Blog
School ethics and the Commissioner's controversies docket
Two separate state processes hear school complaints: the School Ethics Commission for conduct, and the Commissioner for disputes under school law.
When a New Jersey school board votes on something that makes a neighborhood furious, the first instinct of an angry resident is to ask who they can complain to in Trenton. The honest answer is that it depends on what the complaint is about, because the Department of Education houses two very different complaint systems under the same roof, and they do not do the same job. One is about whether a school official behaved ethically. The other is about whether a school board or the state followed the law. A resident who files in the wrong place loses time, and in some cases a deadline. This is how the two work, who can use them and what they can and cannot do.
The School Ethics Commission: conduct
The School Ethics Commission was created under the School Ethics Act, which took effect on April 15, 1992 (N.J.S.A. 18A:12-21 and following sections). The act sets rules for the conduct of school officials, including conflicts of interest, and the Commission is the body that enforces them. It meets on the fourth Tuesday of every month except December. The Commission is housed in the Department of Education, and its decisions and public advisory opinions from January 1, 1997 onward are posted online; before that, only decisions finding a violation and recommending a penalty were published.
Two parts of the act matter most to a person thinking of filing.
- Prohibited acts. The act lists things a school official may not do, such as using their position to secure an unwarranted privilege or taking part in a matter in which they or a relative have a direct or indirect financial interest. A complaint under this part, which is cited as N.J.S.A. 18A:12-24, can name any school official.
- The Code of Ethics for School Board Members. A separate section, 18A:12-24.1, sets out a code of conduct that applies only to board members and charter school trustees. It covers things like keeping confidences, not acting on private promises and not trying to administer the schools instead of leaving it to the staff.
Who can file, and against whom
Anyone can file an ethics complaint, but the complainant must be an individual, not an organization. The people who can be named are school officials, a category that covers board members, charter school trustees and administrators, along with certain employees and officers of the New Jersey School Boards Association. Teachers, private school administrators and secretarial, clerical and maintenance staff cannot be named. The Commission does not decide whether a teacher behaved badly. That is a matter for the district and, in a certification case, for other state bodies.
The deadline and the contents
A complaint has to be filed within 180 days of when the complainant knew, or should have known, of the events that form the basis of the complaint. The complaint has to include the full name, address and contact information for each complainant and respondent; numbered paragraphs describing each alleged violation, with dates, the section of the act violated and the supporting facts; evidence; and a signed and certified statement from each complainant. It is filed by email to the Commission's address at the Department of Education or by mail to the department in Trenton, and a hard copy with exhibits is required for each respondent.
What happens next
The person complained about, the respondent, has 20 days from receiving the complaint to file a written statement that admits or denies each allegation and sets out defenses. Motions to dismiss are no longer accepted at that stage. The respondent personally signs and certifies the statement, even if an attorney prepared it. If the respondent claims the complaint is frivolous, meaning it was filed in bad faith or without a reasonable legal basis, the complainant has 20 days to answer that claim.
The Commission then votes on whether there is probable cause. If not, the complaint is dismissed. If there is, the matter may be kept for a hearing, decided summarily if the material facts are not in dispute, or sent to the Office of Administrative Law if the facts are contested. The Commission can recommend a penalty: reprimand, censure, suspension or removal. It does not impose the penalty. The Commissioner of Education does, and the parties can file exceptions with the Commissioner. A finding of violation can be appealed to the Commissioner, and a finding of no probable cause is a final decision that can be appealed to the Appellate Division of the Superior Court. Complaints are confidential until a final decision, although the Commission cannot force the parties to stay quiet.
What the Commission will not do
The Commission cannot overturn a board's action. If a board has voted for something illegal, the Commission cannot undo the vote. It also does not hear complaints under the Open Public Meetings Act. The department's complaint page says that County Prosecutors enforce that act, which is why a resident who thinks a board violated the sunshine law should look at a different channel. how to attend and speak at a public meeting explains what the public is entitled to see and say.
