Blog

How restaurant inspections work in New Jersey

Who inspects New Jersey restaurants, what the three placard ratings mean, how a failed inspection plays out and how to get a record through OPRA.

The placard in a restaurant window is the most visible piece of public health law most people ever read, and most people read it in a second. It says Satisfactory, Conditionally Satisfactory or Unsatisfactory. Behind those three words is a state code, a network of local health departments and a rule that the findings are public. This is how it works, from who writes the rules to how a diner can get the full report.

Two levels: the state writes the code, the town enforces it

Restaurant sanitation in New Jersey is set at the state level and enforced locally. The rulebook is Chapter 24 of the New Jersey Sanitary Code, N.J.A.C. 8:24, titled the sanitation in retail food establishments rules. The Department of Health writes and interprets it. The code defines a "health authority" as a local board of health with jurisdiction, or the Department itself. In practice the inspector who walks into a restaurant works for a municipal health department, a regional health commission or a county health department, depending on where the restaurant is.

That structure explains why inspection practice looks different from place to place even though the rules are uniform. The Department can issue interpretations of the code, and the code says local health authorities must treat them as statements of statewide policy, which is how uniformity is kept. But staffing, inspection schedules, online reporting and local fees are matters of the local agency. Some county and municipal health departments publish ratings online, some post a list of recent inspections, and some answer by request.

For the larger picture of how the Department fits in state government, see New Jersey Department of Health.

Sorting by risk

Not every food business gets the same attention, because the code sorts them by how much risk the food they handle carries.

  • Risk Type 1. Establishments that sell packaged, non-hazardous food, prepare only non-hazardous foods or only reheat commercially processed foods. The code's own examples include convenience stores, hot dog carts and coffee shops.
  • Risk Type 2. A limited menu, cooked and served mostly to order, with hot and cold holding after cooking. Retail food stores and quick-service operations often fall here.
  • Risk Type 3. An extensive menu, handling raw ingredients, with complex preparation that includes cooking, cooling and reheating several hazardous foods. Full-service restaurants, diners and caterers are the code's examples, and so are hospitals, nursing homes and preschools that serve highly susceptible people.
  • Risk Type 4. Specialized processes, such as smoking, curing, canning, bottling or reduced-oxygen packaging, where a trained food technologist may be needed.

The higher the risk, the more demanding the standard. By the code, at least one person in charge in every Risk Type 3 establishment must be a certified food protection manager, someone who has passed an accredited food safety exam and keeps the certificate current. And before a new establishment is built or an old one is converted, the operator must submit plans and specifications to the health authority for review and approval.

What an inspection is

An inspector can walk in during normal operations. The code says operators must give the health authority access to every part of the establishment and let it examine records of food purchases and employees. The inspector can sample food, forbid the sale of food suspected of being unwholesome or contaminated, and forbid the use of equipment that has not been properly sanitized.

At the end, the findings are written on an inspection report form. The form describes violations in narrative form and cites the section of the code each one breaks. A copy goes to the owner or the person in charge. And, immediately after the inspection, the health authority issues an evaluation placard.

The three ratings

The code defines the placard categories precisely.

  1. Satisfactory. The establishment is operating in substantial compliance with the chapter, and food service personnel have shown that they know and practice sanitation and food safety principles.
  2. Conditionally Satisfactory. At the time of the inspection the establishment was not in substantial compliance and was in violation of one or more provisions. A reinspection is scheduled. The reinspection is unannounced, it is a full inspection, and it happens within a reasonable time determined by the nature of the violation.
  3. Unsatisfactory. The establishment is operating in violation with one or more conditions that amount to gross insanitary or unsafe conditions and pose an imminent health hazard. The health authority asks the person in charge to stop operating voluntarily until a reinspection shows the problem is fixed, and it may use other legal measures, including embargo, condemnation and injunctive relief, to make sure no food is prepared or served until the place is reevaluated.

The word "conditionally" is easy to misread. A Conditionally Satisfactory rating is not a pass with a footnote. It means the inspector found violations serious enough that the establishment was not in substantial compliance, and the place will be inspected again, unannounced.

The placard has to be posted

The operator of every retail food establishment must post the placard from the most recent evaluation immediately, in a conspicuous place near the public entrance, where the public can view it. The operator must also keep the most recent inspection report on the premises for the public to review on request, and keep reports for at least two years. Records that the health authority holds must be available to the public on request.

That last rule is the reason a diner can ask for the full picture. The placard gives the grade, and the report gives the reasons.

Beyond the placard: closures and penalties

Inspection findings are only part of the enforcement power. The code lets the health authority order a restaurant closed when it suspects the place is a source of foodborne infection and the owner does not act at once. The closure order must offer a hearing within a reasonable time, not more than 15 days while the order stays in effect. A health authority that suspects an employee carries a food-borne disease can order that person to leave and stay away until cleared. Any person who violates the chapter or refuses a lawful order can face penalties under the state's public health statutes or an injunction.

A worked example

Say a diner in a town health department's jurisdiction is inspected on a Tuesday, and the inspector finds a walk-in cooler holding food above the temperature the code allows and a hand sink blocked by equipment. The restaurant is Risk Type 3, with a full menu. The inspector records the violations on the report, cites the sections, and issues a Conditionally Satisfactory placard. The operator posts it by the front door. Within a reasonable time, set by the nature of the violations, the inspector returns without warning and does a full inspection. If the cooler and the sink are fixed and nothing else has gone wrong, the placard changes to Satisfactory. If instead the inspector finds an imminent hazard, such as sewage backing up in the kitchen, the rating would be Unsatisfactory and the restaurant would be asked to stop operating until the hazard is gone.

This is a hypothetical, not a record of any restaurant, but the sequence follows the code.

How to get the record

There are three routes, from fastest to most formal.

  1. Look at the placard and ask to see the report. The operator must keep the latest report on site and make it available to the public.
  2. Check the local health department's website. Many county and municipal health departments publish inspection results online. Search the health agency for the town or county where the restaurant sits, not the state.
  3. File an OPRA request. Inspection records held by the health authority are government records. Under the Open Public Records Act, the custodian must respond as soon as possible, and within seven business days. A request should name the establishment, the dates and the records wanted. How to file an OPRA request walks through the process, and An OPRA request from start to finish follows a request from filing to answer.

A requester who is denied can file with the Government Records Council or go to court. The GRC's information line is 866-850-0511, and its site is nj.gov/grc.

When the placard changes hands

The placard belongs to the evaluation, not to the building. If a restaurant is reinspected and the rating changes, the new placard replaces the old one, and the code requires the operator to post the most recent evaluation. A visitor who sees a Conditionally Satisfactory placard is therefore looking at a rating that was current as of the last visit, and a reinspection may already have replaced it. Asking the staff, or checking the health department's list, settles it.

What the rating does not tell you

A single inspection is a snapshot. It reflects what an inspector saw on one day, and a clean report is not a guarantee about every other day. The reverse is also true: a Conditionally Satisfactory placard is a fact about one day, and the follow-up inspection is the better indicator of whether the problem was fixed. Reading a few consecutive reports, where available, says more than any one grade.

Placards also apply to retail food establishments broadly, not only restaurants. Supermarkets, delis, school cafeterias and catering kitchens are inspected under the same chapter, and food stalls at markets and festivals operate as temporary establishments with their own rules. food halls of the state looks at how the rules apply when a dozen kitchens share a room, and farmers markets by season covers the exceptions that apply to home bakers at farmers markets.

For local examples of cities with dense restaurant scenes, see Newark and Paterson.

Related state government

Related guides

Related towns and regions

Latest on this topic