Blog

The comptroller and Medicaid fraud

The Office of the State Comptroller audits agencies, reviews public contracts and polices Medicaid providers. A profile of what it does and how to reach it.

Most state agencies in Trenton exist to deliver something: licenses, road repairs, student aid, unemployment checks. The Office of the State Comptroller delivers scrutiny. It has no building permits to issue and no benefits to hand out. Its work is to read the contracts, count the money and ask whether public dollars were spent the way the law says. It also runs one of the state's main checks on fraud in Medicaid, the health program that New Jersey calls NJ FamilyCare.

The office is young by state-government standards, and its name trips people up. It is spelled "comptroller," pronounced like "controller," and the spelling is an inheritance from older English usage that New Jersey and a number of other states kept. The mailing address is PO Box 024, Trenton, NJ 08625, and the office's web pages live at nj.gov/comptroller.

A 2007 creation

The office was created by a law enacted in 2007 and signed by Governor Jon Corzine, as part of a package of measures meant to improve oversight of state spending. Under that law the comptroller is appointed by the governor with the advice and consent of the Senate and serves a six-year term, with no more than two successive terms. The six-year term is deliberate. It is longer than a governor's four-year term, which gives the officeholder some distance from the administration that appointed them.

In 2010, the powers of the state's Medicaid Inspector General were folded into the comptroller's office. That is why a single agency now handles both the examination of government contracts and the examination of health-care providers who bill Medicaid. Many New Jersey residents have never heard of it, in part because its work is done through reports and enforcement actions rather than public counters.

Do not confuse it with two neighbors. The State Treasurer runs the state's money: the budget, tax collection, debt, pensions and procurement. The State Auditor works for the Legislature, in the Office of Legislative Services, and audits agencies on its behalf. The comptroller sits in the executive branch but is meant to behave like an outside examiner. For the Treasury side, see The Treasury and the state budget; for the department that administers NJ FamilyCare, see New Jersey Department of Human Services.

What the office does

The comptroller's web site organizes the office's work under four headings: audits, investigations, Medicaid fraud and public contracting oversight.

Audits. The office audits state agencies, local governments, school districts and other public entities to see whether they follow the rules on spending, billing and record-keeping. The results are published as reports, and many of them name specific lapses: payments made without documentation, contracts awarded without competition, bills that were not checked against deliveries.

Investigations. When a tip or an audit finding suggests fraud, waste or abuse, the office can investigate. It takes complaints from the public, including anonymous ones, through a hotline and an e-mail address, both listed below.

Public contracting oversight. This is the part of the office that most local officials meet. The state's public contracting laws require government entities to notify the comptroller and submit contract information, with timing that depends on the contract's value and funding source. The office now handles that review through an electronic system, the Electronic Procurement Notice and Submission System. The point of reviewing contracts before or as they are signed is to catch a flawed process while it can still be fixed, rather than after the money has gone out.

Medicaid fraud. This is the division that gives the office its reputation. It looks at providers who bill Medicaid, publishes enforcement actions and accepts complaints.

How Medicaid fraud actually happens

Medicaid is a joint program of the federal government and the states. In New Jersey, the Department of Human Services runs it as NJ FamilyCare, and providers send bills to the state or to the managed-care plans that the state contracts with. Because the system pays enormous numbers of claims, the risks are mostly of a few familiar kinds.

  • Billing for services never delivered. A provider sends a claim for a visit, a test or a day of therapy that did not take place.
  • Billing for a higher level of service than was provided. Sometimes called upcoding, it means a brief visit is billed as a long one or a routine procedure as a complex one.
  • Billing for services that were not medically necessary, or that were not ordered by a licensed professional.
  • Kickbacks. A provider pays or receives something of value for referrals.
  • Eligibility fraud. A person lies about income or household circumstances to obtain coverage they do not qualify for.

The comptroller's Medicaid work centers on providers, rather than on individual beneficiaries, though its complaint channels accept reports of both. Remedies range from recovering overpayments to excluding a provider from the program. Cases that rise to criminal conduct go to the criminal-justice side of state government, which means the Attorney General's office. See Office of the Attorney General for how the Department of Law and Public Safety divides that work.

How to report a concern

The office's published channels, as of 2026, are:

  1. General fraud, waste or abuse: call 1-855-OSC-TIPS (1-855-672-8477) or e-mail [email protected].
  2. Medicaid fraud: call 1-888-9FRAUD5 (1-888-937-2835) or e-mail [email protected].

Both channels accept anonymous complaints. A useful report, anonymous or not, gives the who, what, where and when in as much detail as the reporter honestly has. Names of the provider or agency, dates of service, what was billed or promised, and how the reporter knows are all things an investigator can start with. A reporter should not need to prove fraud; that is the investigator's job. What the reporter needs is a specific, honest account. It also helps to keep any bill, explanation of benefits or contract the reporter has, because original documents are often more useful than recollections.

Complaints about the quality of care, about a denied claim or about a lost benefit belong elsewhere. Those go to the plan, to the Department of Human Services or to the licensing board for the profession involved, not to the comptroller. The comptroller's lane is money that was spent or billed improperly.

What the office's reports look like

Audit reports from the office follow a consistent pattern: a summary of what was examined, a list of findings and a set of recommendations, usually followed by a response from the agency under review. Reading a few of them shows what ordinary government failure tends to look like. It is seldom a villain. More often it is a process that was never written down, a control that depended on one person's memory, or a contract renewed year after year without a fresh look at price and performance.

Public entities under review sometimes disagree with findings, and the published reports often include the agency's own reply. That exchange is part of the record. Reporters, advocates and local officials use the reports to see how other towns and agencies handle the same chores, such as school district purchasing, municipal procurement, and the handling of grant money. The reports are public documents posted on the office's site, and requests for related records fall under the Open Public Records Act. See Deemed denials: what silence means under OPRA for how that law's clock works.

A worked example of a contract review

Say a school district plans to award a large contract for building maintenance. The district's business office writes the specifications, advertises the work and receives bids. Under the state's public contracting rules, the district has to tell the comptroller's office about the contract and send in its details, and what it must submit and when depends on the contract's value and funding source. A reviewer can then ask plain questions. Was the work advertised so that more than one firm could bid? Does the winning price match the specifications? Is there a reason the lowest bidder was passed over? If something does not add up, the reviewer can raise it with the district before the money moves, which is far easier than recovering it afterward.

Where the comptroller fits in the checks on state spending

New Jersey has several layers of oversight, and it is easier to understand the comptroller by seeing the others:

  • The Legislature appropriates the money and its Office of Legislative Services supports the State Auditor.
  • The State Treasurer and the Office of Management and Budget manage the books day to day.
  • The Attorney General prosecutes crimes, including fraud against the state.
  • The State Commission of Investigation is a separate investigative body that issues public reports on matters it chooses.
  • The comptroller audits, reviews contracts and chases fraud in the Medicaid system, and does so from a position that is supposed to stand a step away from the line agencies.

Each layer works with different tools. A grand jury can compel testimony; an auditor can compel records; a contract reviewer can ask a question before the money moves. In practice they overlap, and a Medicaid case that begins as an audit finding may end up with a prosecutor, while a complaint to the hotline may end with a repayment and no criminal case.

What residents can do with this

Three ordinary uses stand out. A resident who sees a local contract that looks unusual can look for the audit reports of that entity and read what the office has said about similar cases. A resident who gets an explanation of benefits for a service they never received can call the Medicaid line, or the plan, and ask. And a public employee who sees something wrong can use the hotline without giving a name. Anyone who suspects a crime that is happening now, or a threat to safety, should call 911 instead; the comptroller's hotline is for fraud, waste and abuse, not for emergencies.

The comptroller's office will never be the most visible agency in Trenton. It does not hold ribbon cuttings or announce new programs. Its value is in the questions it asks after the money has been committed, and in the fact that a resident with a hunch can reach it by telephone, at no charge, without giving a name.

Related state government

Related guides

Latest on this topic