Blog

Ida and the first flash flood emergency

On September 1, 2021, Ida's remnants brought the Weather Service's first flash flood emergency for northeast New Jersey and an EF3 tornado in Mullica Hill.

The most dangerous weather product the National Weather Service can issue for a flood has a short name and a long reputation. It is called a flash flood emergency, and it is meant to be used almost never: when a flood is happening or about to happen, when it threatens catastrophic damage, and when lives are in immediate danger. Most forecast offices go years without one. On the evening of September 1, 2021, the Weather Service office that covers northern New Jersey and New York City issued the first one in its history, for northeastern New Jersey, and then, about an hour later, another for New York City itself. The storm that prompted them had been a hurricane three days earlier on the Gulf Coast. By the time it reached New Jersey it was a rainstorm of a kind the state had not seen.

How a hurricane became a flood

Ida made landfall in Louisiana as a major hurricane at the end of August 2021 and then spent days crossing the South. It became post-tropical early on September 1, then strengthened again as a strongly forced frontal low as it merged with a front and a rich plume of tropical moisture. From the early morning through the late evening, the low moved from West Virginia to roughly the I-95 corridor between northeast Maryland and northeast New Jersey. Torrential rain fell near and west of the storm's track, which is where the catastrophic flash flooding in eastern Pennsylvania and central and northern New Jersey occurred.

A storm like that does not so much deliver rain as hold it over one place. In Hunterdon County, rainfall topped 11 inches. In Newark, the airport recorded its wettest hour on record, 3.24 inches between 8 and 9 p.m., with 5.06 inches in two hours and 7.88 inches in six, and more than 8 inches over the day. Those are rates at which a drainage system built for ordinary storms stops working: the water has nowhere to go and goes where it likes.

The night, hour by hour

By late afternoon, the Weather Service's offices were already seeing the worst of it coming. The Mount Holly office, which covers the southern and central part of the state, noted several tornadoes the afternoon and evening of September 1, with particularly strong and damaging ones in Gloucester County, New Jersey, and Montgomery County, Pennsylvania. At about 6:10 p.m. a tornado began near Harrisonville in Gloucester County and tracked for roughly twenty minutes, ending near Deptford. It passed through Mullica Hill, along Route 45, and the National Weather Service rated it an EF3 on the 0-to-5 Enhanced Fujita scale. A preliminary report estimated its maximum winds at about 150 miles per hour. It destroyed multiple homes. A second tornado, rated EF1, tracked from Edgewater Park in Burlington County toward Bristol, Pennsylvania. The night's tornadoes, together, are the reason Ida is remembered in the southern half of the state as much for wind as for water.

In the north, the rain was the story. As the downpours settled over Essex, Hudson, Union and Passaic counties, the Weather Service's New York office issued a flash flood emergency for northeastern New Jersey. It was the first the office had ever declared. The one for New York City came an hour later, and it was the first ever for the city. The warnings went out to phones as wireless alerts. Newark Liberty International Airport flooded, and all departures were grounded for a time. Much of the subway, the Long Island Rail Road, Metro-North and NJ Transit shut down. Power went out for more than 81,000 customers in New Jersey that night.

The rivers

The storm's second act played out on the rivers. Several reached record or major crests, and the gauge reports tell the story:

  • The Raritan River at Manville crested at 27.66 feet, a record.
  • The Millstone River at Weston crested at 23.75 feet, a record.
  • Stony Brook at Princeton crested at 17.65 feet, a record.

Manville, in Somerset County, had the worst flooding in the state. The borough sits along the Raritan near where the Millstone joins it, and the water rose into homes and businesses, some of which caught fire. In Trenton, parts of the city were evacuated. Rescue teams, including New Jersey Task Force One and county emergency teams, made more than 300 water rescues.

The toll

The loss of life was the hardest part of the story, and the count has been reported with some variation. State and federal summaries record at least 27 deaths in New Jersey, and other tables list 32, with 29 deaths directly from the storm and 3 indirect. As of September 4, the Weather Service listed five known fatalities in Somerset County and six in Hunterdon County. Five people died in an apartment complex in Elizabeth. One person drowned in a car in Passaic. Damage in New Jersey was estimated at $8 billion to $10 billion.

