Blog

Myths about OPRA requests

Six myths about New Jersey's Open Public Records Act, from the seven-business-day rule and deemed denials to immediate-access records and where to complain.

The Open Public Records Act, known by its acronym OPRA, is the law that lets a resident, a reporter or a competing bidder ask a New Jersey government body for its records and expect an answer. It is used every day: by neighbors who want to see the minutes of a zoning board, by reporters chasing a contract, by parents who want a school district's budget, by lawyers looking for an inspection report. It is also surrounded by misunderstanding. People believe that an agency must hand over everything within a week, that silence means yes, that only a lawyer can enforce the law. Each of those beliefs can cost a requester a month.

This post goes through six common myths, using the state's own description of the process. It is general information about a public law and not legal advice. The authoritative guides are those of the Government Records Council, which administers OPRA complaints, and the Attorney General's office, which publishes its own OPRA page for requests to its department.

Myth 1: The agency has seven days to hand over the records

The deadline is seven business days, and it is a deadline to respond, not to deliver. A records custodian must answer a request, in the language of the state's guidance, as soon as possible but not later than seven business days after receiving it. Weekends and holidays do not count. The response must take one of four forms: grant access, deny access, seek clarification of the request, or ask for an extension of time. A custodian who needs more time can say so and give a date, and a requester can agree to an extension.

So a records custodian who writes on day seven that the request is granted and the records will be provided in two weeks has complied with the deadline. A request that takes the custodian a month to fill is not necessarily a violation if the extension was properly requested and a date given. The practical lesson is to read the response and keep track of the dates in it. A detailed walk through the process is in An OPRA request from start to finish, and How to file an OPRA request covers how to file.

Myth 2: If the agency says nothing, it means yes

It means the opposite. Under the law, a request is deemed denied if the custodian does not respond within the seven business days or within an agreed extension. Silence is a denial, which a requester can challenge. That rule exists so that an agency cannot freeze a request by ignoring it. It also places a burden on the requester: a deemed denial is a trigger for a complaint, but nothing arrives in the mail to tell you the clock has run out. Deemed denials: what silence means under OPRA explains the rule in detail.

A requester who has heard nothing after seven business days should put the date in a calendar, follow up with the custodian in writing and consider filing a complaint, which can be done in Superior Court or with the Government Records Council. Time limits apply to those, too, so waiting does not help.

Myth 3: Everything the government has is public

OPRA creates a presumption that government records are open, but the law, along with other statutes, regulations and executive orders, exempts large categories. Among those commonly cited are records of ongoing criminal investigations, certain personnel records, advisory, consultative and deliberative material in which officials weigh options before a decision, and personal identifiers such as Social Security numbers. A custodian who denies part of a request must say which exemption applies, and a requester can challenge the denial.

The presumption cuts both ways. The law is written so that the government bears the burden of showing that an exemption applies, and records that are not exempt must be released. A custodian can redact the exempt part of a document and release the rest. It is common for a requester to get a document with some lines blacked out, and that is not a denial of the whole thing.

Myth 4: A request can ask for everything about a topic

Requests have to be specific enough to identify records. OPRA gives a right to government records, not a right to have staff research a subject and compile the answers. A request for "all emails about the school budget" is likely to be treated as overbroad; a request for the budget, or for emails between named people on named dates containing specific words, can be filled. The same goes for questions: asking an agency "why did you do this?" is not a records request, though asking for the memo or the minutes that explain the decision is.

Good requests name the kind of record, the agency, the date range and, where possible, the people involved. They ask for records that exist. A requester who is not sure what exists can often learn by asking the custodian informally, or by looking at an agency's own website, before filing. A narrower request is also faster, because the custodian has less to search.

Myth 5: It always takes seven business days

Some records come right away. The state's guidance says that certain records are available immediately, including budgets, bills, vouchers and contracts, and that some election-related records are due within two business days. These are the records the Legislature decided were so basic to public oversight that the custodian should not need a week. A requester who asks for the town's current budget, a vendor's contract or a list of vouchers can invoke that right. If an agency stalls on one of them, the requester can point to the rule.

There is a related point about how requests are made. Under the law, requests are filed with the agency's records custodian, and agencies commonly use a standard form and, increasingly, an online portal. The custodian's contact information is usually on the agency's website, and the name of the custodian for a municipality is on the town's page. The law was amended in 2024, and the Government Records Council's citizen's guide, dated October 2024, describes the current rules; a requester should use it.

Myth 6: Only a lawyer can enforce OPRA

A requester who is denied access has two paths, and neither requires a lawyer. One is to file a complaint with the Government Records Council, which is in the Department of Community Affairs and handles complaints about denials at no charge. The council's information line is 866-850-0511. The other is to sue in Superior Court, where a lawyer is useful, though a person may represent themselves. The Council's complaint process is designed for people who do not have an attorney; it takes the complaint, asks the agency to respond and decides whether access was wrongly denied.

The choice between the paths is a real one. The council process is free and informal but can be slow, and the court route allows a judge to order records released and can result in a fee award in some cases. Someone considering either should read the council's guide for the deadlines and for what each forum can order. OPRA, the Government Records Council and Open Public Meetings describes the legal framework and the agencies around it.

What kinds of records people actually get

It helps to see how the law is used. Residents have asked for the minutes and the agendas of municipal bodies, the budget of the school district, the contract for a snow removal service, the inspection reports for a building, the correspondence between a town and a developer, the salary of a public employee and the settlement of a lawsuit against a town. Reporters use OPRA to follow money and decisions. Businesses use it to see bids. A good request is one that someone has thought about in advance.

State agencies receive many requests, and some publish their own pages. The Attorney General's office has an OPRA request page at njoag.gov for records it holds. Other bodies, such as the Office of the State Comptroller and the Election Law Enforcement Commission, publish reports and data on their own sites, so that a requester may find a record without filing. The comptroller and Medicaid fraud and Campaign finance and ELEC describe two such bodies and the records they publish.

Practical checklist

  1. Find the custodian. Look on the agency's website for the records custodian and the OPRA request form or portal.
  2. Be specific. Name the record, the agency, the dates and the people.
  3. Ask for what you want in the format you want, such as electronic copies.
  4. Keep a copy of the request and the date it was received.
  5. Count seven business days from receipt, and note any extension the custodian asks for.
  6. If denied, read the reason. Exemptions must be stated.
  7. Complain if needed. Use the Government Records Council or Superior Court, and mind the deadlines.

The law does its best work when a requester treats it as a conversation with a records custodian, not a contest. Most requests, made clearly, are answered. The myths are what make people give up before they ask. A resident who wants to go further and attend the meetings where the decisions are made can read how to attend and speak at a public meeting.

Related state government

Related guides

Latest on this topic