Blog

The Division on Civil Rights and the Law Against Discrimination

How the Division on Civil Rights enforces the Law Against Discrimination, what it covers, the 180-day and two-year clocks, and how a complaint moves.

A landlord who will not rent to a family because of a child's disability, an employer who fires a worker after she announces a pregnancy, a restaurant that turns away a customer because of his accent: in New Jersey each of those is a possible violation of the same state law, and the same office enforces it. The office is the Division on Civil Rights, which sits inside the Attorney General's Department of Law and Public Safety. The law is the Law Against Discrimination, known by its initials, LAD, one of the oldest and broadest anti-discrimination statutes in the country.

This post explains what the division does, what the law covers, how long a person has to act, what a complaint looks like from start to finish, and where the division's work ends and a lawsuit begins. It is general information about public processes, not legal advice; anyone with a deadline close at hand should ask a lawyer or the division itself.

A law from 1945

The Law Against Discrimination was enacted in 1945, in the aftermath of the Second World War, when New Jersey became one of the first states to bar employment discrimination by statute. The state's 1947 constitution, adopted two years later, also contains an anti-discrimination clause covering civil and military rights. The law has been amended many times since, and each amendment added a protected category or a setting in which the law applies. The Division on Civil Rights traces its roots to the same period, when the state set up an agency with the job of enforcing the new law.

Today the division's own pages describe two main jobs. It enforces the LAD, and it enforces the New Jersey Family Leave Act. Its work is organized into units for investigations, for affirmative enforcement, for policy, for community relations, and for education and training. It issues rules, guidance and model policies, and it runs programs such as a Youth Ambassador Program. The division names its priorities as housing discrimination, hate and bias, civil rights and technology, gender equity and reproductive rights, and the protection of young people.

What the law covers

The LAD forbids discrimination in four main areas of life.

  • Employment. Hiring, firing, pay, promotion, harassment and the terms of work. The law applies to nearly every employer, large and small, in the state.
  • Housing. Renting, selling, financing and advertising a home. The division lists housing discrimination among its first priorities.
  • Public accommodations. Places open to the public: restaurants, hotels, stores, theaters, schools, hospitals, and many online and service businesses.
  • Credit and business contracts. Lending and the terms on which people can borrow or contract.

The protected characteristics are broad and have grown over the years. The division's pages name race, gender, religion and disability, and say the list reaches other protected characteristics. The statute itself, N.J.S.A. 10:5-12, lists among others race, creed, color, national origin, ancestry, age, sex including pregnancy and breastfeeding, marital status, civil union and domestic partnership status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, disability, and nationality. The division states that protection applies regardless of a person's primary language, country of origin or immigration status, and that discrimination based on accent or dialect may violate the law. It also addresses pregnancy- and lactation-related accommodations in the workplace, and protections for LGBTQIA+ residents. Anyone checking whether a particular category applies should read the statute or call the division, because the list in a blog post is a summary.

The law reaches retaliation too. An employer cannot punish someone for filing a complaint, for helping a colleague file one or for opposing an unlawful practice, and that rule is one reason the division takes complaints from people who are still working at the place they are complaining about.

Two roads and two clocks

A person who believes the LAD has been violated has two ways to proceed, and the choice matters because the deadlines differ.

The Division on Civil Rights. A complaint filed with the division must be filed within 180 days of the incident. The process is administrative: no jury, and the division's director is the final decision-maker. The division can order remedies that include back pay, compensatory damages and attorney's fees, as well as equitable relief such as hiring or reinstatement.

Superior Court. A person may skip the division entirely and file a complaint in the Law Division of the Superior Court within two years of the alleged violation. The state's own explanation lists the advantages of court: a jury trial and the possibility of punitive damages, neither of which is available in the administrative forum.

The two roads cannot be walked at the same time. A person who files with the division may withdraw the complaint and go to court, as long as the division has not found no probable cause and fewer than two years have passed since the violation. If the division finds no probable cause, the way forward is an appeal to the Appellate Division. For pay discrimination, the clock generally runs from the most recent discriminatory paycheck. Deadlines can be complicated by continuing harassment, so it is worth reading the division's FAQ and asking before a date slips by.