Many of the dead were people in places that did not look like flood zones: basement apartments, vehicles on roads that were dry an hour earlier, neighborhoods far from any river that most residents could name. The lesson that emergency managers drew from the storm was that a flash flood can happen anywhere that sheds water faster than it can drain, which includes most of the built-up Northeast.

Newark's night in numbers

The airport's gauge at Newark gives the cleanest picture of how the rain arrived, because it keeps records going back generations.

Period on September 1, 2021 Rainfall at Newark
The wettest single hour (8 to 9 p.m.) 3.24 inches
The wettest two hours 5.06 inches
The wettest six hours 7.88 inches
The whole day more than 8 inches

Notice that the single hour holds more than a third of the six-hour total, and that the two wettest hours hold nearly two-thirds of it. 3.24 divided by 7.88 is about 41 percent, and 5.06 divided by 7.88 is about 64 percent. The rain did not fall steadily. It fell in a burst, which is exactly the pattern that overwhelms storm drains and small streams, because they are built to carry a certain rate of flow, not a certain daily total.

What the emergency was for

The flash flood emergency is a reminder of how the Weather Service's alert levels work. A flash flood watch means conditions are favorable. A flash flood warning means flooding is happening or imminent and people should move to higher ground. A flash flood emergency sits above the warning, and it is reserved for cases in which a catastrophe is unfolding. It is intended to stand apart from the background of routine warnings. The New York office had never needed it before. The fact that it used the tool twice in an hour says what its forecasters saw on their radar that night.

For residents the practical lesson is about how to receive and act on a warning. The state's emergency management office points people to NJOEM alerts, the Wireless Emergency Alerts that the Weather Service sends to phones in a warning area and the alert systems run by county offices of emergency management. Emergency alerts and storm preparation in New Jersey explains how to sign up. And the old rule applies, one that Ida confirmed: do not drive into water, and do not stay in a basement when water is rising outside.

Questions worth asking before the next one

None of this is advice for any one household's situation, but emergency managers and the state's own guidance point to a handful of questions that Ida made urgent.

  1. Do the people in your home receive wireless emergency alerts, and is the phone set to let them through at night?
  2. Does your county run its own alert system, and have you signed up? The state's emergency management page lists county coordinators.
  3. If you live below street level, in a basement apartment or a low garage unit, where would you go if water started rising, and how fast could you get there?
  4. Do you know which roads near you flood, so that you are not deciding in the dark whether to drive through an underpass?
  5. Is your insurance coverage for flooding something you have read, not assumed? Ordinary homeowner and renter policies generally treat flood damage separately.

The questions are not new. What Ida did was to show how many people live in places where the answers matter.

What changed afterward

Three things stand out in the years since.

Inland buyouts. The storm moved the idea of flood retreat from the coast to the river valleys, where Blue Acres had been buying land for decades. The Raritan basin, with Manville at its center, became a main focus. Blue Acres: buying out flood-prone homes tells that story.

The rainfall record. Newark's hourly record and Central Park's, which hit 3.15 inches in an hour, led to public debate about whether storm drains and sewers designed for older rainfall rates are adequate. Water and sewer systems are the work of municipalities and regional authorities, and the cost of upgrading them is one of the state's largest infrastructure questions.

The warning culture. The Weather Service and county emergency managers now talk about flash flood risk in the urban and suburban Northeast with new urgency, and the term "flash flood emergency" is no longer unfamiliar to residents.

The state's coastal storm story, told through Sandy, is a different kind of event, driven by surge and wind. Ida was a rain event, and the two together mark the range of what New Jersey weather can do. For the coast see After Sandy: the Seaside Heights rebuild. For the way tornadoes fit into the state's weather, see Tornadoes in New Jersey: your questions answered, and for the rivers themselves, The Passaic, the Raritan and the Mullica: three rivers, three Jerseys. The communities hit hardest include Newark, where the airport flooded (see Newark), and Hunterdon County, which received the highest rainfall totals (Hunterdon County).

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic