Blog
Myths about the Pine Barrens
The Pine Barrens are not barren, empty or unprotected. Seven myths about New Jersey's 1.1 million acre Pinelands, from the soil and fire to the Jersey Devil.
Drive the Atlantic City Expressway toward the shore, or the southern stretch of the Garden State Parkway, and the trees close in on both sides: short, dark pines, scrub oak, and then a gap where a sand road runs off into the woods. Millions of people pass through the Pine Barrens every year at 65 miles per hour without once getting out of the car. Many of them carry a picture in their heads that the name has put there. It is mostly wrong.
The Pinelands, as the state calls them in official documents, cover about 1.1 million acres, most of it in Atlantic, Burlington and Ocean Counties, with parts of several others. That is a large share of southern New Jersey, in the most densely populated state in the country. Here are the common beliefs about this place, and what is actually true.
Myth 1: The Pine Barrens are barren
Fact: The name is a colonial judgment, not a description. Early European settlers looked at the pale, sandy, acidic soil and saw land that would not grow the wheat and corn they knew, so they called it barren. Farmers were right about the crops. They were wrong about the land.
The forest that grows in that sand is a specific and rich one. The dominant tree is the pitch pine, which thrives where little else will. Beneath it grow scrub oaks, huckleberry and blueberry bushes, mountain laurel, sphagnum bogs and Atlantic white cedar swamps. The state describes the Pinelands as home to rare plants and animals found in few other places, and the area carries recognition as a National Reserve and a biosphere reserve. In the far interior, on the so-called plains, the pines stay stunted to head height or below because of the soil and recurring fire. The trees there are small, not necessarily young.
The same acid, sandy soil is why cranberries and blueberries grow so well here. Both crops are grown in the pines' bogs and fields, and they are a living argument against the word "barren." See Cranberries, blueberries and the Pinelands for the farming that grew from it.
Myth 2: It is a wilderness where nobody lives
Fact: People have lived and worked in the Pinelands for centuries. The Lenape used the area long before the colonial period. Later came the bog-iron furnaces, glassworks, charcoal burners and paper mills, whose industries rose and fell with the fuel supply and left old villages and ruins in the woods, such as the restored village at Batsto in Wharton State Forest. Today the Pinelands include towns, farms, military land, highways and quiet subdivisions. Residents of the Pinelands towns pay property tax and send children to school like anyone else in the state.
The thing that makes the Pinelands unusual is not emptiness but a deliberate limit on how much more of it can be built over. That leads to the next myth.
Myth 3: Anyone can build anything out there
Fact: The Pinelands have been covered by a regional land-use plan since the early 1980s, which is unusual in a state that prizes local control. Congress created the Pinelands National Reserve in 1978. The following year the state passed its own Pinelands Protection Act and created the Pinelands Commission, a state agency whose office is in New Lisbon in Burlington County. The commission wrote the Comprehensive Management Plan, which divides the Pinelands into management areas and sets how much development may take place in each. Some areas are meant to stay forest, some are open to farming, and some are regional growth areas where towns can expand.
The practical result is that a town in the Pinelands cannot approve a project that conflicts with the commission's plan, and certain projects need commission review. That is the sort of arrangement that is a source of friction in some years, when a landowner or a town wants something the plan does not allow, and of pride in others, when a stretch of forest is left standing because of it. The commission's rules and the plan itself are public, posted on the agency's site. Residents of Pinelands towns can reach the commission at 609-894-7300 on weekdays. For the larger story, see Protecting the Pinelands and the entry on Pinelands Commission and Highlands Council.
Myth 4: It is one big state park
Fact: Much of the Pinelands is private land, and the public lands are of several kinds. The largest public holdings are state forests, including Wharton State Forest, which is the biggest in the state system, Brendan T. Byrne State Forest and Belleplain State Forest in Cape May County, and Double Trouble State Park, which is a restored cranberry-growing village and bog. The state's Division of Parks and Forests runs these, and reservations for campsites and cabins go through the NJOutdoors portal. Other areas are wildlife management areas managed by the Division of Fish and Wildlife for hunting, fishing and birding, which have their own rules.
It matters because the rules differ. In a state forest you may camp only at designated sites; in a wildlife management area the land may be open to hunting on certain days, so wear bright colors in the fall. On private land, the owner decides. See A guide to New Jersey's state parks and forests for the system and Visiting the Pine Barrens for a practical way in.
Myth 5: Fire is the enemy of the pines
Fact: The Pinelands burn, and the pines are built for it. Pitch pines can sprout new growth from their trunks after a fire, and their cones open in heat. The forest's character, including the small trees on the plains, depends on a history of fire. Take fire out entirely for a few decades and the understory grows thick, fuel builds up, and the next fire is larger and harder to control.
That is why the state's Forest Fire Service, part of the Department of Environmental Protection, does more than put fires out. It fights wildfires, particularly in spring when dry leaves and wind combine, and it also carries out prescribed burns in controlled conditions, in the cooler months, to reduce fuel near homes and roads. If you live near the woods, the Forest Fire Service has guidance on how to make a home defensible. If you are visiting, check the fire danger rating, obey any burn restrictions and never leave a campfire. The history and the science are in The Pine Barrens: ecology and fire.
Myth 6: The Jersey Devil lives there, and that is why people avoid it
Fact: The Jersey Devil is a legend, a winged creature said to have come from a thirteenth child, and it is told in many forms. The story is tied to the Pinelands by tradition, and every few years someone sells a book or a tour on it. The legend has done the Pine Barrens a favor: it has made the region known, and in the 1980s it gave a hockey team in Newark its name. It has not stopped anyone from visiting. People hike the forests, paddle the tea-colored streams and camp in the state forests all year round without a creature in sight.
The tea color of the water is real, and it comes from cedar and plant tannins, not pollution. The water in Pine Barrens streams is brown yet clear and low in minerals. The water supply beneath the forest, in the sandy aquifer, is another reason the plan limits development: what falls on the pines soaks into the sand and feeds the water used by towns around them.
Myth 7: You will get lost, so you should not go
Fact: People do get lost, because the terrain is flat, the trees look alike and the sand roads fork often. But the Pinelands are also among the easiest wild places in the state to visit, with marked trails, canoe liveries on the rivers and developed campgrounds in the state forests. The way to avoid trouble is the way anywhere: carry a map and a charged phone, tell someone your route and do not trust a phone map on a sand road. A normal car will manage most park roads in dry weather, but deep soft sand after rain strands vehicles that are not built for it. Fill the gas tank beforehand, because stations are far apart.
Ticks and biting flies are real in summer, as in the rest of the state. Hunting seasons, which vary by area, are another reason to check the Division of Fish and Wildlife's calendar before a fall hike. Spring and fall are the most pleasant seasons for a long walk.
What to do with this
Go once, and not by car window. A few good first stops:
- Wharton State Forest, the largest, with the Batsto village site, trails and canoe access. See Wharton State Forest: the Pine Barrens' biggest stretch of public land.
- Brendan T. Byrne State Forest, with campgrounds and hiking in the middle of the pines.
- Double Trouble State Park, a cranberry village that shows how the people and the pines worked together.
- Belleplain State Forest, in Cape May County, for the southern end.
The Pinelands Commission's website describes the reserve, its management areas and the plan, and the state's NJOutdoors portal handles camping reservations. The road-trip version of all this is in A Pine Barrens road trip, and the general entry on the region is The Pine Barrens.