How a complaint moves

The division takes complaints through an online portal, listed on its site as bias.njcivilrights.gov. In practice the steps are these.

  1. Filing. The person describes what happened, when, where and who was involved, and names the employer, landlord or business. The division sends the complaint to the respondent.
  2. Investigation. The Investigations Unit gathers documents and statements from both sides. Respondents file an answer.
  3. Finding. The division decides whether there is probable cause to believe the law was violated. If there is no probable cause, the complaint is dismissed and the complainant can appeal.
  4. Conciliation and settlement. On a probable cause finding, the division tries to settle the matter. Many cases end here.
  5. Hearing. Cases that do not settle go to a hearing before an administrative law judge at the Office of Administrative Law, and the division's director issues the final decision. The Office of Administrative Law, a court inside the executive branch explains that office and how its hearings work.
  6. Appeal. A final decision can be appealed to the Appellate Division of Superior Court.

The division also brings cases on its own, through its affirmative enforcement unit, when it sees a pattern of discrimination. In those matters the Attorney General's office is the party. That is why civil rights enforcement sits within the state's top law enforcement department, the office described in Office of the Attorney General.

Where it meets other rules

The LAD sits beside other state and federal laws, and an event can fall under several. A worker who is not paid overtime has a wage claim, covered in wage and hour complaints and workers' compensation, and a worker who is fired after taking leave may have a claim under the Family Leave Act or the LAD, or both. A tenant facing eviction because of a protected characteristic may raise discrimination as well as the good-cause rules described in The Anti-Eviction Act and good cause. The rules for renting in general are in Renting in New Jersey: Truth in Renting and tenant rights. Federal agencies, such as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and the Department of Housing and Urban Development, take complaints under federal law.

New Jerseyans from many backgrounds have used the law. The state's immigrant communities, discussed in Citizenship and new Americans in New Jersey, are protected whatever their status, and the division's attention to language and national origin discrimination fits a state with so many newcomers.

Three illustrations

The following are hypothetical, and they are meant to show how the law's categories work in practice, not to predict an outcome.

Say a woman applies for a job at a warehouse in Middlesex County and tells the interviewer she is eight months pregnant. The offer is withdrawn the next day, and the stated reason is "scheduling." The law treats pregnancy as part of sex discrimination, so she would have grounds to file a complaint about the withdrawn offer. Her 180 days would run from the day the offer was pulled.

Say a family with a child who uses a wheelchair asks a landlord in Camden County for permission to install a ramp at their own expense, and the landlord refuses. The LAD requires reasonable accommodations in housing for disabilities, and a refusal is the kind of dispute the division handles. The housing priority means the division's staff would look at it closely.

Say a customer at a restaurant in Hudson County is told, by a manager who hears him speaking Portuguese on the phone, that he is "not welcome here." Public accommodations are covered, and the division's guidance says that discrimination based on language, accent or national origin can violate the law.

In each case the first practical step is the same: write down what was said, by whom and when, and keep any written notice.

What to bring to a complaint

People who have gone through the process say the same thing: write it down early. A useful file includes a dated timeline of what happened, the names and positions of those involved, the text of any messages, emails or notices, pay stubs or lease documents, and the names of witnesses. If it happened at work, keep copies of any policy or handbook that applies. The division asks for dates because the deadline runs from them.

Mediation is also available in many cases. It can be faster than an investigation and allows the two sides to reach their own agreement, though participation is voluntary. The division's portal and fact sheets explain who can file and what each category covers.

The Division on Civil Rights is not a court and does not represent either party. It is a state agency charged with enforcing a statute, and its investigators serve the law, not the complainant or the employer. That is a different role from a lawyer's, and a person who wants advice on strategy, on whether to go to court or on damages should talk to one. The division's website, reached through the Attorney General's site at njoag.gov, carries the complaint portal, fact sheets on each protected category, and a list of frequently asked questions.

Related state government

Related guides

Latest on this topic