The Commissioner's docket: disputes under school law
The second system is older and broader. Under the state's school laws, the Commissioner of Education hears and decides controversies and disputes arising under those laws. The unit that handles them is called the Office of Controversies and Disputes, and its work is formally begun by a petition of appeal. The kinds of disputes that arrive there are varied: a parent challenging a district's residency determination for a child, a board member contesting a removal, a community challenging a district's decision to close a school or to change a school's boundaries, a charter school disputing a decision. If something has been done by a school board or the Department that a person believes violates the school laws, the docket is the place to take it.
The process has a short clock. Petitions generally must be filed within 90 days of the decision being challenged, and decisions from past years show the Commissioner dismissing cases that arrived late. Disputed facts are typically tried before an administrative law judge in the Office of Administrative Law, who issues an initial decision, and the Commissioner then issues the final one. The Commissioner's decisions are published on the department's site, generally with the prior month's decisions added in the first two weeks of the next month, and they are appealable. Decisions are cited as slip opinions. The department's site keeps the State Board of Education's decisions from January 1997 through June 30, 2008, the last before the law letting people appeal a Commissioner's decision to the State Board was repealed. Since then, appeals go to the Appellate Division.
A hypothetical timeline
Say a resident learns on March 1 that a board member voted to award a district contract to a company owned by the board member's brother. The resident has 180 days from the date they knew, or should have known, to file, so the last day is around August 28. Suppose the complaint is filed on April 15, with the numbered allegations, the contract as evidence and a signed certification. Staff review it for deficiencies, and then it is served. The board member has 20 days to answer. A few weeks later the Commission, meeting on a fourth Tuesday, votes on probable cause. If the facts are not in dispute, the Commission can decide the case on the papers and recommend a penalty, which the Commissioner then imposes or modifies. If the facts are contested, the case goes to an administrative law judge first, and months more go by. At no point in this process does the contract itself get canceled. That would be a separate step, taken through the board, the courts or the Commissioner's docket, which shows why the two systems often run side by side in a single dispute.
The example is made up, but the order of steps follows the department's published procedure. The lesson is simple: write down dates, keep documents and check the clock before anything else.
Which door is yours?
| If the complaint is about... | The place to go |
|---|---|
| A board member using the job for personal benefit, or acting against the Code of Ethics | School Ethics Commission |
| An administrator with a conflict of interest | School Ethics Commission |
| A board vote you think violated school law | Petition to the Commissioner (Controversies and Disputes) |
| A teacher's employment or tenure dispute | Separate employment and tenure procedures, not the Ethics Commission; the county office or an attorney can point the way |
| A closed meeting or inadequate notice | The Open Public Meetings Act channel; the County Prosecutor or the Superior Court |
| A request for records | The Open Public Records Act channel; see An OPRA request from start to finish |
| A question about how a rule works | The county office of education |
The last row is the least glamorous and the most useful. The county superintendent's office is where many disputes get resolved before they become petitions, as the county superintendent and the school district system explains. A call to that office is free, fast and often enough.
Why these systems exist
The ethics law came out of a period in the 1990s when the state wanted a clear set of rules for the thousands of local officials who sit on school boards, almost all of them volunteers with other jobs and many with relatives in the school system. A town with one big employer, one family in the cafeteria and a board of nine neighbors is a place where conflicts of interest are always close at hand. The Commission is the neutral body that decides when a close call crosses the line. The controversies docket, by contrast, is much older. New Jersey's school laws date back generations, and the idea that the state's commissioner, not the courts, is the first place to settle school disputes is built into the system.
Neither process is a quick fix. Ethics complaints can take months, and a petition to the Commissioner can take longer when facts are disputed. Both reward careful drafting and punish missed deadlines. If you are considering one, the department's pages explain the forms, the Commission's decisions show how past complaints turned out, and an attorney can explain the stakes in your individual case. The department's main page is linked from New Jersey Department of Education.