. Standard Oil of California became Chevron. The company that held Standard Oil of Ohio's interests eventually became part of BP, along with Amoco, the old Standard Oil of Indiana.

The immediate effect on Rockefeller was the opposite of what the government hoped. The sum of the parts was worth more than the whole had been, and he became still richer. The breakup did not end the American oil business; it divided it into regional firms that competed with each other in some markets and not in others.

Woodrow Wilson and the New Jersey reputation

New Jersey politics were involved in the case in an unexpected way. In November 1910, between the first argument and the second, New Jersey voters elected Woodrow Wilson governor. Wilson, who had been president of Princeton University, ran on a program of reform, and he took office in January 1911, four months before the decision. The state that had made itself the legal home of the trusts now had a governor who was a critic of them. In 1912 he was elected president.

For New Jersey the result was a change of reputation. The state had been described as the place where corporations came to escape regulation, and critics had a name for it. After the Standard Oil decision and the reform years that followed, the state stopped competing for that title, and other states took it up. It is a reminder that a legislature can make a choice that looks like a smart bid for revenue and later turns out to have shaped the state's image for a generation.

What remains in New Jersey

Little of the old Standard Oil is left under that name, but the geography is the same. The oil industry's installations in Bayonne, Linden and Elizabeth remain part of the state's industrial landscape, and the broader story of manufacturing and employment in New Jersey, past and present, is told in The largest employers: Amazon, RWJBarnabas and Wakefern and where the jobs are: pharma, finance, logistics and health. The Supreme Court's decision remains one of the most-cited antitrust rulings in American law. If you walk the Bayonne waterfront today, you are standing in the place where one of its principal facts began: a corporation whose home was a New Jersey charter and whose business was oil.

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic