Blog

Cherry Hill and the South Jersey suburbs compared

Cherry Hill, Gloucester Township and the old PATCO towns share one Philadelphia commute and three different histories. Here is how they compare.

South Jersey does not look to New York. Its television comes from Philadelphia, its teams are the Eagles, the Phillies, the 76ers and the Flyers, its hoagies are hoagies, and its commute runs west over the Delaware, not east through a tunnel. The suburbs that fill Camden County are where that orientation is easiest to see, and the three that make the best comparison are Cherry Hill, the biggest; Gloucester Township, the one with the confusing name; and the older towns that grew along the PATCO line. They have the same commute and very different histories.

Cherry Hill: the suburb that invented a template

Cherry Hill is New Jersey's twelfth-largest municipality and the largest in Camden County, with 74,553 residents in the 2020 Census. It is, in its present form, an invention of the 1950s and 1960s. For more than a century it was Delaware Township, incorporated in 1844, a farming and Quaker settlement. After the Second World War the township exploded as families moved out from Camden and Philadelphia, and in 1961 the township was renamed. The reason was bureaucratic: the Postal Service insisted on a name that would not be confused with another Delaware Township, in Hunterdon County. Residents chose "Cherry Hill," after a nineteenth-century farm, in a non-binding referendum, and the new name took effect on November 7, 1961.

The same year the Cherry Hill Shopping Center, later the Cherry Hill Mall, opened in October 1961 with 75 stores. It was the first fully enclosed shopping mall in the eastern United States, and its design, with a climate-controlled interior and acres of free parking, became the template for suburban retail across the country. A town that was a collection of farms in 1950 was, by 1965, a symbol of the postwar suburb. The township had a nightlife too: the Latin Casino, a nightclub that operated from 1960 to the early 1980s, drew national acts, and the racetrack at Garden State Park, which closed in the early 2000s, was a regional draw. The sites have been redeveloped; the Cherry Hill station of the Atlantic City Line sits near the racetrack's old grounds.

Today the township uses the Faulkner Act mayor-council form, Plan B, adopted after a 1981 referendum, with a full-time mayor and seven at-large council members. How Faulkner Act governments work explains what that means. Its public school district has 19 schools and about 10,772 students in 2023-24, including two large high schools, Cherry Hill East and Cherry Hill West, and Camden County College has a campus in the township. History is still visible in the middle of the sprawl: the Barclay Farm House, built in 1816, is on the National Register of Historic Places.

Gloucester Township: the confusing name

Gloucester Township is a joke among newcomers because it is in Camden County, not Gloucester County. Its 2020 population of 66,034 makes it one of the larger municipalities in the county, behind Cherry Hill and Camden itself. The name goes back to the colonial period, when Gloucester County extended over a much larger area than it does now, and Camden County was split off in 1844. The name stuck to the township that stayed on the Camden side. The township stretches along the Black Horse Pike (Route 168), a road that for generations has connected the Philadelphia area to the shore, and its suburban identity was built later than Cherry Hill's, mostly in the postwar decades.

For a visitor or a newcomer the lesson is simple: check the county before you plug an address into a map. A Gloucester County town and a Gloucester Township address are not the same, and the difference affects the county clerk you deal with, the courthouse you use and the tax assessor. That is true of every New Jersey place name, which is a function of a state with 564 municipalities and 21 counties. The overview of how that works is in Why New Jersey has 564 municipalities.

The PATCO towns: Haddonfield, Collingswood, Woodcrest

The oldest part of the story is closer to the river. Haddonfield, a borough in Camden County, is a colonial-era town with a walkable downtown, an old tavern museum and a claim that matters to dinosaur lovers: in 1858 the fossil skeleton of Hadrosaurus foulkii, the first nearly complete dinosaur skeleton found in North America, was dug up here. The Indian King Tavern in town, where the New Jersey Assembly met in 1777, is the other landmark. Collingswood, a few stops closer to Philadelphia, has a revived main street. These are the older, denser suburbs, built on streets laid out before cars.

What connects them to Cherry Hill is the PATCO Speedline, the high-speed rail line that the Delaware River Port Authority runs from Lindenwold, in Camden County, across the Benjamin Franklin Bridge to Philadelphia. The Woodcrest station is in Cherry Hill, off Interstate 295 at exit 31, and trains on the line serve other South Jersey stops on the way. PATCO and the DRPA bridges tells the line's history, and Delaware River Port Authority describes the agency that runs the four bridges and the line.

