Blog
Newark, July 12 to 17, 1967: the days, the toll and the Lilley Report
A day-by-day account of the six days of unrest in Newark, who died, and how the governor's commission traced the causes before the Kerner Commission did.
The city in 1967
Newark in the summer of 1967 was a city that had changed faster than the people who ran it. Between 1960 and 1967 its population went from about 65 percent white to about 52 percent Black, as white middle-class families moved to the suburbs along the new highways. The people who stayed faced housing that was crowded and old, an economy that was losing jobs, and a city government that had not changed with them. Of the city's 1,322 police officers, only 145, about 11 percent, were Black. Hugh J. Addonizio, the mayor, was the city's last white mayor, and he was widely criticized for doing little to share political power and city jobs.
That is the background for what began on a Wednesday night in July. The events are known by several names: a riot, a rebellion, the days of unrest. This account uses the dates and numbers on the public record, and it starts with a traffic stop.
Wednesday, July 12
At about 9:40 p.m., two white Newark police officers stopped a cab driver, John William Smith, who was Black, for a traffic violation. The officers beat him and arrested him, and took him to the Fourth Precinct station. Rumors spread that Smith had been beaten to death. A crowd gathered outside the precinct, and accounts differ about who was first to act, whether rocks were thrown first or police rushed out first. After midnight, false alarms sent fire engines to Belmont Avenue, and looters, mostly targeting liquor stores, began to work through the area.
Thursday, July 13
The mayor met with community leaders on Thursday. They demanded that the two officers be suspended, that the events of the previous night be investigated and that a Black police lieutenant, Eddie Williams, be promoted to captain. The mayor asked for 48 hours. A rally at the Fourth Precinct at 7:30 p.m. turned violent within minutes of an announcement about Williams's promotion. Windows at the precinct were smashed, looting spread along Springfield Avenue and Molotov cocktails set buildings on fire.
Friday, July 14
By 1:00 a.m. police were told they could fire if necessary. At 2:20 a.m. the mayor requested the State Police, who arrived with about 300 troopers, and at 2:30 a.m. the National Guard, of which 3,464 were brought into the city. By morning three people had been killed, including Rose Abraham and Tedlock Bell Jr. That evening, at 7:30 p.m., a detective, Frederick Toto, was shot by a sniper, the first police officer to die, and his death drew national attention. About an hour later, at 8:30 p.m., Guardsmen at a checkpoint killed a ten-year-old boy, Eddie Moss.
Saturday, July 15, and the days after
On Saturday gunfire aimed at a second-floor apartment window killed Rebecca Brown. The three forces on the street, the Newark police, the State Police and the National Guard, used different radio frequencies, which made coordination difficult. Bridges to Harrison were closed each evening at 6:00 p.m. until the following morning. By the sixth day, July 17, the toll had reached 26 people dead. Of them, 16 were civilians, eight were suspects and one was a police officer and one a firefighter, by the count of that sixth day. About 727 people were injured: 567 civilians, 67 police officers, 55 firefighters and 38 military personnel. The total of arrests was 1,465, and damage was more than $10 million. In all, 7,917 police and Guard members had been deployed. A photograph of a twelve-year-old boy wounded by stray pellets, Joe Bass Jr., was on the cover of Life magazine on July 28, 1967.
The state's response is one part of the story that is better remembered than the street scenes. The Governor, Richard J. Hughes, called in the State Police and Guard at the mayor's request, and in August 1967 he created a state commission to find out what had happened. The report is called the Lilley Report, after the chairman, Robert D. Lilley, and it came out in 1968. The commission named police misconduct, inequality and political exclusion as the primary causes, and it made nearly 100 recommendations. The Lilley Report preceded the federal Kerner Commission, and it is generally described as a blueprint for the national report. In other words, a New Jersey commission reached its conclusions about the causes of urban unrest before the nation's.
The response on the street
Looking at the first four days together, a pattern appears that the later commissions picked up. The trouble began with a rumor, the rumor that a man in custody had died, and spread faster than any official statement. The city's first response was to put more police on the street, and by the early hours of July 14 officers had been told they could fire if necessary. The call for the State Police and the National Guard came only after that, at 2:20 and 2:30 that morning. By then the unrest had spread along Springfield Avenue and Belmont Avenue.
The three forces then on the street had not trained together and did not share radio channels. The Newark police, the State Police and the Guard used three different frequency ranges, so a unit from one could not easily talk to a unit from another. With nearly 8,000 armed men deployed in a few square miles, at night, with snipers reported and fires burning, the lack of a common command was a hazard in itself. Those conditions are part of the public record of the six days.
Two commissions
The federal government was moving on its own track. President Johnson created the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders, known as the Kerner Commission after its chairman, Governor Otto Kerner of Illinois, on July 27, 1967, while the ashes in Newark were still being counted, and its report came out in the spring of 1968. New Jersey's commission, begun in August 1967, was finished first. That order is why Newark's report gets cited in histories of the period. The Lilley commission named police misconduct, inequality and political exclusion as the primary causes, and the national commission's report followed the same general line.
A note about the numbers: counts of the dead, the injured and the arrested differ somewhat by source and by date, because the figures were tallied during and after the events. The totals used here, 26 dead, about 727 injured and 1,465 arrested, are the ones most commonly cited for the six days.
What changed, and what did not
The aftermath is a long-term one, and historians disagree about how to weigh it. Industry and the white middle class continued to leave the city, and many suburbs grew rapidly in the same period. Disinvestment that began before 1967 accelerated after it. Newark elected its first Black mayor in 1970, Kenneth Gibson, and the city's mayors since have been Black.
The police department changed slowly. In 2000 the force was 37 percent Black, and in 2016 it was 35 percent Black, 24 percent white and 41 percent Latino. The numbers show a department that had come to look much more like the city, though not necessarily in a single step.
The same summer saw unrest in other New Jersey cities. Plainfield had riots in July 1967, and the earlier riots of 1964 in Jersey City, Paterson and Elizabeth are covered in The 1964 riots in Jersey City, Paterson and Elizabeth. The 1967 events in Newark were the largest in the state.
Newark's own telling
The people who lived through it tell the story in different ways, and the city's institutions have approached the subject in different ways. Some Newark historians prefer the word "rebellion," arguing that the events were a response to a political system that excluded Black residents. Others use "riot." The public record uses both. What is not disputed is the number of dead, the role of the police stop that started it, and the role of the state's response afterward.
The city has also spent decades building cultural institutions that are part of a different story. NJPAC and Newark's arts district describes the performing arts center that opened in 1997, and The Newark Black Film Festival, a July week at the museum describes a festival that began in 1974. The city's modern downtown, with the Prudential Center and the light rail, is in A walk around Newark Penn Station and Prudential Center and Newark Light Rail: a line through the city. For a city profile, see Newark.
Newark now
The city that came out of 1967 is the same city that, according to the 2020 Census, had 311,549 residents and remains the largest municipality in New Jersey. It is the home of Newark Liberty International Airport, Rutgers University-Newark, the Prudential Center, the Newark Museum of Art and the New Jersey Performing Arts Center, where the state's governor was sworn in on January 20, 2026. None of that cancels the events of July 1967; they sit in the same city and in the same history.
Where to read more
The Lilley Report, formally the report of the New Jersey Governor's Select Commission on Civil Disorder, and other records of the period are held in public libraries and archives. The State Library and State Archives in Trenton and the Newark Public Library are the places to ask. Anyone visiting the area around Springfield and Belmont avenues will find a neighborhood that has been rebuilt, in some places, and left open in others.
For the State Police's role and structure today, see New Jersey State Police.