Blog

Holocaust and Amistad education in New Jersey schools

New Jersey required Holocaust and genocide teaching in 1994 and created the Amistad Commission in 2002; how the two mandates work in classrooms.

Most state curriculum rules are the kind of thing only a district curriculum director could love: standards by grade band, benchmarks, cross-references. New Jersey has two that are different. They are written into statute, they are named in public conversation as if they were people, and they were the first of their kind. One is the Holocaust and genocide education mandate of 1994. The other is the Amistad law of 2002, which created a commission to promote the teaching of African American history. Both are run from the Department of Education, and both explain a good deal about how the state thinks about what a student should know before graduating.

The 1994 Holocaust and genocide mandate

The Legislature passed the Holocaust and genocide education act in March 1994, and Governor Christine Todd Whitman signed it that spring. It requires every board of education to include instruction on the Holocaust and genocides in the curriculum of elementary and secondary students. The law says what the instruction should accomplish: it must help students analyze the causes of genocide, including prejudice and discrimination, and it must emphasize each citizen's responsibility to fight hatred and bigotry. The requirement first applied to the 1994-95 school year.

It was the first mandate of its kind in the country. The idea came from the state's own Commission on Holocaust Education, which voted unanimously to pursue the legislation after a meeting at what is now Stockton University in the early 1990s. The path was not smooth. Passage faced delays, and the bill drew threats from the Turkish government, as well as concerns from school administrators and educators about adding to the curriculum. The Legislature passed it unanimously in the end. In April 2024 Stockton marked the thirtieth anniversary of the mandate at an event on campus.

New Jersey's law is a mandate in the plainest sense, and it has outlasted every revision of the state's learning standards. The Commission's guidance says the 1994 statute remains in effect and has to be considered whenever a district writes or revises its curriculum, and that changes to the standards do not change the requirement. Districts decide how and where in the curriculum the instruction appears. Most teach it in social studies and language arts, in the middle grades and again in high school.

Who runs it: the Commission on Holocaust Education

The Commission is older than the mandate. Coordinated Holocaust education in New Jersey began in 1974, and a Holocaust Council was created by executive order in 1982. The Legislature established the Commission as a permanent state body in 1991. It is attached to the Department of Education and made up of about twenty members, with a chair, vice chair, executive director and staff, and standing committees for budget and fundraising, education, legislative matters and outreach.

Its job is to help districts do what the law requires. It surveys how the subject is taught, designs and encourages Holocaust and genocide education, runs programs and organizes memorial events, and advises public and private schools and county and local officials on planning courses. The Commission offers:

  • curriculum guides and materials for kindergarten through twelfth grade;
  • an Adopt-A-Survivor project, which pairs students with survivors;
  • training programs for teachers, which are the most requested resource;
  • virtual guided tours, a Holocaust education trunk of materials that can travel to schools and a speakers bureau;
  • a network of Holocaust resource centers on college campuses, including the Sara and Sam Schoffer Holocaust Resource Center at Stockton, which opened in 1990 and was one of the first hosted by a public college; and
  • student award contests.

A survey the Commission ran in 2015, covering more than sixty-five districts, found that teachers drew on a wide mix of books, videos and programs, and that many districts wanted more training for staff. That is a pattern worth keeping in mind: the law says what must be taught, but each classroom's version depends on what materials and preparation the teacher has.

The Amistad Commission

The second mandate has a different history and a different shape. On August 27, 2002, Governor James McGreevey signed the Amistad bill, designated A1301, sponsored by Assemblymen William D. Payne and Craig A. Stanley. The law created the Amistad Commission, named for the ship La Amistad, on which a group of enslaved Africans rebelled in 1839 and won their freedom. The case reached the United States Supreme Court, which ruled in 1841 that they had been taken illegally and were free to go home.

The commission's mission is to make sure New Jersey's educators have the training, resources and curriculum support to teach African and African American history accurately and across subjects, especially social studies and world history. The law directs it to create and promote educational programs on the African slave trade, the history of slavery in America and the contributions of Africans and African Americans. It also tells the commission to develop teacher training, coordinate statewide events and provide memorialization of slavery and the struggle for freedom. The Department of Education's role is to assist the commission in marketing and distributing these materials to educators and to monitor how they are used across the state's schools.

Unlike the Holocaust law, which sets a specific instructional requirement, the Amistad law is mainly a support structure: a body that produces resources and works with teachers. The commission offers in-service workshops, teaching tools, residential summer institutes, curriculum materials aligned with state learning standards and help with lesson planning.

Why New Jersey, and why these two

There is a pattern in how the state treats these subjects that comes from its own history. New Jersey was a slave state in the colonial and early national period, and the end of slavery here was slow. The state's gradual abolition act is dated 1804, and it phased slavery out over decades instead of ending it at once. New Jersey also has a long record of struggle over civil rights, from the 1964 riots in Jersey City, Paterson and Elizabeth to the Newark riots of July 1967. A state whose big cities have been defined by both migration and conflict has reasons to teach history as something that happens on its own streets. See The 1964 riots in Jersey City, Paterson and Elizabeth and Newark, July 12 to 17, 1967: the days, the toll and the Lilley Report for two chapters that residents still argue about.

For the Holocaust mandate, the state's history of immigration matters. New Jersey received many refugees and survivors, and Ellis Island, whose New Jersey side lies in Jersey City, was the gateway for millions of arrivals. The institutions that carry Holocaust memory, from college resource centers to memorial events in the spring, grew out of those communities.

Remembrance beyond the classroom

The state's commemorations extend the same message beyond school hours. The Commission on Holocaust Education organizes memorial events, and it has linked its work to the state's September 11 observances through classroom activities for that anniversary. Colleges that host Holocaust resource centers hold public lectures, and some offer coursework in genocide studies. Stockton University says it offers more Holocaust and Genocide Studies classes than any other university in the world, a claim its president made at the thirtieth anniversary of the mandate. The Amistad Commission, for its part, runs summer institutes where teachers study African American history as a discipline in its own right instead of a month on the calendar.

What this means in a classroom

How the mandates show up in a given school depends on a few levers, and parents can ask about each.

  1. The curriculum. Every district writes its own, and the district's curriculum must address the Holocaust and genocide. Ask which grades teach it and in which courses.
  2. The teacher's training. The commissions offer workshops, and the quality of instruction can turn on whether a teacher has attended one.
  3. The resources. Survivor speakers, museum visits and virtual tours are the kind of thing that shift a lesson from a paragraph to a memory. The Holocaust Commission offers some of these, and many are free or low cost.
  4. The calendar. Observances, including Holocaust remembrance in the spring, give schools a natural moment to bring in a speaker or a program.

The Department of Education posts the commissions' materials on its website, and its pages for each commission list their members, programs and contact information. They are linked from the New Jersey Department of Education page. If a district's local school board is considering a change to its curriculum, the board's own meeting is the place where the community can weigh in, and the county superintendent and the school district system explains how the school district system works around it.

A note on how the state frames memory

Two features set these laws apart. First, they speak in the language of obligation, not recommendation. The 1994 statute does not say that districts may teach about the Holocaust. It says they must. Second, they link the study of the past to present-day behavior: the Holocaust law explicitly names each citizen's responsibility to combat hatred. The Amistad law is framed around accurate teaching of contributions and the memorialization of a hard history. In both cases the legislature decided that the state, not just local school boards, had a stake in what students learned.

Whether the approach works is an argument that educators have had for thirty years, and it is a reasonable one. A mandate does not teach a class. A teacher does. But the two commissions exist so that the teacher in a small district in Salem County has the same resources as one in Newark, and that was the idea from the start.

Related state government

Latest on this topic