How they compare

Cherry Hill Gloucester Township PATCO towns
2020 population 74,553 66,034 smaller boroughs
Era of growth 1950s and 1960s postwar decades colonial era, then rail
Main road Route 70, Route 38 Black Horse Pike (Route 168) Kings Highway, Route 41 and the line
Rail Atlantic City Line, PATCO (Woodcrest) the Lindenwold terminal is next door PATCO
Feel big-box suburb with older cores sprawl with a long road walkable downtowns

The pattern is the suburban story of the whole country, with a South Jersey accent. The first ring grew with the railroad and trolley, the second ring with the car and the mall, and the third ring with the highway.

The commute: three ways to Philadelphia

All three place types share a commuter's problem, which is getting across the Delaware. The options are the PATCO train, the Atlantic City Line and the bridges. PATCO runs frequently and serves Philadelphia's center, but its stations are limited to the Lindenwold corridor. The Atlantic City Line, a NJ Transit service, links Philadelphia and Atlantic City with stops that include Cherry Hill. By car, the Benjamin Franklin Bridge connects to Interstate 676 and the Walt Whitman Bridge to Interstate 76; both are Delaware River Port Authority bridges, and their tolls are collected only going into Pennsylvania. The comparison of the options is in Camden: three ways to Philadelphia, with the long view in Crossing to Pennsylvania and Delaware.

Add in the Turnpike and Interstate 295, which pass through the township, and Cherry Hill is among the best-connected places in South Jersey, which is the real reason it grew. The tradeoff is the usual one: traffic in the mornings and evenings, and bridges that are the pinch points for the whole region.

Camden County in context

The comparison makes more sense with the county behind it. Camden County had 523,485 residents in 2020, and its seat is Camden, the river city that is itself one of the state's larger municipalities with 71,791 people. Cherry Hill alone is about 14 percent of the county's residents (74,553 of 523,485), and with Camden and Gloucester Township the three together account for roughly 40 percent. The rest is spread among dozens of boroughs and townships, from Haddonfield and Collingswood to Voorhees, Winslow and Pennsauken. That fragmentation is typical of New Jersey, where every place, however small, has its own mayor, police chief and school board. The county government, run by a board of commissioners, handles the courts' support offices, the county clerk, the sheriff and county roads; County government explains the division of labor.

What the numbers say about the school district

A district of 19 schools and about 10,772 students averages roughly 570 students a school, a figure that explains why Cherry Hill is organized around two large high schools rather than many small ones. That is large by New Jersey standards, where many districts are tiny, and it shapes everything from bus routes to the school calendar. In a state that funds public schools through a formula that mixes state aid and local property taxes, a district of that size has a very large budget, and the school tax is usually the biggest part of a household's property tax bill. How the formula works is in How school funding works in New Jersey.

An odd bit of local fame

Cherry Hill's reputation was made not only by the mall. In the early 1970s the heavyweight champion Muhammad Ali lived in the township, from 1971 to 1974, at the same time the Latin Casino and the racetrack were drawing crowds. It is a reminder that a place that now seems ordinary was once a place people went to be entertained.

Who lives there, and what they argue about

The suburbs' politics are mostly about the same things as anywhere in New Jersey: property taxes, schools and development. A township with 19 schools, like Cherry Hill, is a big school district, and school budgets are a large share of the local tax bill. Redevelopment of old shopping centers and racetrack land is a recurring debate: how much of it should be housing, retail or offices. Those debates are in public hearings before planning boards and council meetings. The practical guide to taking part is how to attend and speak at a public meeting.

What to see

For a visitor, the best day trip is a loop: start in Haddonfield for the old town and the dinosaur story, drive through Cherry Hill to see the mall and the Barclay Farm House, and finish on the PATCO line or the bridge to Philadelphia. For a deeper look at the river city that these suburbs grew out of, see Camden, and for the township's own guide, Cherry Hill. To the south, Rowan University's hometown has its own story, in Glassboro. And for how South Jersey fits into the state's regions, see North, Central and South Jersey, and the shore: the regions explained.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic