Blog

Route 9 or the Parkway: two ways down the shore

The Garden State Parkway's 172 miles against old Route 9, which parallels it from Toms River to Cape May: speed, tolls, lights, towns and when to take each.

Two roads run down the Jersey Shore, and they look at each other across the pines the whole way. One is the Garden State Parkway, a tolled, limited-access highway built in the 1950s to move cars from the northern suburbs to the beach. The other is U.S. Route 9, which was there first, runs through the town centers and does everything the Parkway does not. For anyone driving the length of the shore, from Toms River to Cape May, the choice between them is the whole trip.

The short answer is that the Parkway is faster and Route 9 is more interesting, and the longer answer depends on the day, the season and what you want out of the drive. This is the comparison.

The Parkway: 172 miles of controlled access

The Garden State Parkway runs about 172 miles, from Exit 0 at Route 109 in Lower Township, Cape May County, to the New York state line at Montvale, and it carries an unsigned state designation, Route 444. It was built between 1946 and 1957 to link North Jersey with the shore. It was planned as a toll-free "Route 4 Parkway," but a lack of money led the state to charge tolls, and the first section opened on June 29, 1950, with the first tolled segment opening on January 13, 1954. The New Jersey Highway Authority that built it was merged into the New Jersey Turnpike Authority in 2003.

On the Parkway, the driving is easy and the speed limit is mostly 65 miles an hour, dropping to 55 in some sections. There are no traffic lights and no cross traffic. It has 11 toll plazas, collecting by cash or E-ZPass, and 11 service areas for fuel and food. It passes west of Atlantic City, through the Pine Barrens, past Toms River, across the Raritan River on the Driscoll Bridge, which is as many as 15 lanes wide, and into the dense suburbs of Middlesex, Union, Essex and Bergen counties. In the south, in Cape May, Atlantic and Bergen counties, it narrows to four lanes. Commercial trucks over 10,000 pounds are barred north of Exit 105, which is why the northern Parkway is a car road. Tolls rise by 3 percent a year under a plan set in 2020, and the E-ZPass and tolls guide explains how the plazas work. The Turnpike and Parkway driving guide and the end-to-end Parkway article go into more detail.

The Parkway's design is also its limit. A road built for 1950s traffic and widened many times is a victim of its own success. On a summer Friday, the southbound lanes are full from the Driscoll Bridge down, and the toll plazas are where the lines form.

Route 9: the old road

U.S. Route 9 is 166.8 miles long in New Jersey, and it has been in the state since 1926, when it was first signed from Absecon to Alpine. The southern end is the Cape May-Lewes Ferry terminal in North Cape May, where the road continues across Delaware Bay by ferry to Lewes, Delaware, an extension made in 1974. The northern end is the approach to the George Washington Bridge in Fort Lee. In between, it is two roads in one.

From North Cape May to Toms River, Route 9 is mostly a two-lane undivided road that runs near the shore and closely follows the Parkway. It goes through the county seat of Cape May Court House and through Rio Grande, Somers Point, Pleasantville, Absecon, Tuckerton, Manahawkin, Beachwood and Berkeley Township. In many places, it is a main street: stoplights, strip malls, diners, roadside farm stands and the occasional small-town traffic jam.

North of Toms River, the road turns northwest, away from the coast, toward Lakewood, and becomes a multilane divided suburban highway, a commuter artery through Monmouth and Middlesex counties, with jughandles and traffic-light-controlled crossings, especially in Monmouth, Middlesex and Union counties.

Where the two roads meet

The roads are not separate. Route 9 shares the Parkway's roadway in several places: at Somers Point, across the Mullica River, and at Toms River. On the shared stretch of the Mullica River, there are no tolls. The Great Egg Harbor Bridge, which carries the Parkway across the bay near Somers Point, also carries Route 9 now: when the old Beesley's Point Bridge closed in 2004 and was demolished in 2013, U.S. 9 was moved onto the Parkway's bridge. Southbound drivers on both routes pay a toll at the Little Egg plaza.

In other words, a driver who follows Route 9 faithfully will end up on the Parkway a few times, and the transitions are easy to miss. Watch the signs.

Why two roads exist

The two routes are two generations of the same idea. Route 9 is the old coastal highway, part of the national numbered system from the 1920s, and it grew out of the stagecoach and turnpike roads that connected the towns of the Jersey coast long before anyone drove to the beach for a weekend. It was built to serve those towns, and it still does. When the Parkway was planned after World War II, the state's aim was different: not to serve the towns but to bypass them, to give the growing suburbs of North Jersey a fast, safe, landscaped road to the shore.

The Parkway succeeded so well that it changed the shore. The towns that had been quiet fishing and farming communities became summer resorts and then year-round suburbs, and Route 9, once the main road, became the local one. Some stretches of Route 9 were realigned in 1954 and after, as the Parkway was built beside them, to keep the two roads from competing. In a few places, as at the Great Egg Harbor and Mullica crossings, they merged. In that sense, the two roads are less rivals than a system: the Parkway for distance, Route 9 for access.

What each costs

The Parkway costs money. Its tolls are collected at plazas along the road, and they have risen by 3 percent each year under a plan set in 2020. E-ZPass users pay less than cash customers at the plazas, and the E-ZPass guide explains how to open an account. Route 9 costs time. A trip down the length of the shore that takes a certain time on the Parkway in light traffic can take far longer on Route 9, and the difference grows with each town and each stoplight. Which is the better bargain depends on how you value an hour against a toll.

Fuel is a small factor, though stop-and-go driving burns more gas than steady highway speeds. A bigger factor is stress: the Parkway demands attention at high speed and in heavy traffic, and Route 9 demands patience.

Side by side

Garden State Parkway U.S. Route 9
Road type Limited-access toll road Mix of two-lane main street and divided highway
Length in New Jersey About 172 miles About 166.8 miles
Speed limit Mostly 65 mph, 55 in places Lower, with changes by town
Traffic lights None Many, especially in the north and in town centers
Tolls Cash or E-ZPass at 11 plazas None, except where it shares the Parkway
Gas and food 11 service areas Everywhere, in town
Trucks Barred over 10,000 pounds north of Exit 105 Allowed
Best for Getting there Getting somewhere on the way

A road trip in two routes

A good way to see the shore is to use both roads, taking the Parkway for the long stretches and Route 9 for the towns worth stopping in. Here is a sample trip from north to south.

Toms River. Start in the Ocean County seat, a township of 95,438 people in the 2020 census, where Route 9 turns away from the water. The Toms River profile gives the context. From here, Route 9 and the Parkway run side by side toward the Mullica.

Manahawkin and Tuckerton. Route 9 passes the causeway to Long Beach Island at Manahawkin. If you have time, turn onto Route 72 and drive the causeway to the island, which is covered in a separate article. Further south, Tuckerton is a small bayside town near the Mullica's estuary.

The Mullica crossing. Where the two roads share a roadway over the river, you are on the edge of Wharton State Forest, and the Pine Barrens are on both sides. The shared stretch has no toll.

Absecon and Atlantic City. Route 9 passes through Absecon, close to Atlantic City, whose lighthouse and boardwalk are a short detour east. The day in Atlantic City explains what is there.

Somers Point and the Great Egg Harbor Bridge. Here the Parkway's bridge carries both roads over the bay, with a view of the back-bay marshes.

Cape May Court House and Rio Grande. Cape May Court House is the Cape May County seat, and Rio Grande lies just beyond it. Past them, the road runs south through marsh and woods to the end of the line.

North Cape May and Cape May. Route 9 ends at the ferry terminal, and the Parkway ends at Exit 0. Cape May is a few minutes beyond, and a weekend in Cape May is a good way to end the trip.

Which one to take

A few rules of thumb.

  • If you are in a hurry, take the Parkway. Fewer lights, a higher speed limit and no town traffic make it the efficient route. The toll is small compared to the time saved on a summer weekend.
  • If you have time and want to see the shore, take Route 9 for the stretch south of Toms River, and stop in the towns.
  • If you are driving on a summer Friday or Sunday, expect delays on both. The Parkway backs up at the plazas and on the bridges, and Route 9 backs up at every stoplight. Leaving early or late is the only real fix.
  • If you have a truck or a trailer, check the rules. Trucks over 10,000 pounds are barred from the Parkway north of Exit 105.
  • If the weather is bad, the Parkway is easier to drive, but a nor'easter can close low sections of either road, and bridges over the bays close in high wind. The 511NJ site and the NJDOT page show closures.

For the real-time picture, check 511NJ, the state's travel information site, before you leave, and the Turnpike Authority's pages for Parkway conditions. Both roads cross the same marshes and the same pines. One does it in a straight line at 65 miles an hour, and the other does it in a long, slow series of towns. A good trip uses both.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic