Blog

The Civil Service Commission and state jobs

How New Jersey's Civil Service Commission posts jobs, runs exams and keeps lists for state, county and municipal titles, and how to read a job announcement.

A person who wants to work for the State of New Jersey, or for a county or a town, quickly runs into a body most residents never think about: the Civil Service Commission. Its job is to make sure that hiring for a large share of public jobs happens through a visible, written process, with announced titles, stated qualifications and tests, rather than through who knows whom. It is one of the oldest ideas in American government, and in New Jersey it still decides how thousands of people are hired and promoted.

The commission's pages are at nj.gov/csc, and its job announcements, examination schedule and application system are all there. This is a guide to how the system works and how to read what it posts.

What civil service is for

The merit system answers a particular problem. Before civil service laws, public jobs were commonly handed out by political patronage, and a change of mayor or governor could mean a wholesale change of employees. Civil service replaced that with rules: positions are given titles and descriptions, applicants must meet published qualifications, people compete in examinations or are rated on their experience, and those who pass are ranked on lists from which appointments are made. Once hired, a permanent employee has protections against being dismissed without cause, and the process for discipline and appeal is defined.

New Jersey's statute, the Civil Service Act, is in Title 11A of the state's laws, and the commission's rules are in Title 4A of the Administrative Code. See How New Jersey state agencies write rules for how rules like those are written.

State, county and municipal jurisdictions

Civil service in New Jersey covers three levels of government, and the distinction matters when reading a posting. State government departments are in the system. Counties and municipalities are in it if they have chosen to be, and the commission's announcements are labeled by the jurisdiction that is hiring. Some towns and counties are civil service jurisdictions, and others are not, and a resident who wants to know which applies to a local government can ask the municipal clerk or the commission. See County government for how counties are organized.

Not every public job is in the system either. The commission's career service includes both competitive and noncompetitive titles. Competitive titles are filled through examinations or other formal selection. Noncompetitive titles are positions where an examination is not practical, and they are filled on the basis of qualifications. Another category, the unclassified service, covers positions that are outside the merit system by law, such as those filled by appointment to serve at the pleasure of an official. Public bodies with their own personnel systems, such as the State's public universities and the bi-state Port Authority, hire through their own career pages.

The job announcement

The commission posts announcements on its web site on weekdays, as soon as a need is identified. Most are open for 21 calendar days. For some titles, in particular those in public safety such as police and fire, announcements are distributed more widely and kept open longer.

There are two basic kinds:

  • Open competitive. It invites the public to compete for vacancies in state, county or municipal titles. Anyone who meets the minimum qualifications may apply.
  • Promotional. It notifies permanent government employees of current or anticipated vacancies and is limited to people already working in the relevant government service, whether a particular department, a county or a municipality. Promotional announcements reward experience and give employees a path upward.

The administrative code requires an announcement to say the examination title, the salary, the minimum qualifications and how to file. For open competitive announcements, it must describe the duties, and for state announcements, say where the vacancy is. Applications are due by 4 p.m. on the closing date unless the commission has set a different time. A person who files at 4:05 p.m. is late, and the lateness is not generally forgiven.

How to read one

Here is a worked example of an announcement's logic. Say a county posts an open competitive announcement for a hypothetical title of "Clerk 2." The notice will give the title, a closing date three weeks away, a salary range, and minimum requirements, which are usually some combination of education and experience. It will tell the applicant which examination, if any, is involved: a written test, an evaluation of education and experience, or some mix. It will state how veterans' preference works, where the law grants it. An applicant who does not meet the minimum qualifications by the closing date cannot take the exam, and the commission can reject an application that does not show them.

The details that cause the most trouble are small ones:

  1. The closing date and time. Count from the posting, and file early.
  2. Residency. Some local announcements have a residency requirement or a preference. The notice says if it does.
  3. Experience that counts. The announcement defines what kind of work qualifies. Time spent in a different kind of job may not count, however valuable.
  4. The examination type. An exam can be written, oral, a performance test or an evaluation of the record. It is stated in the announcement.
  5. Where the job is. For a state job, the work location is stated, and it matters for commuting from a state with as many choices as New Jersey.

From exam to appointment

After an examination, the commission scores the results and prepares an eligible list, with candidates ranked. When a government wants to fill a vacancy, it asks the commission to certify the list. In general, the law lets the appointing authority choose among a small number of the highest-ranked candidates who are willing to take the job, a practice called the rule of three. A candidate who is not chosen remains on the list for its life, which is set when the list is created and can run for a period of years, so a good score can be useful for more than one opening.

Jobs can also be filled provisionally when no list exists. A provisional appointee is typically required to take the exam when it is next given, and a person who does well may be appointed permanent. The details of working test periods, how long a probation lasts and how layoffs and seniority are handled are in the commission's rules and the contracts that cover the employees.

Looking up a title

A visitor to the commission's pages can look up what a title means. Each title has a job specification: a description of the work, the knowledge and skills expected and the minimum requirements. Reading the specification is a good way to understand what a state or local job actually involves, since the titles can be unfamiliar: a "Technical Assistant" may be a clerical post or a skilled one, depending on the level. The salary range for a state title is published with its announcement and with the state's salary tables. The commission also publishes a test schedule, so a person can plan which examinations will come up, and a roadmap of the application process.

Police, fire and the longer exams

Public safety titles follow a heavier version of the same process. A police officer or firefighter in a civil service municipality is generally hired through an open competitive announcement that stays open longer than the usual three weeks and is publicized widely, since a town wants a large pool of applicants. Candidates take a written examination, and those who pass go through further steps, such as physical testing, background checks, medical and psychological screening, before an appointment. The commission's public safety pages list the announcements, and the individual municipality or county handles the later hiring steps. Promotion to sergeant, captain or battalion chief is by promotional announcement, open only to those already serving.

Because each step has its own timeline, a person who applies for a public safety job should expect a long wait between the exam and an appointment. A list may be established months after the test, and a town may not have an opening on the day the list is certified.

Questions to ask before applying

A few questions save time. Is the job in a civil service jurisdiction, or does the town hire on its own? Is the announcement open competitive or promotional? Does the title have a residency requirement? When is the exam, and is a list likely to exist soon? What does the specification say the work really is? Each of these can be answered from the announcement, the specification or a call to the commission or the hiring office, and none of them takes more than a few minutes.

It is also worth knowing that the commission is not the only door. The state's departments, the Legislature, the court system, public colleges and authorities such as NJ Transit all post openings on their own career pages, and each has its own process. The commission's lists are the main route for the departments and the local governments that use the merit system.

What this means for job seekers

For anyone considering a public career in New Jersey, the commission's site is the place to start, and a few habits help:

  • Create an account in the commission's online application system, and keep the profile current.
  • Check announcements regularly. They are posted weekdays, and a title that is open now may not be again for some time.
  • Keep records that prove qualifications: transcripts, certificates, licenses, and job descriptions from past employers.
  • Read the minimum qualifications before you apply, and apply in time.
  • Look at both state and local jurisdictions. A county or a town in a civil service jurisdiction may post the same kind of work as a state department, with different pay and a different commute.

Public employment is a major part of the state's economy. For a broader look at where the work is, see The largest employers: Amazon, RWJBarnabas and Wakefern and where the jobs are: pharma, finance, logistics and health. For the employee who is already in a government job and trying to move up, the promotional announcement is the main tool. It tells them what vacancies are coming and what they need to compete.

A system that explains itself

The best feature of civil service, from a resident's point of view, is that it writes itself down. A job's title, its pay range, the qualifications, the examination and the closing date all appear in a public notice. If a hiring decision looks wrong, there is a paper trail to follow, and there are appeals. The process can seem slow compared with a private employer's. But it is slow in the way that a public process is meant to be: in the open, with the rules posted in advance.

Related state government

Latest on this topic